The Effective Horizon Explains Deep RL Performance in Stochastic Environments
0
🤿
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper aims to explain why deep reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms often perform well in practice, despite using random exploration and more expressive function classes like neural networks.
- The authors introduce a new RL algorithm called SQIRL that separates the exploration and learning components of RL, making it easier to analyze.
- SQIRL iteratively learns a near-optimal policy by exploring randomly and then performing a limited number of steps of fitted-Q iteration over the collected rollouts.
- The authors leverage SQIRL to derive instance-dependent sample complexity bounds for RL and find that SQIRL's performance correlates strongly with that of popular deep RL algorithms like PPO and DQN.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores why deep reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms often work well in practice, even though they use random exploration and more complex neural network models. The authors introduce a new RL algorithm called SQIRL that separates the exploration and learning parts of the process. SQIRL first collects random rollouts (sequences of actions and observations) and then uses a limited number of steps of a learning technique called fitted-Q iteration to extract a near-optimal policy from those rollouts. The authors show that this approach can work well for many types of RL problems because neural networks are good at generalizing in-distribution, and random exploration can be sufficient to find a good solution. The authors also use SQIRL to derive sample complexity bounds that are better than previous RL theory, and they find that SQIRL's performance matches the performance of popular deep RL algorithms like PPO and DQN in various stochastic environments.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by noting that traditional RL theory has focused on proving minimax sample complexity bounds, which require strategic exploration algorithms that use relatively limited function classes. The authors' goal is to explain why deep RL algorithms often perform well in practice despite using random exploration and more expressive function classes like neural networks.
The key insight is that many stochastic Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) can be solved by performing only a few steps of value iteration on the random policy's Q function and then acting greedily. When this is the case, the authors show that it is possible to separate the exploration and learning components of RL, making it much easier to analyze.
The authors introduce a new RL algorithm, SQIRL, that iteratively learns a near-optimal policy by exploring randomly to collect rollouts and then performing a limited number of steps of fitted-Q iteration over those rollouts. The authors prove that any regression algorithm that satisfies basic in-distribution generalization properties can be used in SQIRL to efficiently solve common MDPs. This aligns with the empirical observation that neural networks generalize well in-distribution.
Furthermore, the authors leverage SQIRL to derive instance-dependent sample complexity bounds for RL that are exponential only in an effective horizon of lookahead and on the complexity of the class used for function approximation. This represents an improvement over previous RL theory, which had more pessimistic bounds.
Empirically, the authors find that SQIRL's performance strongly correlates with that of PPO and DQN in a variety of stochastic environments, supporting the idea that their theoretical analysis is predictive of practical performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling explanation for why deep RL algorithms often perform well in practice, despite theoretical challenges. The authors' key insight about the ability to separate exploration and learning in certain MDPs is an important contribution that could help advance RL theory.
However, the paper does not address potential limitations or caveats of the SQIRL algorithm. For example, it is unclear how SQIRL would perform in environments with sparse or deceptive rewards, where random exploration may struggle to find the optimal solution. Additionally, the authors do not discuss the computational efficiency of SQIRL compared to other RL algorithms, which could be an important practical consideration.
Furthermore, the paper's theoretical analysis relies on certain assumptions, such as the ability to perform a limited number of value iteration steps and the existence of function approximators that satisfy in-distribution generalization properties. It would be valuable for the authors to discuss the validity of these assumptions and their potential impact on the broader applicability of the results.
Despite these limitations, the paper represents an important step forward in bridging the gap between RL theory and practice. By introducing SQIRL and deriving improved sample complexity bounds, the authors have provided a framework for better understanding the success of deep RL algorithms in the real world.
Conclusion
This paper offers a promising explanation for the empirical success of deep reinforcement learning algorithms, despite their theoretical challenges. By introducing the SQIRL algorithm, which separates exploration and learning, the authors demonstrate that many stochastic MDPs can be efficiently solved using random exploration and simple function approximation methods.
The authors' key insights - that neural networks can generalize well in-distribution and that limited value iteration can be sufficient to find near-optimal policies - provide a compelling rationale for the effectiveness of deep RL in practice. Furthermore, the improved sample complexity bounds derived using SQIRL represent an important advancement in RL theory.
