On the Identifiability of Switching Dynamical Systems
2305.15925
0
0
🏷️
Abstract
The identifiability of latent variable models has received increasing attention due to its relevance in interpretability and out-of-distribution generalisation. In this work, we study the identifiability of Switching Dynamical Systems, taking an initial step toward extending identifiability analysis to sequential latent variable models. We first prove the identifiability of Markov Switching Models, which commonly serve as the prior distribution for the continuous latent variables in Switching Dynamical Systems. We present identification conditions for first-order Markov dependency structures, whose transition distribution is parametrised via non-linear Gaussians. We then establish the identifiability of the latent variables and non-linear mappings in Switching Dynamical Systems up to affine transformations, by leveraging identifiability analysis techniques from identifiable deep latent variable models. We finally develop estimation algorithms for identifiable Switching Dynamical Systems. Throughout empirical studies, we demonstrate the practicality of identifiable Switching Dynamical Systems for segmenting high-dimensional time series such as videos, and showcase the use of identifiable Markov Switching Models for regime-dependent causal discovery in climate data.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the identifiability of Switching Dynamical Systems, a type of sequential latent variable model, which is important for interpretability and out-of-distribution generalization.
- It first proves the identifiability of Markov Switching Models, a common prior distribution for the continuous latent variables in Switching Dynamical Systems.
- The paper then establishes the identifiability of the latent variables and non-linear mappings in Switching Dynamical Systems up to affine transformations.
- Estimation algorithms for identifiable Switching Dynamical Systems are developed, and their practical applications are demonstrated through empirical studies.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on the concept of identifiability in the context of Switching Dynamical Systems, a type of machine learning model that deals with sequential data and hidden or latent variables. Identifiability is important because it means that the hidden factors in the model can be uniquely determined from the observed data, which is crucial for interpreting the model's outputs and applying it to new, out-of-sample situations.
The researchers first show that a specific type of Switching Dynamical System, called a Markov Switching Model, is identifiable. This means that the hidden "switching" between different states in the model can be uniquely identified from the data. They then extend this result to show that the full Switching Dynamical System, including the non-linear mappings between the hidden variables and the observed data, is also identifiable up to affine transformations.
This work is an important step towards understanding the identifiability of more complex, sequential latent variable models, which can have applications in areas like causal discovery and time series analysis of high-dimensional data, such as video or climate data.
Technical Explanation
The paper first proves the identifiability of Markov Switching Models, which are commonly used as the prior distribution for the continuous latent variables in Switching Dynamical Systems. The researchers present identification conditions for first-order Markov dependency structures, where the transition distribution is parametrized using non-linear Gaussian functions.
Building on this, the paper then establishes the identifiability of the latent variables and non-linear mappings in Switching Dynamical Systems up to affine transformations. This is achieved by leveraging identifiability analysis techniques from the literature on identifiable deep latent variable models.
Finally, the researchers develop estimation algorithms for identifiable Switching Dynamical Systems and demonstrate their practical applications through empirical studies. These studies showcase the use of identifiable Switching Dynamical Systems for segmenting high-dimensional time series data, such as videos, as well as the application of identifiable Markov Switching Models for regime-dependent causal discovery in climate data.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a rigorous theoretical analysis of the identifiability of Switching Dynamical Systems, which is an important step forward in understanding the properties of these types of sequential latent variable models. The researchers have leveraged techniques from the literature on identifiable deep latent variable models to extend the identifiability analysis to this more complex sequential setting.
However, the paper does not discuss the potential limitations of the identifiability conditions they establish, nor does it address the computational challenges that may arise in estimating these models in practice. Additionally, the empirical demonstrations, while showcasing the practical utility of the methods, do not provide a comprehensive evaluation of the model's performance compared to alternative approaches.
It would be useful for future research to further investigate the robustness of the identifiability conditions to model misspecification, as well as to explore the trade-offs between model complexity, identifiability, and practical performance. Addressing these aspects could help strengthen the practical applicability of the proposed methods.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important contribution to the understanding of identifiability in sequential latent variable models, specifically Switching Dynamical Systems. By establishing the identifiability of Markov Switching Models and the full Switching Dynamical System, the researchers have taken a significant step towards enabling the interpretability and out-of-distribution generalization of these types of models.
