G-SAP: Graph-based Structure-Aware Prompt Learning over Heterogeneous Knowledge for Commonsense Reasoning

Read original: arXiv:2405.05616 - Published 5/10/2024 by Ruiting Dai, Yuqiao Tan, Lisi Mo, Shuang Liang, Guohao Huo, Jiayi Luo, Yao Cheng

🤿

Overview

This paper proposes a novel Graph-based Structure-Aware Prompt Learning Model (G-SAP) for commonsense reasoning, which aims to balance heterogeneous knowledge and enhance cross-modal interaction between language models (LMs) and graph neural networks (GNNs).
The key ideas include:
- Constructing an evidence graph by integrating multiple knowledge sources to boost performance.
- Employing a structure-aware frozen pre-trained language model (PLM) to incorporate structured and textual information from the evidence graph.
- Using a heterogeneous message-passing reasoning module to facilitate deep interaction between the LM and graph-based networks.

Plain English Explanation

Commonsense reasoning, the ability to understand and reason about everyday situations, has become increasingly important for various applications like digital assistants and social robots. While advanced language models have achieved impressive results in this area, they can sometimes prioritize textual information too heavily, which can limit their ability to effectively transfer structural knowledge and make their reasoning more interpretable.

To address this, the researchers propose a new model called G-SAP that combines language models with knowledge graphs. Knowledge graphs are structured representations of information that can capture the relationships between different concepts. By integrating multiple knowledge sources, including ConceptNet, Wikipedia, and the Cambridge Dictionary, the researchers create an "evidence graph" that provides a more comprehensive understanding of commonsense knowledge.

The key innovation in G-SAP is the way it leverages this evidence graph. First, it uses a "structure-aware" pre-trained language model, which means the model is designed to better incorporate the structural information from the graph. Second, it employs a "heterogeneous message-passing" mechanism that allows the language model and the graph-based network to deeply interact and exchange knowledge, rather than just coarsely fusing the two.

By balancing the use of textual and structured knowledge, and enabling strong cross-modal interaction, the researchers show that G-SAP can outperform other state-of-the-art models, especially on the OpenBookQA dataset, where it achieves a 6.12% improvement.

Technical Explanation

The researchers begin by noting that while fully fine-tuned pre-trained language models have achieved remarkable performance in commonsense reasoning, their tendency to prioritize textual information can limit their ability to effectively leverage structural knowledge and maintain interpretability.

To address this, the researchers propose the G-SAP model, which integrates language models with knowledge graphs. Specifically, they construct an "evidence graph" by combining multiple knowledge sources, including ConceptNet, Wikipedia, and the Cambridge Dictionary. This graph provides a more comprehensive representation of commonsense knowledge.

The core of the G-SAP model is a "structure-aware frozen pre-trained language model" that is designed to fully incorporate the structured and textual information from the evidence graph. The generation of prompts for this language model is driven by the entities and relations present in the graph.

Additionally, the researchers employ a "heterogeneous message-passing reasoning module" to facilitate deep interaction between the language model and the graph-based networks. This allows for a more profound exchange of knowledge between the two modalities, rather than a simple fusion.

The researchers evaluate G-SAP on three benchmark commonsense reasoning datasets, including OpenBookQA, and demonstrate significant performance improvements over existing state-of-the-art models, particularly a 6.12% improvement on the OpenBookQA dataset.

Critical Analysis

The researchers have made a compelling case for the importance of balancing textual and structural knowledge, as well as enabling strong cross-modal interaction, in commonsense reasoning models. The G-SAP approach appears to be a promising step in this direction, with the evidence graph and the structure-aware language model providing a unique and effective way to leverage heterogeneous knowledge sources.

However, the paper does not delve into the potential limitations or caveats of the proposed approach. For example, it would be interesting to understand how the model performs on more complex or ambiguous commonsense reasoning tasks, or how it might scale to larger knowledge graphs. Additionally, the researchers could have explored the interpretability of the model's reasoning, which is an important consideration for many real-world applications.

Furthermore, the paper does not address potential biases or ethical considerations that may arise from the use of large language models and knowledge graphs, which can sometimes encode societal biases or reflect limited perspectives. Addressing these concerns would be an important area for future research.

Overall, the G-SAP model represents an interesting and valuable contribution to the field of commonsense reasoning, but there is still room for further exploration and refinement to fully unlock its potential.

Conclusion

The proposed G-SAP model offers a novel approach to commonsense reasoning that aims to balance the use of textual and structural knowledge, while also enhancing the cross-modal interaction between language models and graph-based networks. By constructing a comprehensive "evidence graph" and employing a structure-aware language model, the researchers have demonstrated significant performance improvements over existing state-of-the-art models, particularly on the OpenBookQA dataset.

