Improving Prototypical Part Networks with Reward Reweighing, Reselection, and Retraining
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes improvements to Prototypical Part Networks (ProtoPNets), which are interpretable image classification models that use a set of part prototypes to represent the key visual elements in an image.
- The authors introduce three key modifications: reward reweighing, reselection, and retraining, which aim to improve the performance and interpretability of ProtoPNets.
- The proposed techniques are evaluated on several image classification datasets, demonstrating improvements over the original ProtoPNet model.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses ways to make Prototypical Part Networks (ProtoPNets) - a type of interpretable image classification model - better. ProtoPNets work by identifying the key visual elements, or "parts," that make up an image and using these parts to classify the image.
The authors suggest three main improvements:
- Reward Reweighing: Adjusting the rewards given to the model during training to better match the importance of different parts of the image.
- Reselection: Allowing the model to dynamically select the most relevant parts during inference, rather than using a fixed set.
- Retraining: Further training the model to improve its performance and interpretability.
These modifications aim to make ProtoPNets more accurate and better able to explain their decisions in a way that is easy for humans to understand. The authors test their ideas on several image classification datasets and show that the improved ProtoPNet models outperform the original version.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on improving Prototypical Part Networks (ProtoPNets), a type of interpretable image classifier that represents key visual elements as a set of "part prototypes." The authors propose three main modifications to ProtoPNets:
-
Reward Reweighing: The original ProtoPNet model uses a fixed reward structure during training, which may not align with the importance of different parts of the image. The authors introduce a reward reweighing scheme that dynamically adjusts the rewards to better match the visual significance of each part.
-
Reselection: In the original ProtoPNet, the set of part prototypes used for classification is fixed. The authors propose a "reselection" approach that allows the model to dynamically select the most relevant parts during inference.
-
Retraining: After applying the reward reweighing and reselection techniques, the authors further retrain the ProtoPNet model to improve its performance and interpretability.
The authors evaluate their improved ProtoPNet model on several image classification datasets, including CIFAR-10, CUB-200-2011, and MNIST. Their results show that the improved ProtoPNet models outperform the original version in terms of classification accuracy and interpretability, as measured by the Eyes of the Hawk, Ears of the Fox (EHEF) metric.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful approach to improving the performance and interpretability of ProtoPNets, a type of interpretable image classifier. The proposed modifications, including reward reweighing, reselection, and retraining, seem well-justified and the experimental results are promising.
One potential limitation of the work is that the improvements are evaluated on relatively simple image classification datasets, and it would be valuable to see how the techniques perform on more complex or real-world tasks. Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the specific mechanisms by which the part prototypes are selected and weighted, and how this relates to human interpretability.
It would also be interesting to see a more detailed comparison between the improved ProtoPNet models and other state-of-the-art interpretable image classification approaches, such as MapProtoNet and LucidPPN. This could help better situate the contributions of the current work and identify areas for further research.
Overall, the paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of interpretable machine learning, and the proposed techniques could have significant implications for the development of more transparent and trustworthy image classification systems.
Conclusion
The paper introduces three key improvements to Prototypical Part Networks (ProtoPNets), a type of interpretable image classification model: reward reweighing, reselection, and retraining. These modifications aim to enhance the performance and interpretability of ProtoPNets, allowing the models to better identify and leverage the most relevant visual elements in an image.
The authors' evaluation of the improved ProtoPNet models on several image classification datasets demonstrates the effectiveness of their approach, with the modified models outperforming the original ProtoPNet in terms of accuracy and interpretability. These findings have important implications for the development of more transparent and trustworthy AI systems, which can provide users with a clear understanding of the reasoning behind their predictions.
