Contextual Bandits with Packing and Covering Constraints: A Modular Lagrangian Approach via Regression

Read original: arXiv:2211.07484 - Published 7/2/2024 by Aleksandrs Slivkins, Xingyu Zhou, Karthik Abinav Sankararaman, Dylan J. Foster

↗️

Overview

The paper introduces a variant of contextual bandits called "Contextual Bandits with Linear Constraints" (CBwLC)
In CBwLC, the algorithm must consume multiple resources subject to linear constraints on total consumption
This problem generalizes "Contextual Bandits with Knapsacks" (CBwK), allowing for packing and covering constraints, as well as positive and negative resource consumption
The paper presents the first algorithm for CBwLC (or CBwK) that is based on regression oracles
The algorithm is simple, computationally efficient, and statistically optimal under mild assumptions
The paper also provides the first vanishing-regret guarantees for CBwLC (or CBwK) that extend beyond the stochastic environment

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on a type of decision-making problem called "contextual bandits," where an algorithm must choose actions (e.g., recommendations, treatments) based on the current context (e.g., user characteristics, patient history). The researchers introduce a more complex version of this problem, called "Contextual Bandits with Linear Constraints" (CBwLC), where the algorithm must manage multiple resources (e.g., memory, budget) while making these decisions.

In CBwLC, the algorithm has to ensure that the total consumption of these resources stays within certain limits, described by linear constraints. This generalizes an earlier problem called "Contextual Bandits with Knapsacks" (CBwK), allowing for more flexibility in the types of constraints and resource consumption patterns.

The key contribution of the paper is an algorithm that can solve the CBwLC (or CBwK) problem effectively. Unlike previous approaches, this algorithm is based on "regression oracles," which are machine learning models that can predict the resource consumption and reward for different actions. The algorithm is designed to be simple, efficient, and statistically optimal under reasonable assumptions.

Importantly, the paper also provides stronger theoretical guarantees on the algorithm's performance, showing that it can achieve "vanishing regret" - meaning that its decisions will get increasingly close to the optimal choices over time. This is a significant advancement, as prior work had faced strong limitations in this regard.

The paper's insights could be valuable for a wide range of applications, such as link to "Batched Nonparametric Contextual Bandits", link to "Optimal Regret for Locally Private Linear Contextual Bandit", link to "No Regret Is Not Enough: Bandits with General Utility", link to "Generalized Linear Bandits with Limited Adaptivity", and link to "Causal Contextual Bandits and Adaptive Context Selection", where managing limited resources is a key challenge.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces the "Contextual Bandits with Linear Constraints" (CBwLC) problem, which generalizes the "Contextual Bandits with Knapsacks" (CBwK) problem. In CBwLC, the algorithm must choose actions (e.g., recommendations, treatments) based on the current context (e.g., user characteristics, patient history) while managing the consumption of multiple resources (e.g., memory, budget) subject to linear constraints on the total consumption.

The researchers present a new algorithm for solving the CBwLC (or CBwK) problem, which is based on "regression oracles" - machine learning models that can predict the resource consumption and reward for different actions. The algorithm is designed to be simple, computationally efficient, and statistically optimal under mild assumptions.

The key technical insights behind the algorithm are:

Leveraging the modularity of the "LagrangeBwK" (Immorlica et al., FOCS 2019) and "SquareCB" (Foster and Rakhlin, ICML 2020) techniques to combine them effectively.
Identifying a weaker (and arguably fairer) benchmark to compare against, which allows the algorithm to achieve stronger theoretical guarantees.

The paper provides the first vanishing-regret guarantees for CBwLC (or CBwK) that extend beyond the stochastic environment, addressing limitations of prior work.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes several important contributions, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

Assumptions and Practical Applicability: The paper's theoretical guarantees rely on certain assumptions, such as the linearity of resource consumption and the availability of accurate regression oracles. It would be valuable to explore the algorithm's performance under more realistic, noisy, or adversarial conditions.
Scalability and Efficiency: While the algorithm is designed to be computationally efficient, the paper does not provide extensive empirical evaluations or comparisons to alternative approaches. Assessing the algorithm's scalability and real-world performance would be an important next step.
Interpretation and Explainability: The use of regression oracles may limit the interpretability of the algorithm's decision-making process. Exploring ways to enhance the explainability of the algorithm's choices could improve its adoption and trust in practical applications.
Broader Contextual Bandit Challenges: The paper's focus on the CBwLC problem is an important contribution, but there are many other aspects of contextual bandits that warrant further investigation, such as link to "Causal Contextual Bandits and Adaptive Context Selection", link to "Generalized Linear Bandits with Limited Adaptivity", and link to "No Regret Is Not Enough: Bandits with General Utility".

Overall, the paper presents a valuable advancement in the field of contextual bandits, but continued research and practical evaluations will be important to fully realize the potential of these techniques.

