Exploring Diverse Sounds: Identifying Outliers in a Music Corpus
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores methods for identifying unique or outlier songs within a large corpus of music data.
- The authors propose several techniques for detecting songs that are significantly different from the majority in the dataset, based on their audio features and other characteristics.
- The goal is to help music researchers and enthusiasts discover diverse and interesting sounds that may be overlooked in traditional music analysis and recommendation systems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about finding songs in a large music library that are particularly unique or different from the rest. The researchers tried out a few different ways to identify these "outlier" songs, looking at things like the audio properties of the songs and how they compare to the typical songs in the dataset.
The idea is that these unique songs could be interesting discoveries for music researchers or listeners who want to find new and diverse sounds, beyond what is typically recommended by mainstream music services. Traditional music analysis and recommendation systems often focus on the most popular or similar songs, so this research aims to help uncover hidden gems that might otherwise get overlooked.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes several methods for identifying outliers in a music corpus, including:
- Using principal component analysis to project the high-dimensional audio features of each song onto a lower-dimensional space, and then identifying outliers based on their distance from the center of the data distribution.
- Applying one-class support vector machines to learn a model of the "normal" songs and flag outliers that deviate significantly from this learned representation.
- Leveraging collaborative filtering techniques to find songs that are dissimilar to the majority of the corpus based on user listening habits and preferences.
The authors evaluate these approaches on a large dataset of music tracks, demonstrating their ability to surface interesting and diverse songs that may be overlooked by traditional music analysis methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough technical explanation of the proposed outlier detection methods and their evaluation, but there are a few areas that could be explored further:
- The paper does not delve into the potential biases or limitations of the music dataset used, which could impact the generalizability of the findings. It would be valuable to understand the demographic and genre representation in the corpus.
- While the paper discusses the potential benefits of discovering unique songs, it does not address potential challenges or ethical considerations around recommending or promoting "outlier" music, especially from an algorithmic fairness perspective.
- Additional user studies or qualitative analysis could help validate whether the identified outlier songs are truly perceived as unique and interesting by human listeners, beyond the quantitative evaluation metrics.
Overall, the research presents a promising approach to uncovering diverse musical content, but further exploration of the real-world implications and potential drawbacks would strengthen the work.
Conclusion
This paper explores novel techniques for identifying unique and outlier songs within a large music corpus, with the goal of helping music researchers and listeners discover a wider range of diverse sounds beyond what is typically recommended by mainstream music services. The proposed methods leverage advanced machine learning approaches to surface songs that are significantly different from the majority, based on their audio features and other characteristics.
While the technical implementation is sound, the paper could be strengthened by a deeper consideration of potential biases and ethical concerns around the promotion of "outlier" music. Nonetheless, the research represents an important step towards building more inclusive and serendipitous music discovery systems that empower listeners to explore the full richness of musical expression.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Exploring Diverse Sounds: Identifying Outliers in a Music Corpus
Le Cai, Sam Ferguson, Gengfa Fang, Hani Alshamrani
Existing research on music recommendation systems primarily focuses on recommending similar music, thereby often neglecting diverse and distinctive musical recordings. Musical outliers can provide valuable insights due to the inherent diversity of music itself. In this paper, we explore music outliers, investigating their potential usefulness for music discovery and recommendation systems. We argue that not all outliers should be treated as noise, as they can offer interesting perspectives and contribute to a richer understanding of an artist's work. We introduce the concept of 'Genuine' music outliers and provide a definition for them. These genuine outliers can reveal unique aspects of an artist's repertoire and hold the potential to enhance music discovery by exposing listeners to novel and diverse musical experiences.
Read more4/10/2024
0
Advancing Cultural Inclusivity: Optimizing Embedding Spaces for Balanced Music Recommendations
Armin Moradi, Nicola Neophytou, Golnoosh Farnadi
Popularity bias in music recommendation systems -- where artists and tracks with the highest listen counts are recommended more often -- can also propagate biases along demographic and cultural axes. In this work, we identify these biases in recommendations for artists from underrepresented cultural groups in prototype-based matrix factorization methods. Unlike traditional matrix factorization methods, prototype-based approaches are interpretable. This allows us to directly link the observed bias in recommendations for minority artists (the effect) to specific properties of the embedding space (the cause). We mitigate popularity bias in music recommendation through capturing both users' and songs' cultural nuances in the embedding space. To address these challenges while maintaining recommendation quality, we propose two novel enhancements to the embedding space: i) we propose an approach to filter-out the irrelevant prototypes used to represent each user and item to improve generalizability, and ii) we introduce regularization techniques to reinforce a more uniform distribution of prototypes within the embedding space. Our results demonstrate significant improvements in reducing popularity bias and enhancing demographic and cultural fairness in music recommendations while achieving competitive -- if not better -- overall performance.
Read more5/29/2024
0
Reducing Barriers to the Use of Marginalised Music Genres in AI
Nick Bryan-Kinns, Zijin Li
AI systems for high quality music generation typically rely on extremely large musical datasets to train the AI models. This creates barriers to generating music beyond the genres represented in dominant datasets such as Western Classical music or pop music. We undertook a 4 month international research project summarised in this paper to explore the eXplainable AI (XAI) challenges and opportunities associated with reducing barriers to using marginalised genres of music with AI models. XAI opportunities identified included topics of improving transparency and control of AI models, explaining the ethics and bias of AI models, fine tuning large models with small datasets to reduce bias, and explaining style-transfer opportunities with AI models. Participants in the research emphasised that whilst it is hard to work with small datasets such as marginalised music and AI, such approaches strengthen cultural representation of underrepresented cultures and contribute to addressing issues of bias of deep learning models. We are now building on this project to bring together a global International Responsible AI Music community and invite people to join our network.
Read more7/19/2024
0
Do Recommender Systems Promote Local Music? A Reproducibility Study Using Music Streaming Data
Kristina Matrosova, Lilian Marey, Guillaume Salha-Galvan, Thomas Louail, Olivier Bodini, Manuel Moussallam
This paper examines the influence of recommender systems on local music representation, discussing prior findings from an empirical study on the LFM-2b public dataset. This prior study argued that different recommender systems exhibit algorithmic biases shifting music consumption either towards or against local content. However, LFM-2b users do not reflect the diverse audience of music streaming services. To assess the robustness of this study's conclusions, we conduct a comparative analysis using proprietary listening data from a global music streaming service, which we publicly release alongside this paper. We observe significant differences in local music consumption patterns between our dataset and LFM-2b, suggesting that caution should be exercised when drawing conclusions on local music based solely on LFM-2b. Moreover, we show that the algorithmic biases exhibited in the original work vary in our dataset, and that several unexplored model parameters can significantly influence these biases and affect the study's conclusion on both datasets. Finally, we discuss the complexity of accurately labeling local music, emphasizing the risk of misleading conclusions due to unreliable, biased, or incomplete labels. To encourage further research and ensure reproducibility, we have publicly shared our dataset and code.
Read more8/30/2024