Data-driven Conditional Instrumental Variables for Debiasing Recommender Systems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a novel approach called Data-driven Conditional Instrumental Variables (DCIV) to debias recommender systems.
- DCIV leverages data-driven conditional instrumental variables to correct for biases in user-item interactions.
- The method can be used to improve the fairness and accuracy of recommendations without requiring explicit knowledge of the data-generating process.
Plain English Explanation
In recommender systems, users' choices and interactions with items can be influenced by various biases, such as the popularity of certain items or the user's own preferences. These biases can lead to skewed recommendations that do not accurately reflect users' true interests or preferences.
The Data-driven Conditional Instrumental Variables (DCIV) approach aims to address this issue by using data-driven conditional instrumental variables to correct for these biases. Instrumental variables are factors that are related to the user-item interactions but not directly influenced by the biases, allowing the researchers to isolate the true relationship between the user and the item.
By leveraging these conditional instrumental variables, the DCIV method can improve the fairness and accuracy of recommendations without requiring explicit knowledge of the data-generating process. This is particularly useful in real-world scenarios where the underlying biases may be complex and difficult to model directly.
Technical Explanation
The DCIV method works by first identifying conditional instrumental variables from the data, which are variables that are correlated with the user-item interactions but not directly influenced by the biases. These conditional instrumental variables are then used to estimate the unbiased relationship between the user and the item, allowing the researchers to generate recommendations that better reflect the user's true preferences.
The key steps of the DCIV method include:
- Identifying conditional instrumental variables using data-driven techniques.
- Estimating the unbiased relationship between the user and the item using the identified conditional instrumental variables.
- Generating recommendations based on the corrected, unbiased relationship.
The paper also includes experimental evaluations that demonstrate the effectiveness of the DCIV method in improving the fairness and accuracy of recommendations compared to traditional approaches.
Critical Analysis
The DCIV method offers a promising approach to debiasing recommender systems, but it also has some limitations and potential concerns:
-
Dependence on Conditional Instrumental Variables: The effectiveness of the DCIV method relies on the ability to identify suitable conditional instrumental variables from the data. In some cases, it may be challenging to find variables that are strongly correlated with the user-item interactions but not influenced by the biases.
-
Generalization Across Domains: The paper focuses on evaluating the DCIV method in the context of recommender systems, but it is unclear how well the approach would generalize to other domains where bias correction is necessary.
-
Interpretability and Explainability: While the DCIV method aims to improve the fairness and accuracy of recommendations, the underlying process may not be easily interpretable or explainable to users, which could limit its adoption in certain applications.
-
Potential for Unintended Consequences: As with any bias correction technique, there is a possibility of introducing new biases or unintended consequences that could negatively impact the user experience or fairness of the system.
Conclusion
The Data-driven Conditional Instrumental Variables (DCIV) approach represents a promising step towards debiasing recommender systems and improving the fairness and accuracy of recommendations. By leveraging data-driven conditional instrumental variables, the method can correct for complex biases without requiring explicit knowledge of the data-generating process. While the approach has some limitations and potential concerns, it offers a valuable contribution to the field of responsible and ethical recommender system design.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Data-driven Conditional Instrumental Variables for Debiasing Recommender Systems
Zhirong Huang, Shichao Zhang, Debo Cheng, Jiuyong Li, Lin Liu, Guangquan Lu
In recommender systems, latent variables can cause user-item interaction data to deviate from true user preferences. This biased data is then used to train recommendation models, further amplifying the bias and ultimately compromising both recommendation accuracy and user satisfaction. Instrumental Variable (IV) methods are effective tools for addressing the confounding bias introduced by latent variables; however, identifying a valid IV is often challenging. To overcome this issue, we propose a novel data-driven conditional IV (CIV) debiasing method for recommender systems, called CIV4Rec. CIV4Rec automatically generates valid CIVs and their corresponding conditioning sets directly from interaction data, significantly reducing the complexity of IV selection while effectively mitigating the confounding bias caused by latent variables in recommender systems. Specifically, CIV4Rec leverages a variational autoencoder (VAE) to generate the representations of the CIV and its conditional set from interaction data, followed by the application of least squares to derive causal representations for click prediction. Extensive experiments on two real-world datasets, Movielens-10M and Douban-Movie, demonstrate that our CIV4Rec successfully identifies valid CIVs, effectively reduces bias, and consequently improves recommendation accuracy.
Read more8/20/2024
0
Learning Decision Policies with Instrumental Variables through Double Machine Learning
Daqian Shao, Ashkan Soleymani, Francesco Quinzan, Marta Kwiatkowska
A common issue in learning decision-making policies in data-rich settings is spurious correlations in the offline dataset, which can be caused by hidden confounders. Instrumental variable (IV) regression, which utilises a key unconfounded variable known as the instrument, is a standard technique for learning causal relationships between confounded action, outcome, and context variables. Most recent IV regression algorithms use a two-stage approach, where a deep neural network (DNN) estimator learnt in the first stage is directly plugged into the second stage, in which another DNN is used to estimate the causal effect. Naively plugging the estimator can cause heavy bias in the second stage, especially when regularisation bias is present in the first stage estimator. We propose DML-IV, a non-linear IV regression method that reduces the bias in two-stage IV regressions and effectively learns high-performing policies. We derive a novel learning objective to reduce bias and design the DML-IV algorithm following the double/debiased machine learning (DML) framework. The learnt DML-IV estimator has strong convergence rate and $O(N^{-1/2})$ suboptimality guarantees that match those when the dataset is unconfounded. DML-IV outperforms state-of-the-art IV regression methods on IV regression benchmarks and learns high-performing policies in the presence of instruments.
Read more7/1/2024
0
Geometry-Aware Instrumental Variable Regression
Heiner Kremer, Bernhard Scholkopf
Instrumental variable (IV) regression can be approached through its formulation in terms of conditional moment restrictions (CMR). Building on variants of the generalized method of moments, most CMR estimators are implicitly based on approximating the population data distribution via reweightings of the empirical sample. While for large sample sizes, in the independent identically distributed (IID) setting, reweightings can provide sufficient flexibility, they might fail to capture the relevant information in presence of corrupted data or data prone to adversarial attacks. To address these shortcomings, we propose the Sinkhorn Method of Moments, an optimal transport-based IV estimator that takes into account the geometry of the data manifold through data-derivative information. We provide a simple plug-and-play implementation of our method that performs on par with related estimators in standard settings but improves robustness against data corruption and adversarial attacks.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Bounding Causal Effects with Leaky Instruments
David S. Watson, Jordan Penn, Lee M. Gunderson, Gecia Bravo-Hermsdorff, Afsaneh Mastouri, Ricardo Silva
Instrumental variables (IVs) are a popular and powerful tool for estimating causal effects in the presence of unobserved confounding. However, classical approaches rely on strong assumptions such as the $textit{exclusion criterion}$, which states that instrumental effects must be entirely mediated by treatments. This assumption often fails in practice. When IV methods are improperly applied to data that do not meet the exclusion criterion, estimated causal effects may be badly biased. In this work, we propose a novel solution that provides $textit{partial}$ identification in linear systems given a set of $textit{leaky instruments}$, which are allowed to violate the exclusion criterion to some limited degree. We derive a convex optimization objective that provides provably sharp bounds on the average treatment effect under some common forms of information leakage, and implement inference procedures to quantify the uncertainty of resulting estimates. We demonstrate our method in a set of experiments with simulated data, where it performs favorably against the state of the art. An accompanying $texttt{R}$ package, $texttt{leakyIV}$, is available from $texttt{CRAN}$.
Read more5/9/2024