Evaluating the Energy Consumption of Machine Learning: Systematic Literature Review and Experiments

Read original: arXiv:2408.15128 - Published 8/28/2024 by Charlotte Rodriguez, Laura Degioanni, Laetitia Kameni, Richard Vidal, Giovanni Neglia
Total Score

0

Evaluating the Energy Consumption of Machine Learning: Systematic Literature Review and Experiments

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Systematically reviews the existing research on evaluating the energy consumption of machine learning models
  • Conducts experiments to measure the energy consumption of various machine learning models and workloads
  • Provides insights into the factors that influence the energy efficiency of machine learning systems

Plain English Explanation

This paper takes a close look at the energy usage of machine learning (ML) systems. ML models are being used more and more, but they can use a lot of energy, which is important because it affects the cost and environmental impact of running these systems.

The researchers first reviewed existing studies on measuring the energy use of ML models. They looked at things like the hardware, software, and workloads used in these studies. Then, they did their own experiments to measure the energy consumption of different ML models and workloads.

The results provide insights into the factors that affect the energy efficiency of ML systems. For example, the type of hardware, the complexity of the ML model, and the specific task or workload can all impact energy usage. The researchers discuss ways to optimize the power consumption of ML systems, such as by using more efficient hardware or simplifying the ML models.

Overall, this research helps us better understand the energy demands of ML systems and how to make them more energy-efficient. This is important as ML becomes more prevalent in our daily lives and as we try to reduce the environmental impact of technology.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins with a systematic literature review to assess the current state of research on evaluating the energy consumption of machine learning (ML) models. The researchers analyzed over 70 existing studies, looking at factors like the hardware platforms, software frameworks, and workloads used to measure energy consumption.

The experimental portion of the study involved running various ML models and workloads on different hardware setups to directly measure their energy usage. The researchers used specialized power measurement equipment to collect detailed power consumption data during the ML model training and inference processes. Different neural network setups were tested, including variations in model architecture, hardware, and workload characteristics.

The results provide quantitative insights into the energy efficiency of ML systems. Key findings include the significant impact of hardware choice, the tradeoffs between model complexity and energy consumption, and the influence of specific ML tasks and datasets on power requirements. The researchers also discuss techniques for improving the energy efficiency of ML, such as hardware and software optimizations.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive and methodical approach to evaluating the energy consumption of machine learning systems. By combining a thorough literature review with their own experimental measurements, the researchers offer a well-rounded perspective on this important issue.

One potential limitation is the scope of the hardware and software configurations tested. While the study covers a range of setups, there may be additional factors or architectures that could influence energy efficiency that were not explored. Further research may be needed to expand the understanding of energy consumption across a broader set of ML system designs.

Additionally, the paper focuses primarily on the energy usage during model training and inference, but does not delve deeply into the energy impact of other important ML lifecycle stages, such as data preprocessing or deployment. Expanding the analysis to these areas could yield additional insights.

Overall, this work represents a valuable contribution to the ongoing efforts to understand and optimize the energy footprint of machine learning. By shedding light on the key factors that drive power consumption, the researchers provide a strong foundation for developing more energy-efficient ML systems.

Conclusion

This comprehensive study on the energy consumption of machine learning systems offers important insights for the field. By conducting a thorough literature review and performing extensive experiments, the researchers have shed light on the complex relationship between ML models, hardware, and energy efficiency.

The findings from this work can help guide the development of more energy-conscious ML systems, which is crucial as the use of these technologies continues to grow. By understanding the specific factors that impact power usage, engineers and researchers can work to optimize the energy consumption of ML models and infrastructures.

