Grounding LLMs For Robot Task Planning Using Closed-loop State Feedback
0
📶
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Planning algorithms break down complex problems into smaller steps that robots can execute sequentially to complete tasks.
- Recent research has used Large Language Models (LLMs) for task planning, generating robot policies from natural language in simulations and the real world.
- While LLMs like GPT-4 show promise in generalizing to new tasks, their performance is limited by hallucinations due to insufficient grounding in the robot environment.
- Enhancing LLMs with environmental state information and feedback can improve their robustness in task planning.
Plain English Explanation
Planning algorithms for robots break down complex tasks into simpler steps that can be carried out one after the other. Researchers have started using powerful language models like GPT-4 to generate these plans from natural language, allowing robots to understand and execute tasks described in plain words.
While these language models are good at generalizing to new situations, they can sometimes get confused or make mistakes, especially when they don't have enough information about the robot's environment. To fix this, the researchers developed a new approach called BrainBody-LLM that uses two separate language models - one for high-level planning and one for low-level control. This is inspired by how the human brain and body work together.
The BrainBody-LLM system also has a feedback loop, allowing it to learn from mistakes made in the simulation and improve its plans accordingly. This helps the language models become more reliable and effective at planning tasks for robots, even in complex real-world settings.
Technical Explanation
The researchers introduce a novel task planning approach called BrainBody-LLM that utilizes two separate Large Language Models (LLMs) - one for high-level planning and one for low-level control. This is inspired by the human neural system's brain-body architecture.
The high-level planning LLM is responsible for generating a sequence of abstract actions to achieve a given goal, while the low-level control LLM translates these actions into specific robot control commands. BrainBody-LLM implements a closed-loop feedback mechanism, allowing it to learn from simulator errors and correct execution errors in complex settings.
The researchers demonstrate the successful application of BrainBody-LLM in the VirtualHome simulation environment, achieving a 29% improvement in task-oriented success rates over competitive baselines using the GPT-4 backend. They also evaluate their algorithm on seven complex tasks using a realistic physics simulator and the Franka Research 3 robotic arm, comparing it with various state-of-the-art LLMs.
The results show advancements in the reasoning capabilities of recent LLMs, which enable them to learn from raw simulator/controller errors and correct their plans, making them highly effective in robotic task planning.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge that while their BrainBody-LLM approach shows promising results, it still has some limitations. The system relies on a simulated environment for training and feedback, which may not fully capture the complexities of the real world. Additionally, the performance of the low-level control LLM is critical to the overall success of the system, and further research is needed to improve its reliability and robustness.
Another potential concern is the reliance on large language models, which can be opaque and difficult to interpret. The researchers do not provide a detailed analysis of the inner workings of the LLMs used in their system, making it challenging to understand the specific mechanisms behind their success.
Further research could explore ways to ground the language models more deeply in the robot's environment, potentially through the use of additional sensors or physical interaction. This could help address the issue of hallucinations and improve the overall reliability of the planning system.
Conclusion
The BrainBody-LLM approach proposed in this paper represents a significant step forward in the use of large language models for robotic task planning. By dividing the planning process into high-level and low-level components, and implementing a closed-loop feedback mechanism, the researchers have developed a system that is more robust and effective than previous LLM-based approaches.
The successful application of BrainBody-LLM in both simulation and real-world environments suggests that LLMs are becoming increasingly capable of reasoning about complex tasks and learning from their mistakes. As this technology continues to evolve, it has the potential to enable more sophisticated and reliable robotic systems that can tackle a wide range of challenging tasks.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📶
0
Grounding LLMs For Robot Task Planning Using Closed-loop State Feedback
Vineet Bhat, Ali Umut Kaypak, Prashanth Krishnamurthy, Ramesh Karri, Farshad Khorrami
Planning algorithms decompose complex problems into intermediate steps that can be sequentially executed by robots to complete tasks. Recent works have employed Large Language Models (LLMs) for task planning, using natural language to generate robot policies in both simulation and real-world environments. LLMs like GPT-4 have shown promising results in generalizing to unseen tasks, but their applicability is limited due to hallucinations caused by insufficient grounding in the robot environment. The robustness of LLMs in task planning can be enhanced with environmental state information and feedback. In this paper, we introduce a novel approach to task planning that utilizes two separate LLMs for high-level planning and low-level control, improving task-related success rates and goal condition recall. Our algorithm, textit{BrainBody-LLM}, draws inspiration from the human neural system, emulating its brain-body architecture by dividing planning across two LLMs in a structured, hierarchical manner. BrainBody-LLM implements a closed-loop feedback mechanism, enabling learning from simulator errors to resolve execution errors in complex settings. We demonstrate the successful application of BrainBody-LLM in the VirtualHome simulation environment, achieving a 29% improvement in task-oriented success rates over competitive baselines with the GPT-4 backend. Additionally, we evaluate our algorithm on seven complex tasks using a realistic physics simulator and the Franka Research 3 robotic arm, comparing it with various state-of-the-art LLMs. Our results show advancements in the reasoning capabilities of recent LLMs, which enable them to learn from raw simulator/controller errors to correct plans, making them highly effective in robotic task planning.
