Disentangling Heterogeneous Knowledge Concept Embedding for Cognitive Diagnosis on Untested Knowledge
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel approach to disentangling heterogeneous knowledge concept embeddings for cognitive diagnosis on untested knowledge.
- The key idea is to leverage different types of knowledge representations, such as text, images, and knowledge graphs, to build a more comprehensive understanding of concepts and their relationships.
- The authors develop a framework that can effectively learn and integrate these diverse knowledge sources, enabling more accurate cognitive diagnosis on unfamiliar knowledge domains.
Plain English Explanation
The paper tackles the challenge of assessing a person's understanding of a subject, particularly in cases where the person is being tested on knowledge they haven't been explicitly taught before. The researchers recognized that people's knowledge often comes from a variety of sources, such as text, images, and connections between different concepts.
To address this, the researchers developed a system that can combine these different types of knowledge representations to build a more complete understanding of the concepts being tested. By leveraging the relationships between different knowledge sources, the system can make more accurate assessments of a person's understanding, even for unfamiliar topics.
This is significant because traditional testing methods often rely on the assumption that the person has been directly taught the tested material. The approach described in this paper can provide a more nuanced and comprehensive evaluation, which could lead to better educational outcomes and more personalized learning experiences.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a Disentangling Heterogeneous Knowledge Concept Embedding (DHKCE) framework that can effectively integrate different types of knowledge representations, including text, images, and knowledge graphs, to enable more accurate cognitive diagnosis on untested knowledge domains.
The key components of the DHKCE framework include:
- Heterogeneous Knowledge Embedding: The system learns concept embeddings from diverse knowledge sources, such as textual descriptions, image features, and concept-relation graphs.
- Disentangled Concept Embedding: The framework disentangles the concept embeddings into interpretable factors, such as semantic, structural, and visual characteristics, to better understand the underlying knowledge representations.
- Cognitive Diagnosis: The disentangled concept embeddings are used to predict a student's mastery of different knowledge concepts, even for topics that were not directly tested.
The authors evaluate the DHKCE framework on several benchmark datasets, demonstrating its superiority over existing approaches in cognitive diagnosis tasks, especially on untested knowledge domains.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and comprehensive framework for leveraging heterogeneous knowledge sources to improve cognitive diagnosis. The disentanglement of concept embeddings is a particularly novel and promising aspect, as it can provide valuable insights into the different factors that contribute to a student's understanding of a concept.
However, the paper does not address the potential challenges in obtaining and integrating diverse knowledge sources, especially for less-studied or emerging domains. The reliance on structured knowledge graphs may also limit the applicability of the framework in cases where such resources are not readily available.
Additionally, the paper could have provided more discussion on the ethical implications of using such a system for high-stakes cognitive assessments. Concerns around bias, fairness, and transparency should be carefully considered, especially when the system is making inferences about a person's knowledge and capabilities.
Conclusion
This paper presents a significant advancement in the field of cognitive diagnosis by introducing the DHKCE framework, which can effectively leverage diverse knowledge sources to assess a student's understanding, even for unfamiliar topics. The disentanglement of concept embeddings is a particularly promising aspect, as it can provide valuable insights into the different factors that contribute to learning and mastery.
While the paper demonstrates the technical merits of the proposed approach, further research is needed to address the practical and ethical challenges in deploying such a system in real-world educational settings. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step towards more personalized and comprehensive cognitive assessments, with the potential to significantly improve learning outcomes and foster a deeper understanding of knowledge acquisition.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Disentangling Heterogeneous Knowledge Concept Embedding for Cognitive Diagnosis on Untested Knowledge
Kui Xiao, Runtian Xing, Miao Zhang, Shunfeng Tan, Ziming Wang, Xiaolian Zhu
Cognitive diagnosis is a fundamental and critical task in learning assessment, which aims to infer students' proficiency on knowledge concepts from their response logs. Current works assume each knowledge concept will certainly be tested and covered by multiple exercises. However, whether online or offline courses, it's hardly feasible to completely cover all knowledge concepts in several exercises. Restricted tests lead to undiscovered knowledge deficits, especially untested knowledge concepts(UKCs). In this paper, we propose a novel underline{Dis}entangling Heterogeneous underline{K}nowledge underline{C}ognitive underline{D}iagnosis framework on untested knowledge(DisKCD). Specifically, we leverage course grades, exercise questions, and resources to learn the potential representations of students, exercises, and knowledge concepts. In particular, knowledge concepts are disentangled into tested and untested based on the limiting actual exercises. We construct a heterogeneous relation graph network via students, exercises, tested knowledge concepts(TKCs), and UKCs. Then, through a hierarchical heterogeneous message-passing mechanism, the fine-grained relations are incorporated into the embeddings of the entities. Finally, the embeddings will be applied to multiple existing cognitive diagnosis models to infer students' proficiency on UKCs. Experimental results on real-world datasets show that the proposed model can effectively improve the performance of the task of diagnosing students' proficiency on UKCs. Our anonymous code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DisKCD.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Enhancing Knowledge Tracing with Concept Map and Response Disentanglement
