IW-GAE: Importance Weighted Group Accuracy Estimation for Improved Calibration and Model Selection in Unsupervised Domain Adaptation
0
🎯
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Distribution shifts pose significant challenges for model calibration and model selection tasks in the unsupervised domain adaptation problem.
- The goal is to perform well in a distribution shifted domain without labels.
- The researchers tackle these challenges by developing a novel importance weighted group accuracy estimator.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models are often trained on one set of data, but then need to be used on a different set of data. This can lead to performance issues, as the new data may have a different "distribution" or pattern compared to the original training data.
The researchers in this paper focus on a specific problem called "unsupervised domain adaptation." Here, the goal is to have a model perform well on a new set of data, even though that data has a different distribution and there are no labeled examples available from the new domain.
To address this challenge, the researchers developed a new technique to estimate the "group accuracy" of the model on the new data. This allows them to better calibrate the model and select the best version of the model, even without having labels for the new data. Their experiments show this approach can significantly improve performance compared to previous methods.
Technical Explanation
The key contribution of this work is the development of a novel importance weighted group accuracy estimator to tackle the difficulties posed by distribution shifts in the unsupervised domain adaptation problem.
The researchers formulate an optimization problem to find an importance weight that leads to an accurate group accuracy estimation, with theoretical analyses to support their approach. This provides a new perspective on addressing the model calibration and model selection tasks, compared to prior importance weighting techniques.
The experiments demonstrate significant improvements over state-of-the-art, with a 22% boost in the model calibration task and a 14% improvement in the model selection task. This suggests the value of the proposed group accuracy estimation approach for handling distribution shifts.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough technical explanation and rigorous experimental evaluation of the proposed importance weighted group accuracy estimator. However, the analysis is limited to the specific unsupervised domain adaptation setting.
It would be helpful to understand how this technique might generalize to other distribution shift scenarios, such as pairwise alignment for graph domain adaptation or boosting fair classifier generalization. Additionally, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or failure modes of the approach.
Further research could explore the robustness of the method to different types of distribution shifts, as well as compare it to other techniques for handling distribution shift in the absence of labeled data.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel importance weighted group accuracy estimator to address the challenges of distribution shifts in unsupervised domain adaptation. By formulating an optimization problem to find the right importance weights, the researchers are able to significantly improve model calibration and selection performance compared to prior state-of-the-art methods.
The technical insights and empirical results suggest this is a promising approach for handling distribution shifts in machine learning applications where labeled data is scarce or unavailable in the target domain. Further exploration of the generalizability and limitations of the technique could lead to even broader impact.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🎯
0
IW-GAE: Importance Weighted Group Accuracy Estimation for Improved Calibration and Model Selection in Unsupervised Domain Adaptation
Taejong Joo, Diego Klabjan
Distribution shifts pose significant challenges for model calibration and model selection tasks in the unsupervised domain adaptation problem -- a scenario where the goal is to perform well in a distribution shifted domain without labels. In this work, we tackle difficulties coming from distribution shifts by developing a novel importance weighted group accuracy estimator. Specifically, we present a new perspective of addressing the model calibration and model selection tasks by estimating the group accuracy. Then, we formulate an optimization problem for finding an importance weight that leads to an accurate group accuracy estimation with theoretical analyses. Our extensive experiments show that our approach improves state-of-the-art performances by 22% in the model calibration task and 14% in the model selection task.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Calibration of Network Confidence for Unsupervised Domain Adaptation Using Estimated Accuracy
Coby Penso, Jacob Goldberger
This study addresses the problem of calibrating network confidence while adapting a model that was originally trained on a source domain to a target domain using unlabeled samples from the target domain. The absence of labels from the target domain makes it impossible to directly calibrate the adapted network on the target domain. To tackle this challenge, we introduce a calibration procedure that relies on estimating the network's accuracy on the target domain. The network accuracy is first computed on the labeled source data and then is modified to represent the actual accuracy of the model on the target domain. The proposed algorithm calibrates the prediction confidence directly in the target domain by minimizing the disparity between the estimated accuracy and the computed confidence. The experimental results show that our method significantly outperforms existing methods, which rely on importance weighting, across several standard datasets.
Read more9/9/2024
0
Gradient-based Class Weighting for Unsupervised Domain Adaptation in Dense Prediction Visual Tasks
Roberto Alcover-Couso, Marcos Escudero-Vi~nolo, Juan C. SanMiguel, Jesus Besc'os
In unsupervised domain adaptation (UDA), where models are trained on source data (e.g., synthetic) and adapted to target data (e.g., real-world) without target annotations, addressing the challenge of significant class imbalance remains an open issue. Despite considerable progress in bridging the domain gap, existing methods often experience performance degradation when confronted with highly imbalanced dense prediction visual tasks like semantic and panoptic segmentation. This discrepancy becomes especially pronounced due to the lack of equivalent priors between the source and target domains, turning class imbalanced techniques used for other areas (e.g., image classification) ineffective in UDA scenarios. This paper proposes a class-imbalance mitigation strategy that incorporates class-weights into the UDA learning losses, but with the novelty of estimating these weights dynamically through the loss gradient, defining a Gradient-based class weighting (GBW) learning. GBW naturally increases the contribution of classes whose learning is hindered by large-represented classes, and has the advantage of being able to automatically and quickly adapt to the iteration training outcomes, avoiding explicitly curricular learning patterns common in loss-weighing strategies. Extensive experimentation validates the effectiveness of GBW across architectures (convolutional and transformer), UDA strategies (adversarial, self-training and entropy minimization), tasks (semantic and panoptic segmentation), and datasets (GTA and Synthia). Analysing the source of advantage, GBW consistently increases the recall of low represented classes.
Read more7/2/2024
📉
0
Sharp analysis of out-of-distribution error for importance-weighted estimators in the overparameterized regime
Kuo-Wei Lai, Vidya Muthukumar
Overparameterized models that achieve zero training error are observed to generalize well on average, but degrade in performance when faced with data that is under-represented in the training sample. In this work, we study an overparameterized Gaussian mixture model imbued with a spurious feature, and sharply analyze the in-distribution and out-of-distribution test error of a cost-sensitive interpolating solution that incorporates importance weights. Compared to recent work Wang et al. (2021), Behnia et al. (2022), our analysis is sharp with matching upper and lower bounds, and significantly weakens required assumptions on data dimensionality. Our error characterizations also apply to any choice of importance weights and unveil a novel tradeoff between worst-case robustness to distribution shift and average accuracy as a function of the importance weight magnitude.
Read more5/13/2024