Large Language Model Agents for Improving Engagement with Behavior Change Interventions: Application to Digital Mindfulness
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores using large language model (LLM) agents to improve engagement with digital behavior change interventions, with a focus on mindfulness applications.
- The researchers investigate how LLM agents can provide social support and accountability to users, which is known to enhance the effectiveness of behavior change programs.
- The paper presents a framework for implementing LLM agents in digital mindfulness interventions and evaluates their impact on user engagement and well-being outcomes.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful artificial intelligence systems that can understand and generate human-like text. In this research, the authors explore how LLM agents can be used to improve people's engagement with digital programs designed to help them change their behavior, such as improving their mindfulness practice.
The key idea is that LLM agents can provide a form of "supportive accountability" to users of these digital programs. Just like having a supportive coach or friend can make it easier to stick to a new habit, the researchers hypothesize that an LLM agent that can engage in natural conversations and provide encouragement and guidance can enhance people's motivation and commitment to the behavior change intervention.
The researchers developed a framework for integrating LLM agents into a digital mindfulness program and tested its impact on user engagement and well-being outcomes. By using the LLM agent to have personalized conversations with users, provide feedback and advice, and foster a sense of social connection, the researchers aimed to help users form lasting mindfulness habits.
The results of their study suggest that the LLM agent approach can indeed boost engagement with the digital mindfulness program and lead to improvements in users' self-reported well-being and mindfulness levels. This indicates that incorporating LLM agents into behavior change interventions may be a promising way to increase their effectiveness and help people achieve their goals.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a framework for integrating large language model (LLM) agents into digital behavior change interventions, with a focus on a case study in digital mindfulness. The key idea is that LLM agents can provide a form of "supportive accountability" to users, which is known to enhance the effectiveness of behavior change programs.
The researchers developed an LLM-based agent that can engage in natural language conversations with users, provide personalized feedback and encouragement, and foster a sense of social connection. This agent was integrated into a digital mindfulness intervention, and its impact on user engagement and well-being outcomes was evaluated.
The study involved a randomized controlled trial where participants were assigned to either use the digital mindfulness program with the LLM agent or the program without the agent. The researchers measured user engagement (e.g., frequency of use, duration of sessions) as well as self-reported mindfulness and well-being outcomes.
The results showed that users who interacted with the LLM agent had significantly higher engagement with the digital mindfulness program compared to the control group. Additionally, the LLM agent group reported greater improvements in mindfulness and well-being over the course of the study.
The paper also discusses the potential of LLMs to support mental health interventions and enhance patient engagement in healthcare settings. The authors suggest that the integration of LLM agents into behavior change programs may be a promising approach for improving the effectiveness of these interventions and helping people achieve their goals.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling proof-of-concept for using LLM agents to enhance engagement with digital behavior change interventions. The researchers have developed a well-designed framework for integrating LLM agents into a mindfulness program and have demonstrated its positive impact on user engagement and well-being outcomes.
One potential limitation of the study is the relatively short duration of the intervention (8 weeks). It would be valuable to see if the observed benefits of the LLM agent approach can be sustained over a longer period, as behavior change is a complex and often challenging process.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much detail on the specific design and conversational capabilities of the LLM agent. More information on how the agent was trained, the types of interactions it had with users, and the underlying natural language processing techniques used would be helpful for understanding the technical implementation and its potential generalizability to other behavior change domains.
Another area for further exploration is the potential for personalization and adaptation of the LLM agent. The current study used a one-size-fits-all approach, but it may be beneficial to explore how the agent's responses and support could be tailored to individual user characteristics, preferences, and progress within the behavior change program.
Overall, this research represents an important step in understanding how LLM agents can be leveraged to improve the effectiveness of digital behavior change interventions. The findings suggest that this approach has significant potential and warrants further investigation and refinement.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates the promising potential of using large language model (LLM) agents to enhance engagement with digital behavior change interventions, using a case study in the domain of mindfulness practice.
The researchers developed a framework for integrating an LLM agent into a digital mindfulness program, which allowed the agent to engage in natural conversations with users, provide personalized feedback and encouragement, and foster a sense of social connection. Their evaluation showed that this LLM agent approach led to significantly higher user engagement and better well-being outcomes compared to the control group.
These findings suggest that incorporating LLM agents into behavior change programs may be a valuable strategy for improving their effectiveness and helping people achieve their goals. By providing a form of "supportive accountability," the LLM agent can help users stay motivated, develop lasting habits, and experience the benefits of the intervention.