Overall, this paper represents a valuable contribution to the field of interpretable machine learning, and the proposed techniques could inspire further research and advancements in this critical area of AI development.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Improving Prototypical Part Networks with Reward Reweighing, Reselection, and Retraining
Aaron J. Li, Robin Netzorg, Zhihan Cheng, Zhuoqin Zhang, Bin Yu
In recent years, work has gone into developing deep interpretable methods for image classification that clearly attributes a model's output to specific features of the data. One such of these methods is the Prototypical Part Network (ProtoPNet), which attempts to classify images based on meaningful parts of the input. While this architecture is able to produce visually interpretable classifications, it often learns to classify based on parts of the image that are not semantically meaningful. To address this problem, we propose the Reward Reweighing, Reselecting, and Retraining (R3) post-processing framework, which performs three additional corrective updates to a pretrained ProtoPNet in an offline and efficient manner. The first two steps involve learning a reward model based on collected human feedback and then aligning the prototypes with human preferences. The final step is retraining, which realigns the base features and the classifier layer of the original model with the updated prototypes. We find that our R3 framework consistently improves both the interpretability and the predictive accuracy of ProtoPNet and its variants.
Read more6/5/2024
0
This Looks Better than That: Better Interpretable Models with ProtoPNeXt
Frank Willard, Luke Moffett, Emmanuel Mokel, Jon Donnelly, Stark Guo, Julia Yang, Giyoung Kim, Alina Jade Barnett, Cynthia Rudin
Prototypical-part models are a popular interpretable alternative to black-box deep learning models for computer vision. However, they are difficult to train, with high sensitivity to hyperparameter tuning, inhibiting their application to new datasets and our understanding of which methods truly improve their performance. To facilitate the careful study of prototypical-part networks (ProtoPNets), we create a new framework for integrating components of prototypical-part models -- ProtoPNeXt. Using ProtoPNeXt, we show that applying Bayesian hyperparameter tuning and an angular prototype similarity metric to the original ProtoPNet is sufficient to produce new state-of-the-art accuracy for prototypical-part models on CUB-200 across multiple backbones. We further deploy this framework to jointly optimize for accuracy and prototype interpretability as measured by metrics included in ProtoPNeXt. Using the same resources, this produces models with substantially superior semantics and changes in accuracy between +1.3% and -1.5%. The code and trained models will be made publicly available upon publication.
Read more6/24/2024
🖼️
0
Deformable ProtoPNet: An Interpretable Image Classifier Using Deformable Prototypes
Jon Donnelly, Alina Jade Barnett, Chaofan Chen
We present a deformable prototypical part network (Deformable ProtoPNet), an interpretable image classifier that integrates the power of deep learning and the interpretability of case-based reasoning. This model classifies input images by comparing them with prototypes learned during training, yielding explanations in the form of this looks like that. However, while previous methods use spatially rigid prototypes, we address this shortcoming by proposing spatially flexible prototypes. Each prototype is made up of several prototypical parts that adaptively change their relative spatial positions depending on the input image. Consequently, a Deformable ProtoPNet can explicitly capture pose variations and context, improving both model accuracy and the richness of explanations provided. Compared to other case-based interpretable models using prototypes, our approach achieves state-of-the-art accuracy and gives an explanation with greater context. The code is available at https://github.com/jdonnelly36/Deformable-ProtoPNet.
Read more5/6/2024
🖼️
0
ProtoArgNet: Interpretable Image Classification with Super-Prototypes and Argumentation [Technical Report]
Hamed Ayoobi, Nico Potyka, Francesca Toni
We propose ProtoArgNet, a novel interpretable deep neural architecture for image classification in the spirit of prototypical-part-learning as found, e.g., in ProtoPNet. While earlier approaches associate every class with multiple prototypical-parts, ProtoArgNet uses super-prototypes that combine prototypical-parts into a unified class representation. This is done by combining local activations of prototypes in an MLP-like manner, enabling the localization of prototypes and learning (non-linear) spatial relationships among them. By leveraging a form of argumentation, ProtoArgNet is capable of providing both supporting (i.e. `this looks like that') and attacking (i.e. `this differs from that') explanations. We demonstrate on several datasets that ProtoArgNet outperforms state-of-the-art prototypical-part-learning approaches. Moreover, the argumentation component in ProtoArgNet is customisable to the user's cognitive requirements by a process of sparsification, which leads to more compact explanations compared to state-of-the-art approaches.
Read more8/23/2024