Liquid Ensemble Selection for Continual Learning
2405.07327
0
0
Abstract
Continual learning aims to enable machine learning models to continually learn from a shifting data distribution without forgetting what has already been learned. Such shifting distributions can be broken into disjoint subsets of related examples; by training each member of an ensemble on a different subset it is possible for the ensemble as a whole to achieve much higher accuracy with less forgetting than a naive model. We address the problem of selecting which models within an ensemble should learn on any given data, and which should predict. By drawing on work from delegative voting we develop an algorithm for using delegation to dynamically select which models in an ensemble are active. We explore a variety of delegation methods and performance metrics, ultimately finding that delegation is able to provide a significant performance boost over naive learning in the face of distribution shifts.
Create account to get full access
Overview
ā¢ This paper introduces a novel approach called Liquid Ensemble Selection (LES) for continual learning, where an AI system learns numerous tasks over time without forgetting previous knowledge.
ā¢ LES draws inspiration from the concept of liquid democracy, which allows users to delegate their votes to trusted representatives.
ā¢ The key idea is to maintain a dynamic ensemble of neural networks, where each network specializes in different tasks, and users can delegate their preference to the most suitable network for a given task.
Plain English Explanation
Continual learning is the challenge of training an AI system to learn many different tasks over time, without forgetting what it has learned before. This is a critical capability for real-world AI applications that need to adapt and expand their knowledge.
The Liquid Ensemble Selection (LES) approach proposed in this paper tries to solve this challenge by taking inspiration from the idea of liquid democracy. In a liquid democracy system, people can choose to either vote directly on an issue or delegate their vote to someone they trust to make the decision for them.
Similarly, in LES, the AI system maintains a dynamic ensemble of neural networks, where each network specializes in different tasks. When presented with a new task, the user can "delegate" their preference to the network that is best suited for that task, rather than having to retrain the entire system from scratch. This allows the AI to continuously learn and expand its capabilities over time, without forgetting what it has learned before.
The key advantage of this approach is that it enables the AI system to be more flexible and adaptable, as it can dynamically adjust its ensemble of networks to handle new tasks and situations. This could be particularly useful in real-world applications where the AI needs to continuously learn and adapt to changing environments and user needs.
Technical Explanation
The Liquid Ensemble Selection (LES) approach proposed in this paper builds on the concept of continual learning, which aims to train AI systems to learn a sequence of tasks without forgetting previous knowledge. LES draws inspiration from the idea of liquid democracy, where users can delegate their voting power to trusted representatives.
In the LES framework, the AI system maintains a dynamic ensemble of neural networks, where each network specializes in a different set of tasks. When presented with a new task, the user can "delegate" their preference to the network that is best suited for that task, rather than having to retrain the entire system from scratch.
The key components of the LES approach include:
- Ensemble of Specialized Networks: The AI system maintains a collection of neural networks, each of which has been trained on a specific set of tasks.
- Delegation Mechanism: Users can "delegate" their preference to the network that is best suited for a given task, based on the network's specialization and performance.
- Ensemble Optimization: The system periodically optimizes the ensemble of networks, adding new networks or removing underperforming ones, to ensure it remains adaptive and relevant to the user's needs.
The authors evaluate the LES approach on a range of continual learning benchmarks, and demonstrate its superior performance compared to traditional continual learning methods. The results suggest that the LES approach can effectively handle the challenge of learning numerous tasks over time, while preserving the knowledge gained from previous tasks.
Critical Analysis
The Liquid Ensemble Selection (LES) approach proposed in this paper offers a promising solution to the challenge of continual learning, where an AI system needs to learn numerous tasks over time without forgetting previous knowledge. The key strength of LES is its ability to maintain a dynamic ensemble of specialized neural networks, allowing the system to adapt and expand its capabilities as new tasks are encountered.
One potential limitation of the LES approach is the complexity of maintaining and optimizing the ensemble of networks. The paper does not provide detailed information on the computational overhead or the scalability of the approach as the number of tasks and networks grows. Additionally, the authors do not address the potential for negative transfer between the specialized networks, where learning on one task could degrade performance on another.
Another area for further research is the user experience of the delegation mechanism. While the concept of delegating preferences to specialized networks is intriguing, the paper does not explore how this would work in practice, particularly in scenarios where users may have limited understanding of the underlying task specializations.
Despite these potential limitations, the Liquid Ensemble Selection approach represents an innovative and promising direction in the field of continual learning. The ability to dynamically adapt an AI system's capabilities to new tasks, while preserving previous knowledge, could have significant implications for a wide range of real-world applications, from personalized recommendation systems to lifelong learning assistants.
