Just CHOP: Embarrassingly Simple LLM Compression

Read original: arXiv:2305.14864 - Published 7/11/2024 by Ananya Harsh Jha, Tom Sherborne, Evan Pete Walsh, Dirk Groeneveld, Emma Strubell, Iz Beltagy

👨‍🏫

Overview

The paper explores methods to reduce the computational footprint of large language models (LLMs) while maintaining their powerful few-shot and zero-shot reasoning capabilities.
It focuses on a critical step in the compression process, the pretrain-then-finetune paradigm, which has been largely overlooked when adapting existing pruning strategies to LLMs or proposing new ones.
The authors introduce a method called "LayerChop" that involves deterministically removing layers from a model followed by task-agnostic finetuning of the remaining weights through continued self-supervised pretraining.
The paper shows that this simple pruning technique outperforms structured and even semi-structured compression of 7B-scale models while being more inference efficient.
It also demonstrates that distillation, which has been effective for task-agnostic compression of smaller BERT-style models, becomes less efficient compared to the authors' pruning approach at this scale.

Plain English Explanation

Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 and BERT have made remarkable progress in natural language processing, enabling us to perform complex tasks with just a few examples or even without any examples at all (zero-shot). However, these powerful models come with a high computational cost, making them challenging to deploy in real-world applications.

The authors of this paper have developed a technique called "LayerChop" that aims to reduce the computational footprint of LLMs while preserving their impressive capabilities. The key idea is to remove unnecessary layers from the model in a systematic way, followed by a process called "finetuning" where the remaining parts of the model are further trained on a large amount of text data.

This approach is remarkably simple, yet it outperforms more complex compression techniques like quantization (reducing the precision of the model's parameters) and structured pruning (removing entire channels or features from the model) when applied to 7 billion-parameter LLMs. The authors also show that a technique called "distillation," which has been effective for compressing smaller language models, becomes less efficient at this larger scale compared to their pruning approach.

The significance of this work is that it provides a practical way to make LLMs more deployable in real-world applications, such as powering chatbots, language translation, and summarization tools, without sacrificing their impressive performance. By reducing the computational burden, these models can be run on less powerful hardware, making them more accessible and affordable for a wider range of use cases.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on the critical step of the pretrain-then-finetune paradigm when adapting existing pruning strategies or proposing new ones for compressing large language models (LLMs). The authors introduce a simple yet effective method called "LayerChop" that involves deterministically removing layers from a pre-trained LLM, followed by task-agnostic finetuning of the remaining weights through continued self-supervised pretraining.

The authors demonstrate that this approach outperforms structured and even semi-structured compression techniques for 7 billion-parameter LLMs, while also being more inference efficient. They show that at this scale, distillation, a technique that has been super effective in task-agnostic compression of smaller BERT-style models, becomes less efficient compared to their simple pruning technique.

The experiments in the paper are designed to compare the performance and efficiency of different compression methods, including LayerChop, structured pruning, and distillation. The authors evaluate the models on a range of natural language processing tasks, such as question answering, natural language inference, and text generation, to assess their zero-shot and few-shot reasoning capabilities.

The key insights from the paper are:

Embarrassingly simple layer pruning coupled with an extended language model pretraining as the finetuning phase can produce state-of-the-art results against structured and even semi-structured compression of 7B-scale models.
At this scale, distillation, which has been super effective in task-agnostic compression of smaller BERT-style models, becomes inefficient against the authors' simple pruning technique.
The proposed LayerChop method is more inference efficient than other compression approaches while maintaining zero-shot performance.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to reducing the computational footprint of large language models, but there are a few caveats and areas for further research that could be explored:

Generalization to Larger Models: The paper focuses on 7 billion-parameter models, but it would be valuable to see how the LayerChop method scales to even larger LLMs, such as the 175 billion-parameter GPT-3, to ensure its effectiveness at the largest scales.
Transferability to Other Domains: The experiments in the paper are limited to natural language processing tasks. It would be interesting to see how the LayerChop method performs when applied to LLMs trained on other domains, such as computer vision or multimodal tasks.
Exploration of Adaptive Pruning Strategies: The current LayerChop method uses a deterministic layer removal approach. It could be worth exploring more adaptive pruning strategies that dynamically identify and remove redundant layers based on the specific characteristics of the model and the target task.
Combination with Other Compression Techniques: The paper focuses on the LayerChop method, but it would be valuable to investigate how it could be combined with other compression techniques, such as quantization or structured pruning, to achieve even greater compression while maintaining performance.

Overall, the paper presents a novel and effective approach to compressing large language models, and the authors' findings could have significant implications for the deployment of these powerful models in real-world applications.

Conclusion

The paper introduces a simple yet effective method called "LayerChop" that can dramatically reduce the computational footprint of large language models (LLMs) without sacrificing their impressive zero-shot and few-shot reasoning capabilities. By systematically removing unnecessary layers from pre-trained LLMs and then fine-tuning the remaining weights through continued self-supervised pretraining, the authors have developed a practical approach to making these powerful models more deployable in real-world applications.