This research highlights the importance of leveraging diverse knowledge sources and facilitating deeper interactions between different modalities of information in order to improve commonsense reasoning capabilities. As digital assistants, social robots, and other AI-powered applications become more prevalent, the ability to reason about everyday situations in a robust and interpretable manner will be increasingly crucial. The G-SAP model represents an important step forward in this direction, paving the way for further advancements in the field.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤿

G-SAP: Graph-based Structure-Aware Prompt Learning over Heterogeneous Knowledge for Commonsense Reasoning

Ruiting Dai, Yuqiao Tan, Lisi Mo, Shuang Liang, Guohao Huo, Jiayi Luo, Yao Cheng

Commonsense question answering has demonstrated considerable potential across various applications like assistants and social robots. Although fully fine-tuned pre-trained Language Models(LM) have achieved remarkable performance in commonsense reasoning, their tendency to excessively prioritize textual information hampers the precise transfer of structural knowledge and undermines interpretability. Some studies have explored combining LMs with Knowledge Graphs(KGs) by coarsely fusing the two modalities to perform Graph Neural Network(GNN)-based reasoning that lacks a profound interaction between heterogeneous modalities. In this paper, we propose a novel Graph-based Structure-Aware Prompt Learning Model for commonsense reasoning, named G-SAP, aiming to maintain a balance between heterogeneous knowledge and enhance the cross-modal interaction within the LM+GNNs model. In particular, an evidence graph is constructed by integrating multiple knowledge sources, i.e. ConceptNet, Wikipedia, and Cambridge Dictionary to boost the performance. Afterward, a structure-aware frozen PLM is employed to fully incorporate the structured and textual information from the evidence graph, where the generation of prompts is driven by graph entities and relations. Finally, a heterogeneous message-passing reasoning module is used to facilitate deep interaction of knowledge between the LM and graph-based networks. Empirical validation, conducted through extensive experiments on three benchmark datasets, demonstrates the notable performance of the proposed model. The results reveal a significant advancement over the existing models, especially, with 6.12% improvement over the SoTA LM+GNNs model on the OpenbookQA dataset.

5/10/2024

Knowledge Graph Structure as Prompt: Improving Small Language Models Capabilities for Knowledge-based Causal Discovery

Yuni Susanti, Michael Farber

Causal discovery aims to estimate causal structures among variables based on observational data. Large Language Models (LLMs) offer a fresh perspective to tackle the causal discovery problem by reasoning on the metadata associated with variables rather than their actual data values, an approach referred to as knowledge-based causal discovery. In this paper, we investigate the capabilities of Small Language Models (SLMs, defined as LLMs with fewer than 1 billion parameters) with prompt-based learning for knowledge-based causal discovery. Specifically, we present KG Structure as Prompt, a novel approach for integrating structural information from a knowledge graph, such as common neighbor nodes and metapaths, into prompt-based learning to enhance the capabilities of SLMs. Experimental results on three types of biomedical and open-domain datasets under few-shot settings demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, surpassing most baselines and even conventional fine-tuning approaches trained on full datasets. Our findings further highlight the strong capabilities of SLMs: in combination with knowledge graphs and prompt-based learning, SLMs demonstrate the potential to surpass LLMs with larger number of parameters. Our code and datasets are available on GitHub.

7/31/2024

🌀

An Enhanced Prompt-Based LLM Reasoning Scheme via Knowledge Graph-Integrated Collaboration

Yihao Li, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu

While Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in a multitude of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, they encounter challenges in practical applications, including issues with hallucinations, inadequate knowledge updating, and limited transparency in the reasoning process. To overcome these limitations, this study innovatively proposes a collaborative training-free reasoning scheme involving tight cooperation between Knowledge Graph (KG) and LLMs. This scheme first involves using LLMs to iteratively explore KG, selectively retrieving a task-relevant knowledge subgraph to support reasoning. The LLMs are then guided to further combine inherent implicit knowledge to reason on the subgraph while explicitly elucidating the reasoning process. Through such a cooperative approach, our scheme achieves more reliable knowledge-based reasoning and facilitates the tracing of the reasoning results. Experimental results show that our scheme significantly progressed across multiple datasets, notably achieving over a 10% improvement on the QALD10 dataset compared to the best baseline and the fine-tuned state-of-the-art (SOTA) work. Building on this success, this study hopes to offer a valuable reference for future research in the fusion of KG and LLMs, thereby enhancing LLMs' proficiency in solving complex issues.

6/13/2024

Graph Structure Prompt Learning: A Novel Methodology to Improve Performance of Graph Neural Networks

Zhenhua Huang, Kunhao Li, Shaojie Wang, Zhaohong Jia, Wentao Zhu, Sharad Mehrotra

Graph neural networks (GNNs) are widely applied in graph data modeling. However, existing GNNs are often trained in a task-driven manner that fails to fully capture the intrinsic nature of the graph structure, resulting in sub-optimal node and graph representations. To address this limitation, we propose a novel Graph structure Prompt Learning method (GPL) to enhance the training of GNNs, which is inspired by prompt mechanisms in natural language processing. GPL employs task-independent graph structure losses to encourage GNNs to learn intrinsic graph characteristics while simultaneously solving downstream tasks, producing higher-quality node and graph representations. In extensive experiments on eleven real-world datasets, after being trained by GPL, GNNs significantly outperform their original performance on node classification, graph classification, and edge prediction tasks (up to 10.28%, 16.5%, and 24.15%, respectively). By allowing GNNs to capture the inherent structural prompts of graphs in GPL, they can alleviate the issue of over-smooth and achieve new state-of-the-art performances, which introduces a novel and effective direction for GNN research with potential applications in various domains.

7/17/2024