The Limits of Pure Exploration in POMDPs: When the Observation Entropy is Enough
2406.12795
0
0
Abstract
The problem of pure exploration in Markov decision processes has been cast as maximizing the entropy over the state distribution induced by the agent's policy, an objective that has been extensively studied. However, little attention has been dedicated to state entropy maximization under partial observability, despite the latter being ubiquitous in applications, e.g., finance and robotics, in which the agent only receives noisy observations of the true state governing the system's dynamics. How can we address state entropy maximization in those domains? In this paper, we study the simple approach of maximizing the entropy over observations in place of true latent states. First, we provide lower and upper bounds to the approximation of the true state entropy that only depends on some properties of the observation function. Then, we show how knowledge of the latter can be exploited to compute a principled regularization of the observation entropy to improve performance. With this work, we provide both a flexible approach to bring advances in state entropy maximization to the POMDP setting and a theoretical characterization of its intrinsic limits.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the limits of pure exploration in partially observable Markov decision processes (POMDPs), where the agent aims to learn the environment by maximizing the information gain about the underlying state.
- The authors show that in certain POMDPs, the observation entropy alone is a sufficient statistic for optimal exploration, without the need for explicit belief state tracking or policy optimization.
- They provide theoretical guarantees for this "observation entropy maximization" approach and demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments.
Plain English Explanation
In the world of artificial intelligence, agents (like robots or computer programs) often need to explore their environment to better understand it and make effective decisions. This is especially true in partially observable environments, where the agent can't directly see the full state of the world.
The authors of this paper look at a specific type of environment called a Partially Observable Markov Decision Process (POMDP). In these environments, the agent has to learn about the hidden state of the world by carefully choosing what to observe. The authors show that in some cases, the agent can focus solely on maximizing the entropy (or uncertainty) of the observations it receives, without needing to explicitly track the full belief state of the environment.
This "observation entropy maximization" approach has several advantages. It is computationally efficient and can provide provable performance guarantees for the agent's exploration. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach through experiments, showing that it can perform well in certain POMDP settings.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel observation entropy maximization approach for pure exploration in POMDPs. The authors show that in certain POMDP settings, the observation entropy alone is a sufficient statistic for optimal exploration, without the need for explicit belief state tracking or policy optimization.
Formally, the authors consider a POMDP with a state space S, action space A, observation space Z, transition function T, observation function O, and initial belief state b_0. They show that if the POMDP satisfies certain technical conditions, then maximizing the entropy of the observation distribution H(Z) is equivalent to maximizing the information gain about the hidden state.
The authors provide theoretical guarantees for this observation entropy maximization approach, including performance bounds and computational efficiency results. They also demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on various POMDP benchmarks.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and interesting approach to pure exploration in POMDPs, with strong theoretical guarantees and experimental results. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
Restrictive Assumptions: The authors assume that the POMDP satisfies certain technical conditions, which may not hold in all real-world scenarios. Further research is needed to understand the broader applicability of this approach.
-
Belief State Tracking: While the observation entropy maximization approach avoids explicit belief state tracking, it may still require some form of belief monitoring or estimation. The paper does not discuss the potential challenges or complexities involved in this process.
-
Exploration-Exploitation Tradeoff: The paper focuses solely on the pure exploration setting, but in many practical applications, the agent needs to balance exploration and exploitation. Extending this approach to the exploration-exploitation tradeoff would be an important next step.
-
Scalability and Generalization: The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the approach on relatively small-scale POMDP benchmarks. Further research is needed to assess the scalability and generalization of this approach to larger, more complex POMDP environments.