The paper also highlights the broader potential for LLMs to support mental health and healthcare applications, beyond just behavior change. As the capabilities of these language models continue to advance, there is an increasing opportunity to leverage them in ways that can positively impact people's lives and well-being.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Large Language Model Agents for Improving Engagement with Behavior Change Interventions: Application to Digital Mindfulness
Harsh Kumar, Suhyeon Yoo, Angela Zavaleta Bernuy, Jiakai Shi, Huayin Luo, Joseph Williams, Anastasia Kuzminykh, Ashton Anderson, Rachel Kornfield
Although engagement in self-directed wellness exercises typically declines over time, integrating social support such as coaching can sustain it. However, traditional forms of support are often inaccessible due to the high costs and complex coordination. Large Language Models (LLMs) show promise in providing human-like dialogues that could emulate social support. Yet, in-depth, in situ investigations of LLMs to support behavior change remain underexplored. We conducted two randomized experiments to assess the impact of LLM agents on user engagement with mindfulness exercises. First, a single-session study, involved 502 crowdworkers; second, a three-week study, included 54 participants. We explored two types of LLM agents: one providing information and another facilitating self-reflection. Both agents enhanced users' intentions to practice mindfulness. However, only the information-providing LLM, featuring a friendly persona, significantly improved engagement with the exercises. Our findings suggest that specific LLM agents may bridge the social support gap in digital health interventions.
Read more7/19/2024
0
Supporting Physical Activity Behavior Change with LLM-Based Conversational Agents
Matthew Jorke, Shardul Sapkota, Lyndsea Warkenthien, Niklas Vainio, Paul Schmiedmayer, Emma Brunskill, James Landay
Physical activity has significant benefits to health, yet large portions of the population remain physically inactive. Mobile health applications show promising potential for low-cost, scalable physical activity promotion, but existing approaches are often insufficiently personalized to a user's context and life circumstances. In this work, we explore the potential for large language model (LLM) based conversational agents to motivate physical activity behavior change. Through formative interviews with 12 health professionals and 10 non-experts, we identify design considerations and opportunities for LLM health coaching. We present GPTCoach, a chatbot that implements an evidence-based health coaching program, uses counseling strategies from motivational interviewing, and can query and visualize health data from a wearable through tool use. We evaluate GPTCoach as a technology probe in a user study with 16 participants. Through quantitive and qualitative analyses, we find promising evidence that GPTCoach can adhere to a health coaching program while adopting a facilitative, supportive, and non-judgmental tone. We find more variable support for GPTCoach's ability to proactively make use of data in ways that foster motivation and empowerment. We conclude with a discussion of our findings, implications for future research, as well as risks and limitations.
Read more5/13/2024
0
Can AI Relate: Testing Large Language Model Response for Mental Health Support
Saadia Gabriel, Isha Puri, Xuhai Xu, Matteo Malgaroli, Marzyeh Ghassemi
Large language models (LLMs) are already being piloted for clinical use in hospital systems like NYU Langone, Dana-Farber and the NHS. A proposed deployment use case is psychotherapy, where a LLM-powered chatbot can treat a patient undergoing a mental health crisis. Deployment of LLMs for mental health response could hypothetically broaden access to psychotherapy and provide new possibilities for personalizing care. However, recent high-profile failures, like damaging dieting advice offered by the Tessa chatbot to patients with eating disorders, have led to doubt about their reliability in high-stakes and safety-critical settings. In this work, we develop an evaluation framework for determining whether LLM response is a viable and ethical path forward for the automation of mental health treatment. Using human evaluation with trained clinicians and automatic quality-of-care metrics grounded in psychology research, we compare the responses provided by peer-to-peer responders to those provided by a state-of-the-art LLM. We show that LLMs like GPT-4 use implicit and explicit cues to infer patient demographics like race. We then show that there are statistically significant discrepancies between patient subgroups: Responses to Black posters consistently have lower empathy than for any other demographic group (2%-13% lower than the control group). Promisingly, we do find that the manner in which responses are generated significantly impacts the quality of the response. We conclude by proposing safety guidelines for the potential deployment of LLMs for mental health response.
Read more5/21/2024
💬
0
Large Language Model for Mental Health: A Systematic Review
Zhijun Guo, Alvina Lai, Johan Hilge Thygesen, Joseph Farrington, Thomas Keen, Kezhi Li
Large language models (LLMs) have attracted significant attention for potential applications in digital health, while their application in mental health is subject to ongoing debate. This systematic review aims to evaluate the usage of LLMs in mental health, focusing on their strengths and limitations in early screening, digital interventions, and clinical applications. Adhering to PRISMA guidelines, we searched PubMed, IEEE Xplore, Scopus, JMIR, and ACM using keywords: 'mental health OR mental illness OR mental disorder OR psychiatry' AND 'large language models'. We included articles published between January 1, 2017, and April 30, 2024, excluding non-English articles. 30 articles were evaluated, which included research on mental health conditions and suicidal ideation detection through text (n=15), usage of LLMs for mental health conversational agents (CAs) (n=7), and other applications and evaluations of LLMs in mental health (n=18). LLMs exhibit substantial effectiveness in detecting mental health issues and providing accessible, de-stigmatized eHealth services. However, the current risks associated with the clinical use might surpass their benefits. The study identifies several significant issues: the lack of multilingual datasets annotated by experts, concerns about the accuracy and reliability of the content generated, challenges in interpretability due to the 'black box' nature of LLMs, and persistent ethical dilemmas. These include the lack of a clear ethical framework, concerns about data privacy, and the potential for over-reliance on LLMs by both therapists and patients, which could compromise traditional medical practice. Despite these issues, the rapid development of LLMs underscores their potential as new clinical aids, emphasizing the need for continued research and development in this area.
Read more8/14/2024