Goal-conditioned Offline Reinforcement Learning through State Space Partitioning
2303.09367
0
0
🏅
Abstract
Offline reinforcement learning (RL) aims to infer sequential decision policies using only offline datasets. This is a particularly difficult setup, especially when learning to achieve multiple different goals or outcomes under a given scenario with only sparse rewards. For offline learning of goal-conditioned policies via supervised learning, previous work has shown that an advantage weighted log-likelihood loss guarantees monotonic policy improvement. In this work we argue that, despite its benefits, this approach is still insufficient to fully address the distribution shift and multi-modality problems. The latter is particularly severe in long-horizon tasks where finding a unique and optimal policy that goes from a state to the desired goal is challenging as there may be multiple and potentially conflicting solutions. To tackle these challenges, we propose a complementary advantage-based weighting scheme that introduces an additional source of inductive bias: given a value-based partitioning of the state space, the contribution of actions expected to lead to target regions that are easier to reach, compared to the final goal, is further increased. Empirically, we demonstrate that the proposed approach, Dual-Advantage Weighted Offline Goal-conditioned RL (DAWOG), outperforms several competing offline algorithms in commonly used benchmarks. Analytically, we offer a guarantee that the learnt policy is never worse than the underlying behaviour policy.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Offline reinforcement learning (RL) aims to learn decision-making policies from existing datasets, without the ability to interact with the environment
- This is particularly challenging when learning to achieve multiple goals or outcomes, especially with sparse rewards
- Previous work has shown that advantage-weighted log-likelihood loss can improve policy learning, but this approach still struggles with distribution shift and multi-modality problems
Plain English Explanation
Offline reinforcement learning is a technique where computer systems try to learn how to make good decisions without being able to directly interact with the real-world environment. This is especially difficult when the goal is to learn how to accomplish multiple different tasks or achieve various outcomes, particularly when the feedback (rewards) provided is sparse or infrequent.
Earlier research has found that using an "advantage-weighted log-likelihood loss" can help these offline RL systems improve their decision-making policies. However, this approach still struggles with two key challenges: 1) the data used to train the system may not match the real-world distribution of scenarios, and 2) there may be multiple, potentially conflicting, ways to successfully complete a given task.
Technical Explanation
This paper proposes a new approach called "Dual-Advantage Weighted Offline Goal-conditioned RL (DAWOG)" to address the limitations of previous offline RL methods. The key idea is to introduce an additional source of "inductive bias" by leveraging a value-based partitioning of the state space.
Specifically, the contribution of actions that are expected to lead to "easier-to-reach" intermediate regions, rather than directly to the final goal, is further increased during the training process. This helps the system navigate the complex, multi-modal landscape of potential solutions more effectively.
The authors demonstrate empirically that DAWOG outperforms several competing offline RL algorithms on common benchmark tasks. They also provide a theoretical guarantee that the learned policy will never be worse than the original behavior policy used to collect the offline dataset.
Critical Analysis
While the proposed DAWOG approach shows promising results, the authors acknowledge that it does not fully address all the challenges of offline RL, particularly in long-horizon tasks. There may be other sources of inductive bias or alternative training techniques that could further improve performance.
Additionally, the paper does not explore how DAWOG would scale to more complex, real-world environments with higher-dimensional state and action spaces. Further research may be needed to understand the limitations and broader applicability of this method.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel offline RL algorithm, DAWOG, that aims to improve policy learning by leveraging a value-based partitioning of the state space to guide the training process. The results suggest this approach can outperform previous methods, particularly in tasks with multiple potential solutions.