The key significance of this work is that it provides a way to make LLMs more accessible and affordable, as the reduced computational burden allows them to be run on less powerful hardware. This could enable a wider range of use cases, from powering advanced chatbots and language translation tools to summarization and content generation applications. As the field of natural language processing continues to advance, techniques like LayerChop will be crucial for bridging the gap between research breakthroughs and practical deployment.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

👨‍🏫

Just CHOP: Embarrassingly Simple LLM Compression

Ananya Harsh Jha, Tom Sherborne, Evan Pete Walsh, Dirk Groeneveld, Emma Strubell, Iz Beltagy

Large language models (LLMs) enable unparalleled few- and zero-shot reasoning capabilities but at a high computational footprint. A growing assortment of methods for compression promises to reduce the computational burden of LLMs in deployment, but so far, only quantization approaches have been demonstrated to be effective for LLM compression while maintaining zero-shot performance. A critical step in the compression process, the pretrain-then-finetune paradigm, has largely been overlooked when adapting existing pruning strategies to LLMs or proposing new ones. In this work, we show that embarrassingly simple layer pruning coupled with an extended language model pretraining as the finetuning phase produces state-of-the-art results against structured and even semi-structured compression of models at a 7B scale while being more inference efficient. We call this method LayerChop, where we deterministically remove layers from a model followed by task-agnostic finetuning of the remaining weights by continued self-supervised pretraining. At this scale, we also show how distillation, which has been super effective in task-agnostic compression of smaller BERT-style models, becomes inefficient against our simple pruning technique.

7/11/2024

Compact Language Models via Pruning and Knowledge Distillation

Saurav Muralidharan, Sharath Turuvekere Sreenivas, Raviraj Joshi, Marcin Chochowski, Mostofa Patwary, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro, Jan Kautz, Pavlo Molchanov

Large language models (LLMs) targeting different deployment scales and sizes are currently produced by training each variant from scratch; this is extremely compute-intensive. In this paper, we investigate if pruning an existing LLM and then re-training it with a fraction (<3%) of the original training data can be a suitable alternative to repeated, full retraining. To this end, we develop a set of practical and effective compression best practices for LLMs that combine depth, width, attention and MLP pruning with knowledge distillation-based retraining; we arrive at these best practices through a detailed empirical exploration of pruning strategies for each axis, methods to combine axes, distillation strategies, and search techniques for arriving at optimal compressed architectures. We use this guide to compress the Nemotron-4 family of LLMs by a factor of 2-4x, and compare their performance to similarly-sized models on a variety of language modeling tasks. Deriving 8B and 4B models from an already pretrained 15B model using our approach requires up to 40x fewer training tokens per model compared to training from scratch; this results in compute cost savings of 1.8x for training the full model family (15B, 8B, and 4B). Minitron models exhibit up to a 16% improvement in MMLU scores compared to training from scratch, perform comparably to other community models such as Mistral 7B, Gemma 7B and Llama-3 8B, and outperform state-of-the-art compression techniques from the literature. We have open-sourced Minitron model weights on Huggingface, with corresponding supplementary material including example code available on GitHub.

7/23/2024

💬

Sheared LLaMA: Accelerating Language Model Pre-training via Structured Pruning

Mengzhou Xia, Tianyu Gao, Zhiyuan Zeng, Danqi Chen

The popularity of LLaMA (Touvron et al., 2023a;b) and other recently emerged moderate-sized large language models (LLMs) highlights the potential of building smaller yet powerful LLMs. Regardless, the cost of training such models from scratch on trillions of tokens remains high. In this work, we study structured pruning as an effective means to develop smaller LLMs from pre-trained, larger models. Our approach employs two key techniques: (1) targeted structured pruning, which prunes a larger model to a specified target shape by removing layers, heads, and intermediate and hidden dimensions in an end-to-end manner, and (2) dynamic batch loading, which dynamically updates the composition of sampled data in each training batch based on varying losses across different domains. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach by presenting the Sheared-LLaMA series, pruning the LLaMA2-7B model down to 1.3B and 2.7B parameters. Sheared-LLaMA models outperform state-of-the-art open-source models of equivalent sizes, such as Pythia, INCITE, OpenLLaMA and the concurrent TinyLlama models, on a wide range of downstream and instruction tuning evaluations, while requiring only 3% of compute compared to training such models from scratch. This work provides compelling evidence that leveraging existing LLMs with structured pruning is a far more cost-effective approach for building competitive small-scale LLMs

4/12/2024

Streamlining Redundant Layers to Compress Large Language Models

Xiaodong Chen, Yuxuan Hu, Jing Zhang, Yanling Wang, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen

This paper introduces LLM-Streamline, a novel layer pruning approach for large language models. It is based on the observation that different layers have varying impacts on hidden states, enabling the identification of less important layers. LLMStreamline comprises two parts: layer pruning, which removes consecutive layers with the lowest importance based on target sparsity, and layer replacement, where a lightweight network is trained to replace the pruned layers to mitigate performance loss. Additionally, a new metric called stability is proposed to address the limitations of accuracy in evaluating model compression. Experiments show that LLM-Streamline surpasses previous state-of-the-art pruning methods in both accuracy and stability.

5/24/2024