Hierarchical Training of Deep Neural Networks Using Early Exiting

Read original: arXiv:2303.02384 - Published 5/22/2024 by Yamin Sepehri, Pedram Pad, Ahmet Caner Yuzuguler, Pascal Frossard, L. Andrea Dunbar

🏋️

Overview

Deep neural networks provide high accuracy for vision tasks but require significant resources to train
Training often happens on cloud servers, which increases communication costs, runtime, and privacy concerns
This study proposes a novel hierarchical training method that uses "early exits" to separate the neural network architecture between edge and cloud workers

Plain English Explanation

This research looks at a way to make training deep neural networks more efficient and practical. Deep neural networks are very good at tasks like recognizing objects in images, but training them requires a lot of computing power and memory. Typically, this training is done on powerful cloud servers, which means the data has to be sent back and forth between the cloud and the devices (like phones or robots) that will use the trained model.

The researchers propose a new training method that splits the neural network into two parts: one part runs on the edge device, and the other part runs in the cloud. This "hierarchical" approach allows the edge device to do some of the work locally, which reduces the amount of data that needs to be sent to the cloud. It also helps protect the privacy of the data, since the raw input doesn't have to be shared with the cloud.

The key innovation is the use of "early exits" in the neural network. Normally, a neural network processes the input data all the way through the network to produce the final output. But with this new method, the network has several "exits" along the way that can produce intermediate results. The edge device can use these early exits to do some of the processing locally, before sending the data to the cloud for the rest of the computation.

This hierarchical approach with early exits helps reduce the overall training time and makes the training process more efficient, while still maintaining the high accuracy of the final model. This could be very useful for applications like mobile devices or robots that need to run powerful AI models but have limited computing resources.

Technical Explanation

The researchers propose a novel hierarchical training method for deep neural networks that uses "early exits" to distribute the computation between edge devices and cloud servers. Typically, deep neural networks are trained entirely on powerful cloud servers, which increases communication costs, runtime, and privacy concerns.

The key idea is to divide the neural network architecture into two parts: one that runs on the edge device, and one that runs in the cloud. The edge part of the network has several "early exit" points that can produce intermediate outputs before the full computation is completed. During training, the edge device performs the initial layers of the network and uses these early exits to produce partial results. It then sends these partial results to the cloud, which completes the remaining layers of the network.

This approach has several advantages. First, it reduces the amount of data that needs to be communicated between the edge and the cloud, which lowers the overall training time. Second, it allows the training to be performed in parallel on both the edge and cloud, further improving efficiency. Finally, it protects the privacy of the raw input data, since only the partial results are shared with the cloud.

The researchers evaluated this hierarchical training method on several neural network architectures and datasets, including VGG-16, ResNet-18, CIFAR-10, and Tiny ImageNet. The results show that this approach can reduce the training runtime by up to 81% compared to training the full network on the cloud, while maintaining negligible accuracy loss.

Critical Analysis

The researchers present a compelling approach to address the resource and privacy challenges of training deep neural networks on cloud servers. The use of early exits to distribute the computation between edge and cloud is a novel and promising idea.

One potential limitation is the need to carefully design the division of the network architecture between the edge and cloud. This may require some additional effort and experimentation to find the optimal configuration for a given application and hardware setup.

Additionally, the researchers only evaluated the method on computer vision tasks. It would be interesting to see how well it generalizes to other domains, such as natural language processing or speech recognition.

Another area for further research could be exploring ways to dynamically adjust the number of early exits used based on the available resources or the complexity of the input data. This could potentially lead to even greater efficiency gains.

Overall, this research presents a promising step towards making powerful deep learning models more accessible and practical for deployment on resource-constrained edge devices. The hierarchical training approach with early exits is an innovative solution that addresses important challenges in the field of edge computing and distributed AI.

Conclusion

This study introduces a novel hierarchical training method for deep neural networks that uses early exits to distribute the computation between edge and cloud workers. This approach reduces the communication costs, training runtime, and privacy concerns associated with training large neural networks entirely on cloud servers.

The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of this method, showing significant reductions in training time while maintaining high model accuracy. This work has important implications for enabling the deployment of advanced deep learning models on a wide range of edge devices, such as mobile phones, robots, and IoT sensors, which are increasingly important for emerging applications in areas like computer vision, natural language processing, and edge computing.