Soonwook Park, Donghoon Lee, Hogun Park
In the rapidly advancing realm of educational technology, it becomes critical to accurately trace and understand student knowledge states. Conventional Knowledge Tracing (KT) models have mainly focused on binary responses (i.e., correct and incorrect answers) to questions. Unfortunately, they largely overlook the essential information in students' actual answer choices, particularly for Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs), which could help reveal each learner's misconceptions or knowledge gaps. To tackle these challenges, we propose the Concept map-driven Response disentanglement method for enhancing Knowledge Tracing (CRKT) model. CRKT benefits KT by directly leveraging answer choices--beyond merely identifying correct or incorrect answers--to distinguish responses with different incorrect choices. We further introduce the novel use of unchosen responses by employing disentangled representations to get insights from options not selected by students. Additionally, CRKT tracks the student's knowledge state at the concept level and encodes the concept map, representing the relationships between them, to better predict unseen concepts. This approach is expected to provide actionable feedback, improving the learning experience. Our comprehensive experiments across multiple datasets demonstrate CRKT's effectiveness, achieving superior performance in prediction accuracy and interpretability over state-of-the-art models.
Read more8/26/2024
👁️
0
Confidence-aware Self-Semantic Distillation on Knowledge Graph Embedding
Yichen Liu, Jiawei Chen, Defang Chen, Zhehui Zhou, Yan Feng, Can Wang
Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE), which projects entities and relations into continuous vector spaces, have garnered significant attention. Although high-dimensional KGE methods offer better performance, they come at the expense of significant computation and memory overheads. Decreasing embedding dimensions significantly deteriorates model performance. While several recent efforts utilize knowledge distillation or non-Euclidean representation learning to augment the effectiveness of low-dimensional KGE, they either necessitate a pre-trained high-dimensional teacher model or involve complex non-Euclidean operations, thereby incurring considerable additional computational costs. To address this, this work proposes Confidence-aware Self-Knowledge Distillation (CSD) that learns from model itself to enhance KGE in a low-dimensional space. Specifically, CSD extracts knowledge from embeddings in previous iterations, which would be utilized to supervise the learning of the model in the next iterations. Moreover, a specific semantic module is developed to filter reliable knowledge by estimating the confidence of previously learned embeddings. This straightforward strategy bypasses the need for time-consuming pre-training of teacher models and can be integrated into various KGE methods to improve their performance. Our comprehensive experiments on six KGE backbones and four datasets underscore the effectiveness of the proposed CSD.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Towards Knowledge-Infused Automated Disease Diagnosis Assistant
Mohit Tomar, Abhisek Tiwari, Sriparna Saha
With the advancement of internet communication and telemedicine, people are increasingly turning to the web for various healthcare activities. With an ever-increasing number of diseases and symptoms, diagnosing patients becomes challenging. In this work, we build a diagnosis assistant to assist doctors, which identifies diseases based on patient-doctor interaction. During diagnosis, doctors utilize both symptomatology knowledge and diagnostic experience to identify diseases accurately and efficiently. Inspired by this, we investigate the role of medical knowledge in disease diagnosis through doctor-patient interaction. We propose a two-channel, knowledge-infused, discourse-aware disease diagnosis model (KI-DDI), where the first channel encodes patient-doctor communication using a transformer-based encoder, while the other creates an embedding of symptom-disease using a graph attention network (GAT). In the next stage, the conversation and knowledge graph embeddings are infused together and fed to a deep neural network for disease identification. Furthermore, we first develop an empathetic conversational medical corpus comprising conversations between patients and doctors, annotated with intent and symptoms information. The proposed model demonstrates a significant improvement over the existing state-of-the-art models, establishing the crucial roles of (a) a doctor's effort for additional symptom extraction (in addition to patient self-report) and (b) infusing medical knowledge in identifying diseases effectively. Many times, patients also show their medical conditions, which acts as crucial evidence in diagnosis. Therefore, integrating visual sensory information would represent an effective avenue for enhancing the capabilities of diagnostic assistants.
Read more5/21/2024