Conclusion

The paper introduces a novel variant of contextual bandits called "Contextual Bandits with Linear Constraints" (CBwLC), which generalizes the "Contextual Bandits with Knapsacks" (CBwK) problem. The researchers present a simple, computationally efficient, and statistically optimal algorithm for solving the CBwLC (or CBwK) problem, based on regression oracles.

Importantly, the paper also provides the first vanishing-regret guarantees for CBwLC (or CBwK) that extend beyond the stochastic environment, addressing limitations of prior work. These insights could have significant implications for a wide range of applications where managing limited resources is a key challenge, such as link to "Batched Nonparametric Contextual Bandits", link to "Optimal Regret for Locally Private Linear Contextual Bandit", and link to "Generalized Linear Bandits with Limited Adaptivity".

While the paper makes valuable contributions, there are areas for further research, such as exploring the algorithm's performance under more realistic conditions, assessing its scalability and efficiency, and enhancing the interpretability of its decision-making process. Continued advancements in this field could lead to more robust and impactful applications of contextual bandits in the real world.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

↗️

Contextual Bandits with Packing and Covering Constraints: A Modular Lagrangian Approach via Regression

Aleksandrs Slivkins, Xingyu Zhou, Karthik Abinav Sankararaman, Dylan J. Foster

We consider contextual bandits with linear constraints (CBwLC), a variant of contextual bandits in which the algorithm consumes multiple resources subject to linear constraints on total consumption. This problem generalizes contextual bandits with knapsacks (CBwK), allowing for packing and covering constraints, as well as positive and negative resource consumption. We provide the first algorithm for CBwLC (or CBwK) that is based on regression oracles. The algorithm is simple, computationally efficient, and statistically optimal under mild assumptions. Further, we provide the first vanishing-regret guarantees for CBwLC (or CBwK) that extend beyond the stochastic environment. We side-step strong impossibility results from prior work by identifying a weaker (and, arguably, fairer) benchmark to compare against. Our algorithm builds on LagrangeBwK (Immorlica et al., FOCS 2019), a Lagrangian-based technique for CBwK, and SquareCB (Foster and Rakhlin, ICML 2020), a regression-based technique for contextual bandits. Our analysis leverages the inherent modularity of both techniques.

7/2/2024

Batched Nonparametric Contextual Bandits

Rong Jiang, Cong Ma

We study nonparametric contextual bandits under batch constraints, where the expected reward for each action is modeled as a smooth function of covariates, and the policy updates are made at the end of each batch of observations. We establish a minimax regret lower bound for this setting and propose a novel batch learning algorithm that achieves the optimal regret (up to logarithmic factors). In essence, our procedure dynamically splits the covariate space into smaller bins, carefully aligning their widths with the batch size. Our theoretical results suggest that for nonparametric contextual bandits, a nearly constant number of policy updates can attain optimal regret in the fully online setting.

6/12/2024

Contextual Bandits for Unbounded Context Distributions

Puning Zhao, Jiafei Wu, Zhe Liu, Huiwen Wu

Nonparametric contextual bandit is an important model of sequential decision making problems. Under $alpha$-Tsybakov margin condition, existing research has established a regret bound of $tilde{O}left(T^{1-frac{alpha+1}{d+2}}right)$ for bounded supports. However, the optimal regret with unbounded contexts has not been analyzed. The challenge of solving contextual bandit problems with unbounded support is to achieve both exploration-exploitation tradeoff and bias-variance tradeoff simultaneously. In this paper, we solve the nonparametric contextual bandit problem with unbounded contexts. We propose two nearest neighbor methods combined with UCB exploration. The first method uses a fixed $k$. Our analysis shows that this method achieves minimax optimal regret under a weak margin condition and relatively light-tailed context distributions. The second method uses adaptive $k$. By a proper data-driven selection of $k$, this method achieves an expected regret of $tilde{O}left(T^{1-frac{(alpha+1)beta}{alpha+(d+2)beta}}+T^{1-beta}right)$, in which $beta$ is a parameter describing the tail strength. This bound matches the minimax lower bound up to logarithm factors, indicating that the second method is approximately optimal.

8/20/2024

On the Optimal Regret of Locally Private Linear Contextual Bandit

Jiachun Li, David Simchi-Levi, Yining Wang

Contextual bandit with linear reward functions is among one of the most extensively studied models in bandit and online learning research. Recently, there has been increasing interest in designing emph{locally private} linear contextual bandit algorithms, where sensitive information contained in contexts and rewards is protected against leakage to the general public. While the classical linear contextual bandit algorithm admits cumulative regret upper bounds of $tilde O(sqrt{T})$ via multiple alternative methods, it has remained open whether such regret bounds are attainable in the presence of local privacy constraints, with the state-of-the-art result being $tilde O(T^{3/4})$. In this paper, we show that it is indeed possible to achieve an $tilde O(sqrt{T})$ regret upper bound for locally private linear contextual bandit. Our solution relies on several new algorithmic and analytical ideas, such as the analysis of mean absolute deviation errors and layered principal component regression in order to achieve small mean absolute deviation errors.

4/16/2024