The hierarchical training with early exits represents an important step forward in making powerful deep neural networks more accessible and practical for real-world use cases, particularly in scenarios where data privacy, communication bandwidth, and computational resources are key concerns.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏋️

Hierarchical Training of Deep Neural Networks Using Early Exiting

Yamin Sepehri, Pedram Pad, Ahmet Caner Yuzuguler, Pascal Frossard, L. Andrea Dunbar

Deep neural networks provide state-of-the-art accuracy for vision tasks but they require significant resources for training. Thus, they are trained on cloud servers far from the edge devices that acquire the data. This issue increases communication cost, runtime and privacy concerns. In this study, a novel hierarchical training method for deep neural networks is proposed that uses early exits in a divided architecture between edge and cloud workers to reduce the communication cost, training runtime and privacy concerns. The method proposes a brand-new use case for early exits to separate the backward pass of neural networks between the edge and the cloud during the training phase. We address the issues of most available methods that due to the sequential nature of the training phase, cannot train the levels of hierarchy simultaneously or they do it with the cost of compromising privacy. In contrast, our method can use both edge and cloud workers simultaneously, does not share the raw input data with the cloud and does not require communication during the backward pass. Several simulations and on-device experiments for different neural network architectures demonstrate the effectiveness of this method. It is shown that the proposed method reduces the training runtime for VGG-16 and ResNet-18 architectures by 29% and 61% in CIFAR-10 classification and by 25% and 81% in Tiny ImageNet classification when the communication with the cloud is done over a low bit rate channel. This gain in the runtime is achieved whilst the accuracy drop is negligible. This method is advantageous for online learning of high-accuracy deep neural networks on sensor-holding low-resource devices such as mobile phones or robots as a part of an edge-cloud system, making them more flexible in facing new tasks and classes of data.

5/22/2024

PriPHiT: Privacy-Preserving Hierarchical Training of Deep Neural Networks

Yamin Sepehri, Pedram Pad, Pascal Frossard, L. Andrea Dunbar

The training phase of deep neural networks requires substantial resources and as such is often performed on cloud servers. However, this raises privacy concerns when the training dataset contains sensitive content, e.g., face images. In this work, we propose a method to perform the training phase of a deep learning model on both an edge device and a cloud server that prevents sensitive content being transmitted to the cloud while retaining the desired information. The proposed privacy-preserving method uses adversarial early exits to suppress the sensitive content at the edge and transmits the task-relevant information to the cloud. This approach incorporates noise addition during the training phase to provide a differential privacy guarantee. We extensively test our method on different facial datasets with diverse face attributes using various deep learning architectures, showcasing its outstanding performance. We also demonstrate the effectiveness of privacy preservation through successful defenses against different white-box and deep reconstruction attacks.

8/12/2024

Early-Exit meets Model-Distributed Inference at Edge Networks

Marco Colocrese, Erdem Koyuncu, Hulya Seferoglu

Distributed inference techniques can be broadly classified into data-distributed and model-distributed schemes. In data-distributed inference (DDI), each worker carries the entire deep neural network (DNN) model but processes only a subset of the data. However, feeding the data to workers results in high communication costs, especially when the data is large. An emerging paradigm is model-distributed inference (MDI), where each worker carries only a subset of DNN layers. In MDI, a source device that has data processes a few layers of DNN and sends the output to a neighboring device, i.e., offloads the rest of the layers. This process ends when all layers are processed in a distributed manner. In this paper, we investigate the design and development of MDI with early-exit, which advocates that there is no need to process all the layers of a model for some data to reach the desired accuracy, i.e., we can exit the model without processing all the layers if target accuracy is reached. We design a framework MDI-Exit that adaptively determines early-exit and offloading policies as well as data admission at the source. Experimental results on a real-life testbed of NVIDIA Nano edge devices show that MDI-Exit processes more data when accuracy is fixed and results in higher accuracy for the fixed data rate.

8/13/2024

Joint or Disjoint: Mixing Training Regimes for Early-Exit Models

Bart{l}omiej Krzepkowski, Monika Michaluk, Franciszek Szarwacki, Piotr Kubaty, Jary Pomponi, Tomasz Trzci'nski, Bartosz W'ojcik, Kamil Adamczewski

Early exits are an important efficiency mechanism integrated into deep neural networks that allows for the termination of the network's forward pass before processing through all its layers. By allowing early halting of the inference process for less complex inputs that reached high confidence, early exits significantly reduce the amount of computation required. Early exit methods add trainable internal classifiers which leads to more intricacy in the training process. However, there is no consistent verification of the approaches of training of early exit methods, and no unified scheme of training such models. Most early exit methods employ a training strategy that either simultaneously trains the backbone network and the exit heads or trains the exit heads separately. We propose a training approach where the backbone is initially trained on its own, followed by a phase where both the backbone and the exit heads are trained together. Thus, we advocate for organizing early-exit training strategies into three distinct categories, and then validate them for their performance and efficiency. In this benchmark, we perform both theoretical and empirical analysis of early-exit training regimes. We study the methods in terms of information flow, loss landscape and numerical rank of activations and gauge the suitability of regimes for various architectures and datasets.

7/22/2024