Enhancing Group Fairness in Online Settings Using Oblique Decision Forests

Overview

• This paper addresses the challenge of achieving group fairness in online machine learning settings, where data arrives one instance at a time.
• The authors propose a novel ensemble model called Aranyani that can efficiently compute fairness gradients using aggregate statistics, eliminating the need for additional storage and forward/backward passes.
• Aranyani is an ensemble of oblique decision trees that allows for parameter isolation and faster fairness computations compared to traditional in-processing fairness techniques.
• The authors evaluate Aranyani on several public datasets and show it achieves a better accuracy-fairness trade-off than baseline approaches.

Plain English Explanation

When machine learning models are used to make decisions that impact people, it's important to ensure those decisions are fair, both for individual users and for different demographic groups. Fairness, especially group fairness, is an important consideration in the context of machine learning systems.

One way to make models more fair is to incorporate fairness objectives into the training process, such as demographic parity. However, when data arrives one instance at a time in an online setting, optimizing these fairness objectives becomes challenging. Estimating group fairness requires additional storage and computation that can slow down the training process.

To address this, the researchers developed a new model called Aranyani, which is an ensemble of decision trees. The tree structure of Aranyani allows the model to efficiently compute fairness gradients using aggregate statistics from previous decisions, without needing to store extra data or perform extra computation.

The authors tested Aranyani on several different datasets, including vision and language tasks, and found that it was able to achieve a better balance between accuracy and fairness compared to other approaches. Aranyani was able to make fair decisions in these online settings more effectively than baseline methods.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation in this paper is the Aranyani model, which is an ensemble of oblique decision trees designed for online settings where data arrives one instance at a time. Traditional in-processing fairness techniques, which optimize a combination of a fairness objective and a task-specific objective, face challenges in the online setting.

Specifically, group fairness objectives like demographic parity require estimating expectations of predictions across different demographic groups. In the online setting, this estimation requires additional storage and significantly more computation (e.g., forward/backward passes) at every time step compared to the task-specific objective alone.

Aranyani addresses this by leveraging the hierarchical tree structure to enable parameter isolation and efficient fairness gradient computation. The authors present an efficient training framework for Aranyani and provide theoretical analysis of its properties.

In their experiments, the researchers evaluate Aranyani on 5 publicly available benchmarks, including vision and language datasets. The results show that Aranyani achieves a better accuracy-fairness trade-off compared to baseline approaches like adversarial debiasing and optimized in-processing techniques.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a novel and promising approach to addressing group fairness in online machine learning settings. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of Aranyani through extensive experiments on diverse datasets.

One potential limitation is that the paper focuses on group fairness, while individual fairness is also an important consideration in many real-world applications. The authors acknowledge this, but do not provide a comprehensive solution for both group and individual fairness simultaneously.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the interpretability of the Aranyani model, which could be an important factor in certain applications where model decisions need to be explainable. Further research could investigate ways to enhance the interpretability of the Aranyani ensemble.

It would also be valuable to see how Aranyani performs in more complex, real-world scenarios with higher-dimensional data and a greater diversity of features and protected attributes. The current experiments, while comprehensive, may not fully capture the challenges of deploying such a system in practice.

Overall, the Aranyani approach represents a significant contribution to the field of fair machine learning, and the authors have provided a solid foundation for future research in this area.

Conclusion

This paper presents Aranyani, a novel ensemble model for achieving group fairness in online machine learning settings. By leveraging the hierarchical structure of decision trees, Aranyani can efficiently compute fairness gradients using aggregate statistics, overcoming the challenges of traditional in-processing fairness techniques in the online setting.

The empirical results demonstrate that Aranyani is able to achieve a better balance between accuracy and fairness compared to baseline approaches, across a variety of public datasets. This work advances the state of the art in fair machine learning and provides a promising direction for further research in this important area.