Read more8/19/2024
0
LLM-based Robot Task Planning with Exceptional Handling for General Purpose Service Robots
Ruoyu Wang, Zhipeng Yang, Zinan Zhao, Xinyan Tong, Zhi Hong, Kun Qian
The development of a general purpose service robot for daily life necessitates the robot's ability to deploy a myriad of fundamental behaviors judiciously. Recent advancements in training Large Language Models (LLMs) can be used to generate action sequences directly, given an instruction in natural language with no additional domain information. However, while the outputs of LLMs are semantically correct, the generated task plans may not accurately map to acceptable actions and might encompass various linguistic ambiguities. LLM hallucinations pose another challenge for robot task planning, which results in content that is inconsistent with real-world facts or user inputs. In this paper, we propose a task planning method based on a constrained LLM prompt scheme, which can generate an executable action sequence from a command. An exceptional handling module is further proposed to deal with LLM hallucinations problem. This module can ensure the LLM-generated results are admissible in the current environment. We evaluate our method on the commands generated by the RoboCup@Home Command Generator, observing that the robot demonstrates exceptional performance in both comprehending instructions and executing tasks.
Read more5/27/2024
0
Open Grounded Planning: Challenges and Benchmark Construction
Shiguang Guo, Ziliang Deng, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has increasingly drawn attention to the use of LLMs for human-like planning. Existing work on LLM-based planning either focuses on leveraging the inherent language generation capabilities of LLMs to produce free-style plans, or employs reinforcement learning approaches to learn decision-making for a limited set of actions within restricted environments. However, both approaches exhibit significant discrepancies from the open and executable requirements in real-world planning. In this paper, we propose a new planning task--open grounded planning. The primary objective of open grounded planning is to ask the model to generate an executable plan based on a variable action set, thereby ensuring the executability of the produced plan. To this end, we establishes a benchmark for open grounded planning spanning a wide range of domains. Then we test current state-of-the-art LLMs along with five planning approaches, revealing that existing LLMs and methods still struggle to address the challenges posed by grounded planning in open domains. The outcomes of this paper define and establish a foundational dataset for open grounded planning, and shed light on the potential challenges and future directions of LLM-based planning.
Read more6/6/2024
0
Grounding Language Models in Autonomous Loco-manipulation Tasks
Jin Wang, Nikos Tsagarakis
Humanoid robots with behavioral autonomy have consistently been regarded as ideal collaborators in our daily lives and promising representations of embodied intelligence. Compared to fixed-based robotic arms, humanoid robots offer a larger operational space while significantly increasing the difficulty of control and planning. Despite the rapid progress towards general-purpose humanoid robots, most studies remain focused on locomotion ability with few investigations into whole-body coordination and tasks planning, thus limiting the potential to demonstrate long-horizon tasks involving both mobility and manipulation under open-ended verbal instructions. In this work, we propose a novel framework that learns, selects, and plans behaviors based on tasks in different scenarios. We combine reinforcement learning (RL) with whole-body optimization to generate robot motions and store them into a motion library. We further leverage the planning and reasoning features of the large language model (LLM), constructing a hierarchical task graph that comprises a series of motion primitives to bridge lower-level execution with higher-level planning. Experiments in simulation and real-world using the CENTAURO robot show that the language model based planner can efficiently adapt to new loco-manipulation tasks, demonstrating high autonomy from free-text commands in unstructured scenes.
Read more9/4/2024