An introduction to reinforcement learning for neuroscience

Overview

• Reinforcement learning has a long history in neuroscience, from early work on dopamine as a reward prediction error signal to recent advancements in deep reinforcement learning.
• There is a tight link between theoretical developments in reinforcement learning and neuroscientific findings.
• The theories describing experimental data have become increasingly complex and difficult to navigate.
• This review covers the basic theory of classical reinforcement learning and introduces modern deep reinforcement learning methods with applications in systems neuroscience.

Plain English Explanation

Reinforcement learning is a type of machine learning where an agent learns to take actions in an environment to maximize a reward. Neuroscientists have long been interested in reinforcement learning because it can help explain how the brain processes rewards and learns from experience.

The early work in this field focused on the role of dopamine, a neurotransmitter in the brain, in signaling reward prediction errors - the difference between expected and actual rewards. This formed the basis of a reinforcement learning technique called temporal difference learning.

Over time, the theories and models in reinforcement learning have become more sophisticated, often drawing inspiration from the latest developments in machine learning, particularly the rise of deep learning. Deep reinforcement learning combines deep neural networks with reinforcement learning algorithms, allowing agents to learn complex behaviors by interacting with their environment.

This review paper provides an introduction to these modern deep reinforcement learning methods and how they have been applied to study various learning phenomena in the brain, such as meta-reinforcement learning (where an agent learns to learn) and distributional reinforcement learning (where the agent learns the full distribution of possible rewards, not just the expected value).

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by providing an overview of the classical reinforcement learning problem and the core algorithms, such as temporal difference learning. It then discusses the distinction between "model-free" and "model-based" reinforcement learning, where the former learns directly from experience, and the latter learns an internal model of the environment.

The review also covers intermediate methods, such as DYNA and successor representations, that combine elements of both model-free and model-based approaches.

Throughout these sections, the authors highlight the close parallels between the machine learning methods and related work in experimental and theoretical neuroscience.

The paper then provides an introduction to deep reinforcement learning, explaining how these modern techniques have been used to model various learning phenomena in systems neuroscience, such as meta-reinforcement learning and distributional reinforcement learning.

The authors also provide code and figures to illustrate the methods discussed in the paper.

Critical Analysis

The paper does a commendable job of covering a wide range of topics in a relatively concise manner, making it a valuable resource for those interested in the intersection of reinforcement learning and neuroscience.

However, as the authors acknowledge, the theories and models described have become increasingly complex, which can be a challenge for readers unfamiliar with the field. The paper could have benefited from more in-depth explanations or examples to help the reader fully grasp the nuances of the various approaches.

Additionally, while the paper touches on some potential applications of these methods in neuroscience, it does not delve deeply into the specific insights or implications of the research. Further discussion on how these techniques can advance our understanding of the brain and inform neuroscientific research would have been a valuable addition.

Conclusion

This review paper provides a comprehensive overview of the evolution of reinforcement learning from its early foundations in neuroscience to the modern deep reinforcement learning techniques that are now being applied to study various learning phenomena in the brain.

By highlighting the tight coupling between theoretical advances in machine learning and neuroscientific findings, the paper underscores the importance of cross-pollination between these fields. As reinforcement learning continues to grow in sophistication, it will likely play an increasingly crucial role in advancing our understanding of the neural mechanisms underlying learning and decision-making.