A Mathematical Framework, a Taxonomy of Modeling Paradigms, and a Suite of Learning Techniques for Neural-Symbolic Systems
0
🔮
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The field of Neural-Symbolic (NeSy) systems is rapidly growing, with various approaches showing promise in combining neural and symbolic methods.
- However, these NeSy systems differ fundamentally, leading to a need for a unifying theory to understand their commonalities and differences.
- This paper introduces Neural-Symbolic Energy-Based Models (NeSy-EBMs), a mathematical framework for discriminative and generative modeling with NeSy approaches.
- The paper develops a taxonomy of NeSy modeling paradigms and presents learning techniques for NeSy-EBMs, including methods from bilevel and stochastic policy optimization.
- The paper also introduces Neural Probabilistic Soft Logic (NeuPSL), an open-source NeSy-EBM library designed for scalability and expressivity.
- The authors demonstrate the practical advantages of NeSy-EBMs across various tasks, including image classification, graph node labeling, autonomous vehicle situation awareness, and question answering.
Plain English Explanation
The paper proposes a new framework called Neural-Symbolic Energy-Based Models (NeSy-EBMs) to help researchers and developers better understand and work with different types of neural-symbolic systems. Neural-symbolic systems combine the strengths of neural networks, which are good at learning from data, and symbolic systems, which are good at logical reasoning.
The authors explain that while there are many different approaches to building neural-symbolic systems, there hasn't been a unifying theory to help understand how they work and how they differ from each other. NeSy-EBMs provide a common mathematical foundation that can be used to describe and analyze various neural-symbolic models.
The paper also introduces Neural Probabilistic Soft Logic (NeuPSL), an open-source library that makes it easier for researchers and developers to build and experiment with neural-symbolic systems. The authors show how NeSy-EBMs and NeuPSL can be used to tackle a variety of real-world problems, such as image classification, graph analysis, and question answering.
The key idea is to provide a more systematic and unified way of working with neural-symbolic systems, which could help drive further progress in this important and rapidly evolving field of AI.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces Neural-Symbolic Energy-Based Models (NeSy-EBMs), a unifying mathematical framework for discriminative and generative modeling with probabilistic and non-probabilistic NeSy approaches. The authors develop a taxonomy of NeSy modeling paradigms based on the system's neural-symbolic interface and reasoning capabilities.
The paper also presents a suite of learning techniques for NeSy-EBMs, including methods from bilevel and stochastic policy optimization. These learning approaches leverage gradients of prominent learning losses, which the authors derive for NeSy-EBMs.
The authors introduce Neural Probabilistic Soft Logic (NeuPSL), an open-source NeSy-EBM library designed for scalability and expressivity. Through extensive empirical analysis across multiple datasets, the authors demonstrate the practical advantages of NeSy-EBMs in tasks such as image classification, graph node labeling, autonomous vehicle situation awareness, and question answering.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive and well-designed framework for understanding and working with neural-symbolic systems. The authors have carefully considered the diverse range of existing approaches and developed a unifying theory that can accommodate their differences.
One potential limitation is the complexity of the NeSy-EBM framework, which may require significant expertise to fully understand and apply. The authors acknowledge this and emphasize the need for further research to simplify the framework and make it more accessible to a broader audience.
Additionally, while the empirical results demonstrate the practical advantages of NeSy-EBMs, the paper does not provide a detailed comparison to other state-of-the-art neural-symbolic approaches, such as simple and effective transfer learning for neuro-symbolic integration or convex bilevel optimization for neuro-symbolic inference and learning. A more comprehensive comparative analysis could help position NeSy-EBMs within the broader landscape of neural-symbolic systems.
Overall, the paper represents a significant contribution to the field of neural-symbolic computing and lays the groundwork for further advancements in combining large language models with symbolic reasoning and knowledge graph-based neural-symbolic systems.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a unifying mathematical framework called Neural-Symbolic Energy-Based Models (NeSy-EBMs) to help researchers and developers better understand and work with different types of neural-symbolic systems. The authors develop a taxonomy of NeSy modeling paradigms and present learning techniques that leverage methods from bilevel and stochastic policy optimization.
