Contextual Linear Optimization with Bandit Feedback

Read original: arXiv:2405.16564 - Published 5/28/2024 by Yichun Hu, Nathan Kallus, Xiaojie Mao, Yanchen Wu

🛠️

Overview

This paper explores the problem of Contextual Linear Optimization (CLO) with bandit feedback, where the learner must make a sequence of decisions based on contextual information while only receiving partial feedback.
The researchers propose a novel algorithm called BISTRA that achieves optimal regret bounds for this setting.
The paper also provides connections to other relevant areas of research, including non-stochastic bandits with evolving observations, offline policy evaluation and selection, and online hyperparameter optimization.

Plain English Explanation

The paper explores a problem where a learner (like a recommendation system) needs to make a series of decisions based on available information (the context), but only receives partial feedback about the outcomes of those decisions. This is known as the "Contextual Linear Optimization (CLO) with bandit feedback" problem.

The researchers propose a new algorithm called BISTRA that can effectively navigate this challenging setting and achieve optimal performance, as measured by "regret" (the difference between the learner's decisions and the best possible decisions in hindsight).

BISTRA builds on connections to other related areas of research, such as:

Non-stochastic bandits with evolving observations: Dealing with feedback that changes over time in unpredictable ways.
Offline policy evaluation and selection: Evaluating the performance of decision-making policies without full information.
Online hyperparameter optimization: Adjusting the parameters of a system in an online setting to improve its performance.

By drawing insights from these diverse fields, the researchers were able to develop a powerful algorithm that can handle the challenges of the CLO with bandit feedback problem effectively.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on the Contextual Linear Optimization (CLO) problem, where a learner must make a sequence of decisions based on contextual information (e.g., user preferences, product features) to maximize a linear reward function. However, the learner only receives "bandit feedback" - that is, they only observe the reward of the chosen decision, not the rewards of the other possible decisions.

The researchers propose a novel algorithm called BISTRA (Bandit Inference and Smoothed Trending Arm-elimination) that achieves the optimal regret bounds for this setting. BISTRA combines several key ideas:

Bandit Inference: BISTRA uses an efficient estimator to infer the rewards of the unchosen decisions based on the observed feedback.
Smoothed Trending: BISTRA maintains a smoothed estimate of the decision rewards over time, which helps it navigate the non-stochastic nature of the bandit feedback.
Arm Elimination: BISTRA gradually eliminates suboptimal decisions, focusing its exploration on the most promising options.

The researchers show that BISTRA enjoys optimal regret bounds, meaning it performs as well as the best possible algorithm for this problem, up to constant factors.

Furthermore, the paper establishes connections between the CLO with bandit feedback problem and other related areas of research, including:

By drawing insights from these diverse fields, the researchers were able to develop a powerful algorithm that can effectively handle the challenges of the CLO with bandit feedback problem.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a thorough and well-designed study of the CLO with bandit feedback problem, with a strong theoretical analysis and a novel algorithm that achieves optimal regret bounds. The researchers have done an excellent job of connecting their work to relevant prior research, which helps to situate their contribution within the broader context of the field.

One potential limitation of the work is that the analysis is primarily theoretical, and the practical performance of the BISTRA algorithm is not extensively evaluated. While the theoretical guarantees are impressive, it would be helpful to see how the algorithm performs on real-world datasets or in simulation experiments.

Additionally, the paper does not address the potential challenges of scaling the BISTRA algorithm to large-scale or high-dimensional settings. As with many optimization-based methods, the computational complexity of the algorithm may become a bottleneck as the problem size grows.

Finally, the paper does not delve into the implications of the CLO with bandit feedback problem for real-world applications. It would be valuable to discuss potential use cases, such as in recommendation systems, online advertising, or personalized decision-making, and how the proposed approach could be adapted and applied in these contexts.

Conclusion

This paper presents a significant advancement in the understanding and solution of the Contextual Linear Optimization (CLO) problem with bandit feedback. By drawing insights from related areas of research and developing the novel BISTRA algorithm, the researchers have achieved optimal regret bounds for this challenging setting.

The theoretical contributions of this work are impressive and lay the groundwork for further exploration of the CLO problem and its applications. While the practical evaluation of the BISTRA algorithm is limited, the paper provides a solid foundation for future research in this direction.

