DISentangled Counterfactual Visual interpretER (DISCOVER) generalizes to natural images
0
🌿
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The researchers presented a method called DISCOVER (DISentangled COunterfactual Visual interpretER) for systematically interpreting the visual traits that image classification models use to make decisions.
- DISCOVER was demonstrated on two biomedical domains, and the researchers now show that it can also be applied to natural images like facial photographs of dogs and cats.
- The visual interpretations produced by DISCOVER for these natural images reveal insights about the key facial features that distinguish dogs from cats, as well as the important characteristics for distinguishing different human faces.
- These results suggest that DISCOVER is a generalized interpretability method that can be applied across various image domains.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers developed a tool called DISCOVER that can help us understand how image classification models make their decisions. This is important because these models are increasingly being used in high-stakes applications like healthcare, but it's not always clear what visual traits they are focusing on to make their predictions.
With DISCOVER, the researchers were able to visually interpret the key features that a model uses to distinguish between images of dogs and cats. They found that the model was focusing on things like the size of the nose, the shape of the muzzle, and the overall size of the face. For human faces, DISCOVER highlighted characteristics like the cheeks and jawline, the eyebrows and hair, and the eyes as being important discriminative features.
These insights from DISCOVER provide valuable transparency into how these image classification models work under the hood. By revealing the specific visual cues the models are utilizing, we can better understand their decision-making process and assess whether they are making judgments for the right reasons. This can help build trust in these models and ensure they are being used responsibly, especially in high-stakes domains like medical imaging.
Overall, the successful application of DISCOVER across both biomedical and natural image domains suggests it is a flexible and generalizable tool for interpreting the inner workings of image classification models. This type of model transparency is crucial as these technologies become more prevalent in our lives.
Technical Explanation
The DISCOVER method works by generating counterfactual images - slightly modified versions of the input image that would cause the model to change its prediction. By analyzing the differences between the original image and these counterfactual images, DISCOVER can identify the specific visual traits that the model is using to make its classification decision.
In this work, the researchers applied DISCOVER to image classification models trained to distinguish between facial photographs of dogs and cats, as well as models trained to classify different human faces. DISCOVER was able to visually interpret several key discriminative features for each task:
- For the dog vs. cat classification, DISCOVER highlighted the nose size, muzzle area, and overall face size as important visual traits.
- For human face classification, DISCOVER identified the cheeks and jawline, eyebrows and hair, and the eyes as the most discriminative facial characteristics.
These successful visual interpretations across both the dog/cat and human face domains demonstrate that DISCOVER is a generalizable technique that can be applied to a variety of image classification problems. This stands in contrast to more specialized interpretability methods that may be tailored to specific tasks or model architectures.
The ability of DISCOVER to uncover the black box of image classification models and reveal their underlying decision-making logic is a valuable contribution toward building more transparent and trustworthy AI systems - an important goal as these models become increasingly prevalent in high-stakes applications.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge some limitations of the DISCOVER method that could be addressed in future work. For example, the current implementation requires access to the model's internal parameters, which may not always be available in real-world deployment scenarios.
Additionally, while DISCOVER was able to identify discriminative visual traits, the method does not provide a way to quantify the relative importance of these traits or how they interact. Extending DISCOVER to provide more nuanced and granular insights into the model's decision-making process could further strengthen its interpretability capabilities.
It would also be valuable to assess DISCOVER's performance on a wider range of image classification tasks and model architectures to fully establish its generalizability. Comparisons to other interpretability techniques, both in terms of the insights generated and the computational overhead, could help position DISCOVER within the broader landscape of model explanation methods.
Overall, the successful application of DISCOVER to natural image domains is an encouraging step toward developing flexible and powerful tools for unveiling the inner workings of complex vision models. Continued research in this direction can help build greater trust and transparency in the use of AI for high-impact applications.
Conclusion
The DISCOVER method presented in this work offers a systematic approach for interpreting the visual traits that image classification models use to make their predictions. By generating counterfactual images and analyzing the differences, DISCOVER was able to uncover key discriminative features for distinguishing between facial images of dogs and cats, as well as for identifying different human faces.
These successful visual interpretations across both biomedical and natural image domains suggest that DISCOVER is a generalized interpretability technique that can be applied to a variety of image classification problems. This level of transparency into the inner workings of these models is crucial as they become more widely deployed, particularly in high-stakes applications where understanding and trusting the decision-making process is of utmost importance.