The development of estimation algorithms and the demonstration of practical applications, such as in video segmentation and climate data analysis, suggest that identifiable Switching Dynamical Systems could have a wide range of real-world applications. This work lays the foundation for further research in this area, which could lead to advancements in areas like causal discovery, time series analysis, and the interpretability of complex machine learning models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Identifying latent state transition in non-linear dynamical systems
c{C}au{g}lar H{i}zl{i}, c{C}au{g}atay Y{i}ld{i}z, Matthias Bethge, ST John, Pekka Marttinen
0
0
This work aims to improve generalization and interpretability of dynamical systems by recovering the underlying lower-dimensional latent states and their time evolutions. Previous work on disentangled representation learning within the realm of dynamical systems focused on the latent states, possibly with linear transition approximations. As such, they cannot identify nonlinear transition dynamics, and hence fail to reliably predict complex future behavior. Inspired by the advances in nonlinear ICA, we propose a state-space modeling framework in which we can identify not just the latent states but also the unknown transition function that maps the past states to the present. We introduce a practical algorithm based on variational auto-encoders and empirically demonstrate in realistic synthetic settings that we can (i) recover latent state dynamics with high accuracy, (ii) correspondingly achieve high future prediction accuracy, and (iii) adapt fast to new environments.
6/7/2024
A least-square method for non-asymptotic identification in linear switching control
Haoyuan Sun, Ali Jadbabaie
0
0
The focus of this paper is on linear system identification in the setting where it is known that the underlying partially-observed linear dynamical system lies within a finite collection of known candidate models. We first consider the problem of identification from a given trajectory, which in this setting reduces to identifying the index of the true model with high probability. We characterize the finite-time sample complexity of this problem by leveraging recent advances in the non-asymptotic analysis of linear least-square methods in the literature. In comparison to the earlier results that assume no prior knowledge of the system, our approach takes advantage of the smaller hypothesis class and leads to the design of a learner with a dimension-free sample complexity bound. Next, we consider the switching control of linear systems, where there is a candidate controller for each of the candidate models and data is collected through interaction of the system with a collection of potentially destabilizing controllers. We develop a dimension-dependent criterion that can detect those destabilizing controllers in finite time. By leveraging these results, we propose a data-driven switching strategy that identifies the unknown parameters of the underlying system. We then provide a non-asymptotic analysis of its performance and discuss its implications on the classical method of estimator-based supervisory control.
4/15/2024
Identifiability of Differential-Algebraic Systems
Arthur N. Montanari, Franc{c}ois Lamoline, Robert Bereza, Jorge Gonc{c}alves
0
0
Data-driven modeling of dynamical systems often faces numerous data-related challenges. A fundamental requirement is the existence of a unique set of parameters for a chosen model structure, an issue commonly referred to as identifiability. Although this problem is well studied for ordinary differential equations (ODEs), few studies have focused on the more general class of systems described by differential-algebraic equations (DAEs). Examples of DAEs include dynamical systems with algebraic equations representing conservation laws or approximating fast dynamics. This work introduces a novel identifiability test for models characterized by nonlinear DAEs. Unlike previous approaches, our test only requires prior knowledge of the system equations and does not need nonlinear transformation, index reduction, or numerical integration of the DAEs. We employed our identifiability analysis across a diverse range of DAE models, illustrating how system identifiability depends on the choices of sensors, experimental conditions, and model structures. Given the added challenges involved in identifying DAEs when compared to ODEs, we anticipate that our findings will have broad applicability and contribute significantly to the development and validation of data-driven methods for DAEs and other structure-preserving models.
5/24/2024
👀
Marrying Causal Representation Learning with Dynamical Systems for Science
Dingling Yao, Caroline Muller, Francesco Locatello
0
0
Causal representation learning promises to extend causal models to hidden causal variables from raw entangled measurements. However, most progress has focused on proving identifiability results in different settings, and we are not aware of any successful real-world application. At the same time, the field of dynamical systems benefited from deep learning and scaled to countless applications but does not allow parameter identification. In this paper, we draw a clear connection between the two and their key assumptions, allowing us to apply identifiable methods developed in causal representation learning to dynamical systems. At the same time, we can leverage scalable differentiable solvers developed for differential equations to build models that are both identifiable and practical. Overall, we learn explicitly controllable models that isolate the trajectory-specific parameters for further downstream tasks such as out-of-distribution classification or treatment effect estimation. We experiment with a wind simulator with partially known factors of variation. We also apply the resulting model to real-world climate data and successfully answer downstream causal questions in line with existing literature on climate change.
5/24/2024