However, offline RL remains a challenging problem, and DAWOG does not solve all the known issues. Continued research into new techniques and combined approaches will be necessary to further advance the state of the art in this important field of machine learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
GOPlan: Goal-conditioned Offline Reinforcement Learning by Planning with Learned Models
Mianchu Wang, Rui Yang, Xi Chen, Hao Sun, Meng Fang, Giovanni Montana
0
0
Offline Goal-Conditioned RL (GCRL) offers a feasible paradigm for learning general-purpose policies from diverse and multi-task offline datasets. Despite notable recent progress, the predominant offline GCRL methods, mainly model-free, face constraints in handling limited data and generalizing to unseen goals. In this work, we propose Goal-conditioned Offline Planning (GOPlan), a novel model-based framework that contains two key phases: (1) pretraining a prior policy capable of capturing multi-modal action distribution within the multi-goal dataset; (2) employing the reanalysis method with planning to generate imagined trajectories for funetuning policies. Specifically, we base the prior policy on an advantage-weighted conditioned generative adversarial network, which facilitates distinct mode separation, mitigating the pitfalls of out-of-distribution (OOD) actions. For further policy optimization, the reanalysis method generates high-quality imaginary data by planning with learned models for both intra-trajectory and inter-trajectory goals. With thorough experimental evaluations, we demonstrate that GOPlan achieves state-of-the-art performance on various offline multi-goal navigation and manipulation tasks. Moreover, our results highlight the superior ability of GOPlan to handle small data budgets and generalize to OOD goals.
5/17/2024
🏅
State-Constrained Offline Reinforcement Learning
Charles A. Hepburn, Yue Jin, Giovanni Montana
0
0
Traditional offline reinforcement learning methods predominantly operate in a batch-constrained setting. This confines the algorithms to a specific state-action distribution present in the dataset, reducing the effects of distributional shift but restricting the algorithm greatly. In this paper, we alleviate this limitation by introducing a novel framework named emph{state-constrained} offline reinforcement learning. By exclusively focusing on the dataset's state distribution, our framework significantly enhances learning potential and reduces previous limitations. The proposed setting not only broadens the learning horizon but also improves the ability to combine different trajectories from the dataset effectively, a desirable property inherent in offline reinforcement learning. Our research is underpinned by solid theoretical findings that pave the way for subsequent advancements in this domain. Additionally, we introduce StaCQ, a deep learning algorithm that is both performance-driven on the D4RL benchmark datasets and closely aligned with our theoretical propositions. StaCQ establishes a strong baseline for forthcoming explorations in state-constrained offline reinforcement learning.
5/24/2024
📊
Learning Goal-Conditioned Policies from Sub-Optimal Offline Data via Metric Learning
Alfredo Reichlin, Miguel Vasco, Hang Yin, Danica Kragic
0
0
We address the problem of learning optimal behavior from sub-optimal datasets for goal-conditioned offline reinforcement learning. To do so, we propose the use of metric learning to approximate the optimal value function for goal-conditioned offline RL problems under sparse rewards, invertible actions and deterministic transitions. We introduce distance monotonicity, a property for representations to recover optimality and propose an optimization objective that leads to such property. We use the proposed value function to guide the learning of a policy in an actor-critic fashion, a method we name MetricRL. Experimentally, we show that our method estimates optimal behaviors from severely sub-optimal offline datasets without suffering from out-of-distribution estimation errors. We demonstrate that MetricRL consistently outperforms prior state-of-the-art goal-conditioned RL methods in learning optimal policies from sub-optimal offline datasets.
6/11/2024
Offline Reinforcement Learning with Imbalanced Datasets
Li Jiang, Sijie Cheng, Jielin Qiu, Haoran Xu, Wai Kin Chan, Zhao Ding
0
0
The prevalent use of benchmarks in current offline reinforcement learning (RL) research has led to a neglect of the imbalance of real-world dataset distributions in the development of models. The real-world offline RL dataset is often imbalanced over the state space due to the challenge of exploration or safety considerations. In this paper, we specify properties of imbalanced datasets in offline RL, where the state coverage follows a power law distribution characterized by skewed policies. Theoretically and empirically, we show that typically offline RL methods based on distributional constraints, such as conservative Q-learning (CQL), are ineffective in extracting policies under the imbalanced dataset. Inspired by natural intelligence, we propose a novel offline RL method that utilizes the augmentation of CQL with a retrieval process to recall past related experiences, effectively alleviating the challenges posed by imbalanced datasets. We evaluate our method on several tasks in the context of imbalanced datasets with varying levels of imbalance, utilizing the variant of D4RL. Empirical results demonstrate the superiority of our method over other baselines.
5/22/2024