While DISCOVER has some limitations that could be addressed through future research, this work represents an important step forward in developing interpretable AI systems that can provide meaningful insights into their decision-making logic. Continued advancements in this area will help build greater trust and accountability in the use of machine learning for real-world, impactful applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌿
0
DISentangled Counterfactual Visual interpretER (DISCOVER) generalizes to natural images
Oded Rotem, Assaf Zaritsky
We recently presented DISentangled COunterfactual Visual interpretER (DISCOVER), a method toward systematic visual interpretability of image-based classification models and demonstrated its applicability to two biomedical domains. Here we demonstrate that DISCOVER can be applied to the domain of natural images. First, DISCOVER visually interpreted the nose size, the muzzle area, and the face size as semantic discriminative visual traits discriminating between facial images of dogs versus cats. Second, DISCOVER visually interpreted the cheeks and jawline, eyebrows and hair, and the eyes, as discriminative facial characteristics. These successful visual interpretations across two natural images domains indicate that DISCOVER is a generalized interpretability method.
Read more6/26/2024
0
DiG-IN: Diffusion Guidance for Investigating Networks -- Uncovering Classifier Differences, Neuron Visualisations, and Visual Counterfactual Explanations
Maximilian Augustin, Yannic Neuhaus, Matthias Hein
While deep learning has led to huge progress in complex image classification tasks like ImageNet, unexpected failure modes, e.g. via spurious features, call into question how reliably these classifiers work in the wild. Furthermore, for safety-critical tasks the black-box nature of their decisions is problematic, and explanations or at least methods which make decisions plausible are needed urgently. In this paper, we address these problems by generating images that optimize a classifier-derived objective using a framework for guided image generation. We analyze the decisions of image classifiers by visual counterfactual explanations (VCEs), detection of systematic mistakes by analyzing images where classifiers maximally disagree, and visualization of neurons and spurious features. In this way, we validate existing observations, e.g. the shape bias of adversarially robust models, as well as novel failure modes, e.g. systematic errors of zero-shot CLIP classifiers. Moreover, our VCEs outperform previous work while being more versatile.
Read more7/15/2024
🔮
0
DISCOVER: A Data-driven Interactive System for Comprehensive Observation, Visualization, and ExploRation of Human Behaviour
Dominik Schiller, Tobias Hallmen, Daksitha Withanage Don, Elisabeth Andr'e, Tobias Baur
Understanding human behavior is a fundamental goal of social sciences, yet its analysis presents significant challenges. Conventional methodologies employed for the study of behavior, characterized by labor-intensive data collection processes and intricate analyses, frequently hinder comprehensive exploration due to their time and resource demands. In response to these challenges, computational models have proven to be promising tools that help researchers analyze large amounts of data by automatically identifying important behavioral indicators, such as social signals. However, the widespread adoption of such state-of-the-art computational models is impeded by their inherent complexity and the substantial computational resources necessary to run them, thereby constraining accessibility for researchers without technical expertise and adequate equipment. To address these barriers, we introduce DISCOVER -- a modular and flexible, yet user-friendly software framework specifically developed to streamline computational-driven data exploration for human behavior analysis. Our primary objective is to democratize access to advanced computational methodologies, thereby enabling researchers across disciplines to engage in detailed behavioral analysis without the need for extensive technical proficiency. In this paper, we demonstrate the capabilities of DISCOVER using four exemplary data exploration workflows that build on each other: Interactive Semantic Content Exploration, Visual Inspection, Aided Annotation, and Multimodal Scene Search. By illustrating these workflows, we aim to emphasize the versatility and accessibility of DISCOVER as a comprehensive framework and propose a set of blueprints that can serve as a general starting point for exploratory data analysis.
Read more7/19/2024
0
See or Guess: Counterfactually Regularized Image Captioning
Qian Cao, Xu Chen, Ruihua Song, Xiting Wang, Xinting Huang, Yuchen Ren
Image captioning, which generates natural language descriptions of the visual information in an image, is a crucial task in vision-language research. Previous models have typically addressed this task by aligning the generative capabilities of machines with human intelligence through statistical fitting of existing datasets. While effective for normal images, they may struggle to accurately describe those where certain parts of the image are obscured or edited, unlike humans who excel in such cases. These weaknesses they exhibit, including hallucinations and limited interpretability, often hinder performance in scenarios with shifted association patterns. In this paper, we present a generic image captioning framework that employs causal inference to make existing models more capable of interventional tasks, and counterfactually explainable. Our approach includes two variants leveraging either total effect or natural direct effect. Integrating them into the training process enables models to handle counterfactual scenarios, increasing their generalizability. Extensive experiments on various datasets show that our method effectively reduces hallucinations and improves the model's faithfulness to images, demonstrating high portability across both small-scale and large-scale image-to-text models. The code is available at https://github.com/Aman-4-Real/See-or-Guess.
Read more9/2/2024