The authors also introduce Neural Probabilistic Soft Logic (NeuPSL), an open-source library that makes it easier to build and experiment with neural-symbolic systems. The empirical results demonstrate the practical advantages of NeSy-EBMs across various tasks, suggesting that this framework could be a valuable tool for driving further progress in the field of neural-symbolic computing.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔮
0
A Mathematical Framework, a Taxonomy of Modeling Paradigms, and a Suite of Learning Techniques for Neural-Symbolic Systems
Charles Dickens, Connor Pryor, Changyu Gao, Alon Albalak, Eriq Augustine, William Wang, Stephen Wright, Lise Getoor
The field of Neural-Symbolic (NeSy) systems is growing rapidly. Proposed approaches show great promise in achieving symbiotic unions of neural and symbolic methods. However, each NeSy system differs in fundamental ways. There is a pressing need for a unifying theory to illuminate the commonalities and differences in approaches and enable further progress. In this paper, we introduce Neural-Symbolic Energy-Based Models (NeSy-EBMs), a unifying mathematical framework for discriminative and generative modeling with probabilistic and non-probabilistic NeSy approaches. We utilize NeSy-EBMs to develop a taxonomy of modeling paradigms focusing on a system's neural-symbolic interface and reasoning capabilities. Additionally, we introduce a suite of learning techniques for NeSy-EBMs. Importantly, NeSy-EBMs allow the derivation of general expressions for gradients of prominent learning losses, and we provide four learning approaches that leverage methods from multiple domains, including bilevel and stochastic policy optimization. Finally, we present Neural Probabilistic Soft Logic (NeuPSL), an open-source NeSy-EBM library designed for scalability and expressivity, facilitating real-world application of NeSy systems. Through extensive empirical analysis across multiple datasets, we demonstrate the practical advantages of NeSy-EBMs in various tasks, including image classification, graph node labeling, autonomous vehicle situation awareness, and question answering.
Read more7/16/2024
🔍
0
A Semantic Framework for Neural-Symbolic Computing
Simon Odense, Artur d'Avila Garcez
The field of neuro-symbolic AI aims to benefit from the combination of neural networks and symbolic systems. A cornerstone of the field is the translation or encoding of symbolic knowledge into neural networks. Although many neuro-symbolic methods and approaches have been proposed throughout the years, and with an large increase in recent years, no common definition of encoding exists that can enable a precise, theoretical comparison of neuro-symbolic methods. This paper addresses this problem by introducing a semantic framework for neuro-symbolic AI. We start by providing a formal definition of semantic encoding, specifying the components and conditions under which a knowledge-base can be encoded correctly by a neural network. We then show that many neuro-symbolic approaches are accounted for by this definition. We provide a number of examples and correspondence proofs of the application of the proposed framework to the neural encoding of various forms of knowledge representation. Many, at first sight disparate, neuro-symbolic methods, are shown to fall within the proposed formalization. This is expected to provide a guidance to future neuro-symbolic encodings by placing them in the broader context of the semantic encoding of entire families of existing neuro-symbolic systems. The paper is hoped to help initiate a discussion around the provision of a theory for neuro-symbolic AI and a semantics for deep learning.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Simple and Effective Transfer Learning for Neuro-Symbolic Integration
Alessandro Daniele, Tommaso Campari, Sagar Malhotra, Luciano Serafini
Deep Learning (DL) techniques have achieved remarkable successes in recent years. However, their ability to generalize and execute reasoning tasks remains a challenge. A potential solution to this issue is Neuro-Symbolic Integration (NeSy), where neural approaches are combined with symbolic reasoning. Most of these methods exploit a neural network to map perceptions to symbols and a logical reasoner to predict the output of the downstream task. These methods exhibit superior generalization capacity compared to fully neural architectures. However, they suffer from several issues, including slow convergence, learning difficulties with complex perception tasks, and convergence to local minima. This paper proposes a simple yet effective method to ameliorate these problems. The key idea involves pretraining a neural model on the downstream task. Then, a NeSy model is trained on the same task via transfer learning, where the weights of the perceptual part are injected from the pretrained network. The key observation of our work is that the neural network fails to generalize only at the level of the symbolic part while being perfectly capable of learning the mapping from perceptions to symbols. We have tested our training strategy on various SOTA NeSy methods and datasets, demonstrating consistent improvements in the aforementioned problems.
Read more7/16/2024
🛠️
0
Convex and Bilevel Optimization for Neuro-Symbolic Inference and Learning
Charles Dickens, Changyu Gao, Connor Pryor, Stephen Wright, Lise Getoor
We leverage convex and bilevel optimization techniques to develop a general gradient-based parameter learning framework for neural-symbolic (NeSy) systems. We demonstrate our framework with NeuPSL, a state-of-the-art NeSy architecture. To achieve this, we propose a smooth primal and dual formulation of NeuPSL inference and show learning gradients are functions of the optimal dual variables. Additionally, we develop a dual block coordinate descent algorithm for the new formulation that naturally exploits warm-starts. This leads to over 100x learning runtime improvements over the current best NeuPSL inference method. Finally, we provide extensive empirical evaluations across 8 datasets covering a range of tasks and demonstrate our learning framework achieves up to a 16% point prediction performance improvement over alternative learning methods.
Read more6/5/2024