Localization with Single or Antipodal Distance Measurements

Overview

• This paper presents an efficient data structure for solving the preimage problem for depth sensors in a polygonal workspace.
• The preimage problem is to determine all the possible positions and orientations of a depth sensor that would yield a given depth measurement.
• The paper describes an output-sensitive data structure that can solve this problem in O(k log n) time, where k is the number of vertices and maximal arcs in the solution.
• The paper also considers the case where the sensor performs two antipodal depth measurements, which can further narrow down the set of possible poses.
• The paper presents simpler data structures for these problems, with query times that are output-sensitive relative to a decomposition of the workspace.

Plain English Explanation

The paper is about a problem that comes up when using depth sensors, like those found in many robots and other devices. Imagine you have a sensor that can measure the distance to the nearest wall or object in a certain direction. The preimage problem is: if the sensor reports a certain distance, what are all the possible places and orientations the sensor could be in to get that reading?

The researchers describe a way to efficiently solve this problem, by preprocessing the workspace (the area the sensor is in) and storing the information in a data structure. Then, when you ask the system "What are all the possible sensor positions and orientations that could give a reading of X?", it can quickly figure that out using the preprocessed data.

This is useful because it allows you to narrow down the possible locations and orientations of a sensor based on just a few depth measurements, rather than having to do a full exploration of the workspace. This could save time and resources, since you don't need expensive sensors or a lot of storage and communication bandwidth.

Technical Explanation

The researchers consider a polygonal workspace W, with a depth sensor placed at a point p=(x,y) inside W and oriented in direction θ. The sensor measures the distance d=h(x,y,θ) to the closest point on the boundary of W along a ray in direction θ.

The key problem they address is: for a polygon W with n vertices, preprocess it so that given a query depth d, one can efficiently compute the preimage h^(-1)(d) ⊂ W×S¹, i.e., the set of all sensor poses (position and orientation) that could yield the depth reading d.

The researchers describe an output-sensitive data structure that can solve this problem in O(k log n) time, where k is the number of vertices and maximal arcs of low-degree algebraic curves that make up the preimage. This means the query time depends on the complexity of the actual solution, not just the size of the workspace.

They also consider the case where the sensor performs two antipodal depth measurements from the same point, which can further constrain the set of possible poses. For this, they develop analogous output-sensitive data structures.

Additionally, the researchers present simpler data structures for these problems, where they employ a decomposition of W×S¹, and the query time is output-sensitive relative to this decomposition. They provide an open-source software implementation of these structures.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that their approach, while efficient, is not as comprehensive as fully exploring the visibility polygon of a sensor's location. However, they argue that their method of using only a few depth measurements can be advantageous in situations where cost, storage, or communication bandwidth are concerns.

One potential limitation is the reliance on low-degree algebraic curves to represent the preimage. While this allows for efficient queries, it may not be able to capture more complex shapes that could arise in real-world workspaces. Further research could explore alternative representations that maintain efficiency while allowing for greater flexibility.

Additionally, the paper does not address how the data structures would handle dynamic changes to the workspace, such as moving obstacles. Extending the techniques to cope with non-static environments could be an interesting area for future work.

Overall, this research presents a novel and efficient approach to the preimage problem for depth sensors, which could have practical applications in robot localization and other fields where depth information is used. The researchers' focus on output-sensitivity and the availability of their software implementation make this work a valuable contribution to the field.

Conclusion

This paper introduces an efficient data structure for solving the preimage problem for depth sensors in a polygonal workspace. By preprocessing the workspace, the system can quickly determine all the possible positions and orientations of a sensor that could yield a given depth reading.

The researchers' approach is particularly useful in situations where cost, storage, or communication bandwidth are concerns, as it allows for accurate pose prediction using only a few depth measurements, rather than requiring a full exploration of the workspace.

While the technique has some limitations, such as the reliance on low-degree algebraic curves, the paper's contribution of efficient, output-sensitive data structures and the availability of the software implementation make it a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners working on sensor-based localization and related problems.