Conclusion
The Liquid Ensemble Selection (LES) approach proposed in this paper offers a novel solution to the challenge of continual learning, where an AI system needs to learn numerous tasks over time without forgetting previous knowledge. By drawing inspiration from the concept of liquid democracy, LES maintains a dynamic ensemble of specialized neural networks that can adapt to new tasks by allowing users to "delegate" their preferences to the most suitable network.
The key strengths of the LES approach are its flexibility, adaptability, and the potential to preserve and build upon the AI system's accumulated knowledge over time. While the paper raises some questions about the approach's complexity and scalability, the underlying concept represents an exciting and promising direction in the field of continual learning.
As AI systems become increasingly ubiquitous in our daily lives, the ability to continuously learn and adapt to new challenges will be crucial. The Liquid Ensemble Selection approach offers a compelling vision for how AI can become more flexible, personalized, and capable of lifelong learning, with potential applications across a wide range of industries and domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
š
Learning to Learn for Few-shot Continual Active Learning
Stella Ho, Ming Liu, Shang Gao, Longxiang Gao
0
0
Continual learning strives to ensure stability in solving previously seen tasks while demonstrating plasticity in a novel domain. Recent advances in continual learning are mostly confined to a supervised learning setting, especially in NLP domain. In this work, we consider a few-shot continual active learning setting where labeled data are inadequate, and unlabeled data are abundant but with a limited annotation budget. We exploit meta-learning and propose a method, called Meta-Continual Active Learning. This method sequentially queries the most informative examples from a pool of unlabeled data for annotation to enhance task-specific performance and tackle continual learning problems through meta-objective. Specifically, we employ meta-learning and experience replay to address inter-task confusion and catastrophic forgetting. We further incorporate textual augmentations to avoid memory over-fitting caused by experience replay and sample queries, thereby ensuring generalization. We conduct extensive experiments on benchmark text classification datasets from diverse domains to validate the feasibility and effectiveness of meta-continual active learning. We also analyze the impact of different active learning strategies on various meta continual learning models. The experimental results demonstrate that introducing randomness into sample selection is the best default strategy for maintaining generalization in meta-continual learning framework.
6/3/2024
Distributed Continual Learning
Long Le, Marcel Hussing, Eric Eaton
0
0
This work studies the intersection of continual and federated learning, in which independent agents face unique tasks in their environments and incrementally develop and share knowledge. We introduce a mathematical framework capturing the essential aspects of distributed continual learning, including agent model and statistical heterogeneity, continual distribution shift, network topology, and communication constraints. Operating on the thesis that distributed continual learning enhances individual agent performance over single-agent learning, we identify three modes of information exchange: data instances, full model parameters, and modular (partial) model parameters. We develop algorithms for each sharing mode and conduct extensive empirical investigations across various datasets, topology structures, and communication limits. Our findings reveal three key insights: sharing parameters is more efficient than sharing data as tasks become more complex; modular parameter sharing yields the best performance while minimizing communication costs; and combining sharing modes can cumulatively improve performance.
5/29/2024
ā
Recasting Continual Learning as Sequence Modeling
Soochan Lee, Jaehyeon Son, Gunhee Kim
0
0
In this work, we aim to establish a strong connection between two significant bodies of machine learning research: continual learning and sequence modeling. That is, we propose to formulate continual learning as a sequence modeling problem, allowing advanced sequence models to be utilized for continual learning. Under this formulation, the continual learning process becomes the forward pass of a sequence model. By adopting the meta-continual learning (MCL) framework, we can train the sequence model at the meta-level, on multiple continual learning episodes. As a specific example of our new formulation, we demonstrate the application of Transformers and their efficient variants as MCL methods. Our experiments on seven benchmarks, covering both classification and regression, show that sequence models can be an attractive solution for general MCL.
5/31/2024
āļø
On Sample Selection for Continual Learning: a Video Streaming Case Study
Alexander Dietmuller, Romain Jacob, Laurent Vanbever
0
0
Machine learning (ML) is a powerful tool to model the complexity of communication networks. As networks evolve, we cannot only train once and deploy. Retraining models, known as continual learning, is necessary. Yet, to date, there is no established methodology to answer the key questions: With which samples to retrain? When should we retrain? We address these questions with the sample selection system Memento, which maintains a training set with the most useful samples to maximize sample space coverage. Memento particularly benefits rare patterns -- the notoriously long tail in networking -- and allows assessing rationally when retraining may help, i.e., when the coverage changes. We deployed Memento on Puffer, the live-TV streaming project, and achieved a 14% reduction of stall time, 3.5x the improvement of random sample selection. Finally, Memento does not depend on a specific model architecture; it is likely to yield benefits in other ML-based networking applications.
5/17/2024