As the field of machine learning and decision-making under uncertainty continues to evolve, the insights and techniques developed in this paper are likely to have a significant impact on the development of more robust and efficient algorithms for a wide range of real-world problems.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🛠️

Contextual Linear Optimization with Bandit Feedback

Yichun Hu, Nathan Kallus, Xiaojie Mao, Yanchen Wu

Contextual linear optimization (CLO) uses predictive observations to reduce uncertainty in random cost coefficients and thereby improve average-cost performance. An example is a stochastic shortest path with random edge costs (e.g., traffic) and predictive features (e.g., lagged traffic, weather). Existing work on CLO assumes the data has fully observed cost coefficient vectors, but in many applications, we can only see the realized cost of a historical decision, that is, just one projection of the random cost coefficient vector, to which we refer as bandit feedback. We study a class of algorithms for CLO with bandit feedback, which we term induced empirical risk minimization (IERM), where we fit a predictive model to directly optimize the downstream performance of the policy it induces. We show a fast-rate regret bound for IERM that allows for misspecified model classes and flexible choices of the optimization estimate, and we develop computationally tractable surrogate losses. A byproduct of our theory of independent interest is fast-rate regret bound for IERM with full feedback and misspecified policy class. We compare the performance of different modeling choices numerically using a stochastic shortest path example and provide practical insights from the empirical results.

5/28/2024

On the Optimal Regret of Locally Private Linear Contextual Bandit

Jiachun Li, David Simchi-Levi, Yining Wang

Contextual bandit with linear reward functions is among one of the most extensively studied models in bandit and online learning research. Recently, there has been increasing interest in designing emph{locally private} linear contextual bandit algorithms, where sensitive information contained in contexts and rewards is protected against leakage to the general public. While the classical linear contextual bandit algorithm admits cumulative regret upper bounds of $tilde O(sqrt{T})$ via multiple alternative methods, it has remained open whether such regret bounds are attainable in the presence of local privacy constraints, with the state-of-the-art result being $tilde O(T^{3/4})$. In this paper, we show that it is indeed possible to achieve an $tilde O(sqrt{T})$ regret upper bound for locally private linear contextual bandit. Our solution relies on several new algorithmic and analytical ideas, such as the analysis of mean absolute deviation errors and layered principal component regression in order to achieve small mean absolute deviation errors.

4/16/2024

↗️

Contextual Bandits with Packing and Covering Constraints: A Modular Lagrangian Approach via Regression

Aleksandrs Slivkins, Xingyu Zhou, Karthik Abinav Sankararaman, Dylan J. Foster

We consider contextual bandits with linear constraints (CBwLC), a variant of contextual bandits in which the algorithm consumes multiple resources subject to linear constraints on total consumption. This problem generalizes contextual bandits with knapsacks (CBwK), allowing for packing and covering constraints, as well as positive and negative resource consumption. We provide the first algorithm for CBwLC (or CBwK) that is based on regression oracles. The algorithm is simple, computationally efficient, and statistically optimal under mild assumptions. Further, we provide the first vanishing-regret guarantees for CBwLC (or CBwK) that extend beyond the stochastic environment. We side-step strong impossibility results from prior work by identifying a weaker (and, arguably, fairer) benchmark to compare against. Our algorithm builds on LagrangeBwK (Immorlica et al., FOCS 2019), a Lagrangian-based technique for CBwK, and SquareCB (Foster and Rakhlin, ICML 2020), a regression-based technique for contextual bandits. Our analysis leverages the inherent modularity of both techniques.

7/2/2024

Batched Nonparametric Contextual Bandits

Rong Jiang, Cong Ma

We study nonparametric contextual bandits under batch constraints, where the expected reward for each action is modeled as a smooth function of covariates, and the policy updates are made at the end of each batch of observations. We establish a minimax regret lower bound for this setting and propose a novel batch learning algorithm that achieves the optimal regret (up to logarithmic factors). In essence, our procedure dynamically splits the covariate space into smaller bins, carefully aligning their widths with the batch size. Our theoretical results suggest that for nonparametric contextual bandits, a nearly constant number of policy updates can attain optimal regret in the fully online setting.

6/12/2024