Diffusion-ES: Gradient-free Planning with Diffusion for Autonomous Driving and Zero-Shot Instruction Following

Overview

• Diffusion models excel at modeling complex and multimodal trajectory distributions for decision-making and control
• Reward-gradient guided denoising has been proposed to generate trajectories that maximize both a differentiable reward function and the likelihood under the data distribution captured by a diffusion model
• This method has limitations as it requires a differentiable reward function fitted to both clean and noised samples
• The paper proposes DiffusionES, a method that combines gradient-free optimization with trajectory denoising to optimize black-box non-differentiable objectives while staying in the data manifold

Plain English Explanation

Diffusion models are a type of AI system that can capture the complexity and diversity of real-world trajectory data, like the paths a self-driving car might take. This makes them useful for decision-making and control tasks.

Previous work has tried to use diffusion models to generate trajectories that not only match the patterns in the training data, but also maximize a reward function - a mathematical way of describing how "good" the trajectory is. However, this approach has limitations because it requires the reward function to be differentiable, meaning it needs to be a smooth, continuous function that can be easily optimized.

In this paper, the researchers propose a new method called DiffusionES that overcomes this limitation. DiffusionES combines gradient-free optimization (a way of searching for good solutions without relying on gradients or derivatives) with a process called "trajectory denoising" (removing noise from the generated trajectories to keep them realistic). This allows DiffusionES to optimize non-differentiable, "black-box" reward functions - functions that may be complex, discontinuous, or even unknown.

The key idea is to sample candidate trajectories from a diffusion model, score them using a black-box reward function, and then "mutate" the high-scoring trajectories using a truncated diffusion process (applying a small number of noising and denoising steps). This allows for efficient exploration of the solution space without wandering too far from the data manifold (the set of realistic trajectories).

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces DiffusionES, a method that combines gradient-free optimization with trajectory denoising to optimize black-box non-differentiable objectives while staying in the data manifold.

The key steps of DiffusionES are:

1. Sample candidate trajectories from a pre-trained diffusion model, which can capture the complex and multimodal distribution of real-world trajectories.
2. Score the sampled trajectories using a black-box reward function, which may be non-differentiable and difficult to optimize.
3. "Mutate" the high-scoring trajectories by applying a truncated diffusion process - a small number of noising and denoising steps. This allows for efficient exploration of the solution space while keeping the trajectories close to the data manifold.

The researchers show that DiffusionES achieves state-of-the-art performance on the nuPlan benchmark for autonomous driving, outperforming existing sampling-based planners, reactive deterministic or diffusion-based policies, and reward-gradient guidance methods.

Additionally, the paper demonstrates that DiffusionES can optimize non-differentiable language-shaped reward functions generated by few-shot prompting of large language models (LLMs). This allows the method to generate novel, highly complex behaviors, such as aggressive lane weaving, that are not present in the training data, solving the hardest nuPlan scenarios.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to trajectory optimization using diffusion models and gradient-free optimization. The key strength of DiffusionES is its ability to handle non-differentiable, black-box reward functions, which greatly expands the types of objectives that can be optimized.

However, the paper does not address some potential limitations and areas for further research:

• Scalability: The performance of DiffusionES on the nuPlan benchmark is impressive, but it's unclear how well the method would scale to more complex, high-dimensional trajectory optimization problems.
• Interpretability: As with many deep learning-based methods, the inner workings of DiffusionES may be difficult to interpret, which can be a concern for safety-critical applications like autonomous driving.
• Robustness: The paper does not explore the sensitivity of DiffusionES to factors like noisy or incomplete reward functions, or its ability to generalize to unseen environments or task variations.

Further research could investigate ways to address these limitations, such as exploring physics-informed diffusion models or tuning-free alignment techniques to improve scalability and interpretability.

Conclusion

The proposed DiffusionES method represents an important advance in trajectory optimization, enabling the use of complex, non-differentiable reward functions while maintaining realism and diversity in the generated trajectories. This flexibility opens up new possibilities for applications like autonomous driving, where desired behaviors may be difficult to capture in a simple, differentiable objective function.

The strong performance on the nuPlan benchmark and the ability to optimize language-shaped rewards suggest that DiffusionES could be a valuable tool for solving challenging decision-making and control problems. As the field of diffusion models continues to evolve, further research on scalability, interpretability, and robustness will be key to unlocking the full potential of this approach.