While the paper does not address all potential limitations of the SQIRL approach, it offers a significant step forward in bridging the gap between RL theory and real-world applications. By providing a practical and theoretically grounded explanation for the success of deep RL, this work could inspire new directions for RL algorithm design and analysis, ultimately leading to more robust and efficient reinforcement learning systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
0
The Effective Horizon Explains Deep RL Performance in Stochastic Environments
Cassidy Laidlaw, Banghua Zhu, Stuart Russell, Anca Dragan
Reinforcement learning (RL) theory has largely focused on proving minimax sample complexity bounds. These require strategic exploration algorithms that use relatively limited function classes for representing the policy or value function. Our goal is to explain why deep RL algorithms often perform well in practice, despite using random exploration and much more expressive function classes like neural networks. Our work arrives at an explanation by showing that many stochastic MDPs can be solved by performing only a few steps of value iteration on the random policy's Q function and then acting greedily. When this is true, we find that it is possible to separate the exploration and learning components of RL, making it much easier to analyze. We introduce a new RL algorithm, SQIRL, that iteratively learns a near-optimal policy by exploring randomly to collect rollouts and then performing a limited number of steps of fitted-Q iteration over those rollouts. Any regression algorithm that satisfies basic in-distribution generalization properties can be used in SQIRL to efficiently solve common MDPs. This can explain why deep RL works, since it is empirically established that neural networks generalize well in-distribution. Furthermore, SQIRL explains why random exploration works well in practice. We leverage SQIRL to derive instance-dependent sample complexity bounds for RL that are exponential only in an effective horizon of lookahead and on the complexity of the class used for function approximation. Empirically, we also find that SQIRL performance strongly correlates with PPO and DQN performance in a variety of stochastic environments, supporting that our theoretical analysis is predictive of practical performance. Our code and data are available at https://github.com/cassidylaidlaw/effective-horizon.
Read more4/16/2024
0
Efficient Exploration in Deep Reinforcement Learning: A Novel Bayesian Actor-Critic Algorithm
Nikolai Rozanov
Reinforcement learning (RL) and Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL), in particular, have the potential to disrupt and are already changing the way we interact with the world. One of the key indicators of their applicability is their ability to scale and work in real-world scenarios, that is in large-scale problems. This scale can be achieved via a combination of factors, the algorithm's ability to make use of large amounts of data and computational resources and the efficient exploration of the environment for viable solutions (i.e. policies). In this work, we investigate and motivate some theoretical foundations for deep reinforcement learning. We start with exact dynamic programming and work our way up to stochastic approximations and stochastic approximations for a model-free scenario, which forms the theoretical basis of modern reinforcement learning. We present an overview of this highly varied and rapidly changing field from the perspective of Approximate Dynamic Programming. We then focus our study on the short-comings with respect to exploration of the cornerstone approaches (i.e. DQN, DDQN, A2C) in deep reinforcement learning. On the theory side, our main contribution is the proposal of a novel Bayesian actor-critic algorithm. On the empirical side, we evaluate Bayesian exploration as well as actor-critic algorithms on standard benchmarks as well as state-of-the-art evaluation suites and show the benefits of both of these approaches over current state-of-the-art deep RL methods. We release all the implementations and provide a full python library that is easy to install and hopefully will serve the reinforcement learning community in a meaningful way, and provide a strong foundation for future work.
Read more8/20/2024
0
Stochastic Q-learning for Large Discrete Action Spaces
Fares Fourati, Vaneet Aggarwal, Mohamed-Slim Alouini
In complex environments with large discrete action spaces, effective decision-making is critical in reinforcement learning (RL). Despite the widespread use of value-based RL approaches like Q-learning, they come with a computational burden, necessitating the maximization of a value function over all actions in each iteration. This burden becomes particularly challenging when addressing large-scale problems and using deep neural networks as function approximators. In this paper, we present stochastic value-based RL approaches which, in each iteration, as opposed to optimizing over the entire set of $n$ actions, only consider a variable stochastic set of a sublinear number of actions, possibly as small as $mathcal{O}(log(n))$. The presented stochastic value-based RL methods include, among others, Stochastic Q-learning, StochDQN, and StochDDQN, all of which integrate this stochastic approach for both value-function updates and action selection. The theoretical convergence of Stochastic Q-learning is established, while an analysis of stochastic maximization is provided. Moreover, through empirical validation, we illustrate that the various proposed approaches outperform the baseline methods across diverse environments, including different control problems, achieving near-optimal average returns in significantly reduced time.
Read more5/17/2024
0
SHIRE: Enhancing Sample Efficiency using Human Intuition in REinforcement Learning
Amogh Joshi, Adarsh Kumar Kosta, Kaushik Roy
The ability of neural networks to perform robotic perception and control tasks such as depth and optical flow estimation, simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM), and automatic control has led to their widespread adoption in recent years. Deep Reinforcement Learning has been used extensively in these settings, as it does not have the unsustainable training costs associated with supervised learning. However, DeepRL suffers from poor sample efficiency, i.e., it requires a large number of environmental interactions to converge to an acceptable solution. Modern RL algorithms such as Deep Q Learning and Soft Actor-Critic attempt to remedy this shortcoming but can not provide the explainability required in applications such as autonomous robotics. Humans intuitively understand the long-time-horizon sequential tasks common in robotics. Properly using such intuition can make RL policies more explainable while enhancing their sample efficiency. In this work, we propose SHIRE, a novel framework for encoding human intuition using Probabilistic Graphical Models (PGMs) and using it in the Deep RL training pipeline to enhance sample efficiency. Our framework achieves 25-78% sample efficiency gains across the environments we evaluate at negligible overhead cost. Additionally, by teaching RL agents the encoded elementary behavior, SHIRE enhances policy explainability. A real-world demonstration further highlights the efficacy of policies trained using our framework.
Read more9/17/2024