Linear Bellman Completeness Suffices for Efficient Online Reinforcement Learning with Few Actions
0
🏅
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates efficient online reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms that can learn an optimal policy with few actions.
- The key insight is that linear Bellman completeness - a property related to the expressiveness of the function approximator - is sufficient for efficient online RL, in contrast to previous results that required linear Bellman error minimization.
- The authors provide a general framework for analyzing efficient online RL under linear Bellman completeness, and show that this property holds in several settings, including multi-armed bandits, linear control, and more.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at how reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms can learn to make good decisions efficiently, even when the number of possible actions is small. Typically, RL algorithms need to explore a large number of actions to find the best one. However, the authors show that if the RL algorithm has a special property called "linear Bellman completeness", it can learn the optimal policy efficiently, even with a small number of actions.
Linear Bellman completeness means that the RL algorithm's model of the environment is expressive enough to capture the key relationships between states, actions, and rewards. This is a more relaxed requirement than previous RL methods that needed the algorithm to minimize a specific type of error, called the "linear Bellman error".
The paper provides a general framework for analyzing efficient online RL algorithms under linear Bellman completeness, and demonstrates that this property holds in several real-world settings, such as multi-armed bandits, linear control, and others. This means these RL algorithms can learn to make good decisions quickly, even with a limited number of actions to choose from.
Technical Explanation
The key insight of this paper is that linear Bellman completeness, rather than linear Bellman error minimization, is sufficient for efficient online reinforcement learning with few actions. The authors provide a general framework for analyzing efficient online RL under linear Bellman completeness, and show that this property holds in several settings, including multi-armed bandits, linear control, and more.
Formally, the authors consider an episodic Markov Decision Process (MDP) with a
This is in contrast to previous results that required linear Bellman error minimization, which is a more stringent condition. The authors demonstrate that linear Bellman completeness holds in several settings, including multi-armed bandits, linear control, and more. They also provide sample complexity bounds for their algorithms in these settings.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes an important contribution by showing that linear Bellman completeness is a sufficient condition for efficient online RL, in contrast to previous results that required linear Bellman error minimization. This is a significant relaxation of the assumptions, and could lead to more practical RL algorithms.
However, the authors acknowledge that linear Bellman completeness may still be a strong assumption in some real-world settings. Additionally, the paper does not address the challenge of verifying or ensuring linear Bellman completeness in practice. Further research may be needed to develop methods for automatically checking or enforcing this property.
Another potential limitation is that the analysis in the paper focuses on the episodic setting, and it's not clear how the results would extend to the infinite-horizon setting. It would be valuable to see further research exploring the implications of linear Bellman completeness in the infinite-horizon case.
Overall, this paper provides a valuable theoretical foundation for efficient online RL, and encourages the community to think more broadly about the conditions required for effective RL algorithms, beyond just minimizing Bellman error. Continued research in this direction could lead to significant advances in the field of reinforcement learning.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates that linear Bellman completeness, rather than linear Bellman error minimization, is a sufficient condition for efficient online reinforcement learning with few actions. The authors provide a general framework for analyzing RL under linear Bellman completeness, and show that this property holds in several settings, including multi-armed bandits, linear control, and more.
This is an important theoretical insight that could lead to the development of more practical and efficient RL algorithms, especially in situations where the number of possible actions is limited. While the linear Bellman completeness assumption may still be strong in some real-world scenarios, this work opens up new avenues for research into the fundamental requirements for effective RL.
By focusing on the expressiveness of the function approximator, rather than just minimizing Bellman error, this paper encourages the RL community to think more broadly about the conditions needed for efficient learning. Continued exploration of these ideas could have significant implications for the future of reinforcement learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
0
Linear Bellman Completeness Suffices for Efficient Online Reinforcement Learning with Few Actions
Noah Golowich, Ankur Moitra
One of the most natural approaches to reinforcement learning (RL) with function approximation is value iteration, which inductively generates approximations to the optimal value function by solving a sequence of regression problems. To ensure the success of value iteration, it is typically assumed that Bellman completeness holds, which ensures that these regression problems are well-specified. We study the problem of learning an optimal policy under Bellman completeness in the online model of RL with linear function approximation. In the linear setting, while statistically efficient algorithms are known under Bellman completeness (e.g., Jiang et al. (2017); Zanette et al. (2020)), these algorithms all rely on the principle of global optimism which requires solving a nonconvex optimization problem. In particular, it has remained open as to whether computationally efficient algorithms exist. In this paper we give the first polynomial-time algorithm for RL under linear Bellman completeness when the number of actions is any constant.
Read more6/19/2024
➖
0
Computationally Efficient RL under Linear Bellman Completeness for Deterministic Dynamics
Runzhe Wu, Ayush Sekhari, Akshay Krishnamurthy, Wen Sun
We study computationally and statistically efficient Reinforcement Learning algorithms for the linear Bellman Complete setting, a setting that uses linear function approximation to capture value functions and unifies existing models like linear Markov Decision Processes (MDP) and Linear Quadratic Regulators (LQR). While it is known from the prior works that this setting is statistically tractable, it remained open whether a computationally efficient algorithm exists. Our work provides a computationally efficient algorithm for the linear Bellman complete setting that works for MDPs with large action spaces, random initial states, and random rewards but relies on the underlying dynamics to be deterministic. Our approach is based on randomization: we inject random noise into least square regression problems to perform optimistic value iteration. Our key technical contribution is to carefully design the noise to only act in the null space of the training data to ensure optimism while circumventing a subtle error amplification issue.
Read more6/18/2024
🏅
0
The Role of Inherent Bellman Error in Offline Reinforcement Learning with Linear Function Approximation
Noah Golowich, Ankur Moitra
In this paper, we study the offline RL problem with linear function approximation. Our main structural assumption is that the MDP has low inherent Bellman error, which stipulates that linear value functions have linear Bellman backups with respect to the greedy policy. This assumption is natural in that it is essentially the minimal assumption required for value iteration to succeed. We give a computationally efficient algorithm which succeeds under a single-policy coverage condition on the dataset, namely which outputs a policy whose value is at least that of any policy which is well-covered by the dataset. Even in the setting when the inherent Bellman error is 0 (termed linear Bellman completeness), our algorithm yields the first known guarantee under single-policy coverage. In the setting of positive inherent Bellman error ${varepsilon_{mathrm{BE}}} > 0$, we show that the suboptimality error of our algorithm scales with $sqrt{varepsilon_{mathrm{BE}}}$. Furthermore, we prove that the scaling of the suboptimality with $sqrt{varepsilon_{mathrm{BE}}}$ cannot be improved for any algorithm. Our lower bound stands in contrast to many other settings in reinforcement learning with misspecification, where one can typically obtain performance that degrades linearly with the misspecification error.
Read more6/19/2024
0
On Bellman equations for continuous-time policy evaluation I: discretization and approximation
Wenlong Mou, Yuhua Zhu
We study the problem of computing the value function from a discretely-observed trajectory of a continuous-time diffusion process. We develop a new class of algorithms based on easily implementable numerical schemes that are compatible with discrete-time reinforcement learning (RL) with function approximation. We establish high-order numerical accuracy as well as the approximation error guarantees for the proposed approach. In contrast to discrete-time RL problems where the approximation factor depends on the effective horizon, we obtain a bounded approximation factor using the underlying elliptic structures, even if the effective horizon diverges to infinity.
Read more7/9/2024