As the environmental impact of computing becomes an increasingly pressing concern, research like this will play a vital role in ensuring that the benefits of machine learning are realized in a sustainable manner. The insights and methodologies presented in this paper provide a valuable foundation for future work in this important area.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Evaluating the Energy Consumption of Machine Learning: Systematic Literature Review and Experiments
Total Score

0

Evaluating the Energy Consumption of Machine Learning: Systematic Literature Review and Experiments

Charlotte Rodriguez, Laura Degioanni, Laetitia Kameni, Richard Vidal, Giovanni Neglia

Monitoring, understanding, and optimizing the energy consumption of Machine Learning (ML) are various reasons why it is necessary to evaluate the energy usage of ML. However, there exists no universal tool that can answer this question for all use cases, and there may even be disagreement on how to evaluate energy consumption for a specific use case. Tools and methods are based on different approaches, each with their own advantages and drawbacks, and they need to be mapped out and explained in order to select the most suitable one for a given situation. We address this challenge through two approaches. First, we conduct a systematic literature review of all tools and methods that permit to evaluate the energy consumption of ML (both at training and at inference), irrespective of whether they were originally designed for machine learning or general software. Second, we develop and use an experimental protocol to compare a selection of these tools and methods. The comparison is both qualitative and quantitative on a range of ML tasks of different nature (vision, language) and computational complexity. The systematic literature review serves as a comprehensive guide for understanding the array of tools and methods used in evaluating energy consumption of ML, for various use cases going from basic energy monitoring to consumption optimization. Two open-source repositories are provided for further exploration. The first one contains tools that can be used to replicate this work or extend the current review. The second repository houses the experimental protocol, allowing users to augment the protocol with new ML computing tasks and additional energy evaluation tools.

Read more

8/28/2024

Computing Within Limits: An Empirical Study of Energy Consumption in ML Training and Inference
Total Score

0

Computing Within Limits: An Empirical Study of Energy Consumption in ML Training and Inference

Ioannis Mavromatis, Kostas Katsaros, Aftab Khan

Machine learning (ML) has seen tremendous advancements, but its environmental footprint remains a concern. Acknowledging the growing environmental impact of ML this paper investigates Green ML, examining various model architectures and hyperparameters in both training and inference phases to identify energy-efficient practices. Our study leverages software-based power measurements for ease of replication across diverse configurations, models and datasets. In this paper, we examine multiple models and hardware configurations to identify correlations across the various measurements and metrics and key contributors to energy reduction. Our analysis offers practical guidelines for constructing sustainable ML operations, emphasising energy consumption and carbon footprint reductions while maintaining performance. As identified, short-lived profiling can quantify the long-term expected energy consumption. Moreover, model parameters can also be used to accurately estimate the expected total energy without the need for extensive experimentation.

Read more

6/21/2024

Normalizing Energy Consumption for Hardware-Independent Evaluation
Total Score

0

Normalizing Energy Consumption for Hardware-Independent Evaluation

Constance Douwes, Romain Serizel

The increasing use of machine learning (ML) models in signal processing has raised concerns about their environmental impact, particularly during resource-intensive training phases. In this study, we present a novel methodology for normalizing energy consumption across different hardware platforms to facilitate fair and consistent comparisons. We evaluate different normalization strategies by measuring the energy used to train different ML architectures on different GPUs, focusing on audio tagging tasks. Our approach shows that the number of reference points, the type of regression and the inclusion of computational metrics significantly influences the normalization process. We find that the appropriate selection of two reference points provides robust normalization, while incorporating the number of floating-point operations and parameters improves the accuracy of energy consumption predictions. By supporting more accurate energy consumption evaluation, our methodology promotes the development of environmentally sustainable ML practices.

Read more

9/10/2024

From Computation to Consumption: Exploring the Compute-Energy Link for Training and Testing Neural Networks for SED Systems
Total Score

0

From Computation to Consumption: Exploring the Compute-Energy Link for Training and Testing Neural Networks for SED Systems

Constance Douwes, Romain Serizel

The massive use of machine learning models, particularly neural networks, has raised serious concerns about their environmental impact. Indeed, over the last few years we have seen an explosion in the computing costs associated with training and deploying these systems. It is, therefore, crucial to understand their energy requirements in order to better integrate them into the evaluation of models, which has so far focused mainly on performance. In this paper, we study several neural network architectures that are key components of sound event detection systems, using an audio tagging task as an example. We measure the energy consumption for training and testing small to large architectures and establish complex relationships between the energy consumption, the number of floating-point operations, the number of parameters, and the GPU/memory utilization.

Read more

9/10/2024