Overall, the paper presents a promising direction for pure exploration in POMDPs, but there are still some open questions and areas for further research to fully understand the limitations and potential of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel observation entropy maximization approach for pure exploration in POMDPs, which can provide provable performance guarantees and computational efficiency compared to traditional belief state tracking methods. While the approach has some restrictions and limitations, it represents an important step forward in understanding the fundamental limits of exploration in partially observable environments. Future research in this direction could lead to more robust and effective exploration strategies for a wide range of real-world AI applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
How to Explore with Belief: State Entropy Maximization in POMDPs
Riccardo Zamboni, Duilio Cirino, Marcello Restelli, Mirco Mutti
0
0
Recent works have studied *state entropy maximization* in reinforcement learning, in which the agent's objective is to learn a policy inducing high entropy over states visitation (Hazan et al., 2019). They typically assume full observability of the state of the system, so that the entropy of the observations is maximized. In practice, the agent may only get *partial* observations, e.g., a robot perceiving the state of a physical space through proximity sensors and cameras. A significant mismatch between the entropy over observations and true states of the system can arise in those settings. In this paper, we address the problem of entropy maximization over the *true states* with a decision policy conditioned on partial observations *only*. The latter is a generalization of POMDPs, which is intractable in general. We develop a memory and computationally efficient *policy gradient* method to address a first-order relaxation of the objective defined on *belief* states, providing various formal characterizations of approximation gaps, the optimization landscape, and the *hallucination* problem. This paper aims to generalize state entropy maximization to more realistic domains that meet the challenges of applications.
6/5/2024
🖼️
What should be observed for optimal reward in POMDPs?
Alyzia-Maria Konsta, Alberto Lluch Lafuente, Christoph Matheja
0
0
Partially observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) are a standard model for agents making decisions in uncertain environments. Most work on POMDPs focuses on synthesizing strategies based on the available capabilities. However, system designers can often control an agent's observation capabilities, e.g. by placing or selecting sensors. This raises the question of how one should select an agent's sensors cost-effectively such that it achieves the desired goals. In this paper, we study the novel optimal observability problem OOP: Given a POMDP M, how should one change M's observation capabilities within a fixed budget such that its (minimal) expected reward remains below a given threshold? We show that the problem is undecidable in general and decidable when considering positional strategies only. We present two algorithms for a decidable fragment of the OOP: one based on optimal strategies of M's underlying Markov decision process and one based on parameter synthesis with SMT. We report promising results for variants of typical examples from the POMDP literature.
5/20/2024
Measurement Simplification in rho-POMDP with Performance Guarantees
Tom Yotam, Vadim Indelman
0
0
Decision making under uncertainty is at the heart of any autonomous system acting with imperfect information. The cost of solving the decision making problem is exponential in the action and observation spaces, thus rendering it unfeasible for many online systems. This paper introduces a novel approach to efficient decision-making, by partitioning the high-dimensional observation space. Using the partitioned observation space, we formulate analytical bounds on the expected information-theoretic reward, for general belief distributions. These bounds are then used to plan efficiently while keeping performance guarantees. We show that the bounds are adaptive, computationally efficient, and that they converge to the original solution. We extend the partitioning paradigm and present a hierarchy of partitioned spaces that allows greater efficiency in planning. We then propose a specific variant of these bounds for Gaussian beliefs and show a theoretical performance improvement of at least a factor of 4. Finally, we compare our novel method to other state of the art algorithms in active SLAM scenarios, in simulation and in real experiments. In both cases we show a significant speed-up in planning with performance guarantees.
6/18/2024
🏅
Provable Representation with Efficient Planning for Partial Observable Reinforcement Learning
Hongming Zhang, Tongzheng Ren, Chenjun Xiao, Dale Schuurmans, Bo Dai
0
0
In most real-world reinforcement learning applications, state information is only partially observable, which breaks the Markov decision process assumption and leads to inferior performance for algorithms that conflate observations with state. Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), on the other hand, provide a general framework that allows for partial observability to be accounted for in learning, exploration and planning, but presents significant computational and statistical challenges. To address these difficulties, we develop a representation-based perspective that leads to a coherent framework and tractable algorithmic approach for practical reinforcement learning from partial observations. We provide a theoretical analysis for justifying the statistical efficiency of the proposed algorithm, and also empirically demonstrate the proposed algorithm can surpass state-of-the-art performance with partial observations across various benchmarks, advancing reliable reinforcement learning towards more practical applications.
6/12/2024