Maverick-Aware Shapley Valuation for Client Selection in Federated Learning
0
🛸
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Federated Learning (FL) allows multiple clients to collaboratively train a machine learning model without sharing their private data.
- A key challenge in practical FL systems is handling clients with rare or unique data, known as "Mavericks".
- Mavericks are clients who own one or more data classes exclusively, and their participation is crucial for model performance.
- This paper proposes a novel approach called FedMS to address the challenge of Mavericks in FL.
Plain English Explanation
Federated Learning (FL) is a way for multiple people or organizations to train a machine learning model together without sharing their private data. One key challenge in real-world FL systems is dealing with clients who have rare or unique data, called "Mavericks". These Mavericks are clients who own one or more data classes that no one else has. Their participation is very important for the model to perform well, but their rare data can make it difficult to incorporate them.
This paper introduces a new approach called FedMS that addresses the issue of Mavericks in FL. The main idea is to carefully evaluate the contribution of Mavericks and then select the clients that contribute the most in each round of training. This helps ensure that the model performance is good and that the rewards for contributing to the model are distributed fairly.
Technical Explanation
The paper first designs a "Maverick-aware Shapley valuation" to fairly evaluate the contribution of Mavericks. The key insight is to compute the Shapley value (a measure of contribution) of each client on a per-class basis, rather than just overall. This allows the method to properly account for the unique value that Mavericks bring with their rare data classes.
Next, the paper proposes FedMS, a client selection mechanism for FL that uses the Maverick-aware Shapley values to intelligently choose the clients that contribute the most in each round of training. By focusing on the clients that bring the most value, FedMS is able to achieve better model performance and fairer distribution of rewards compared to other approaches.
The paper also explores related ideas such as data valuation, personalization, and fairness in the context of FL.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed solution to the important problem of handling Mavericks in practical Federated Learning systems. The Maverick-aware Shapley valuation and the FedMS client selection mechanism are novel contributions that could have a significant impact on the field.
However, the paper does not address the computational complexity of the proposed methods, which could be a practical limitation, especially as the number of clients and data classes grows. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential impact of client drift or data distribution shifts over time, which could affect the reliability of the Shapley value computations.
Further research could explore ways to make the Maverick-aware Shapley valuation more efficient, as well as investigate methods to adapt the client selection process to changing data distributions and client behaviors. Incorporating these considerations could further enhance the real-world applicability of the FedMS approach.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an innovative solution called FedMS to address the challenge of Mavericks in Federated Learning. By carefully evaluating the contribution of Mavericks and intelligently selecting clients based on their importance, FedMS can achieve better model performance and fairer distribution of rewards. The Maverick-aware Shapley valuation and the FedMS client selection mechanism are valuable contributions that could significantly improve the practicality of Federated Learning systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛸
0
Maverick-Aware Shapley Valuation for Client Selection in Federated Learning
Mengwei Yang, Ismat Jarin, Baturalp Buyukates, Salman Avestimehr, Athina Markopoulou
Federated Learning (FL) allows clients to train a model collaboratively without sharing their private data. One key challenge in practical FL systems is data heterogeneity, particularly in handling clients with rare data, also referred to as Mavericks. These clients own one or more data classes exclusively, and the model performance becomes poor without their participation. Thus, utilizing Mavericks throughout training is crucial. In this paper, we first design a Maverick-aware Shapley valuation that fairly evaluates the contribution of Mavericks. The main idea is to compute the clients' Shapley values (SV) class-wise, i.e., per label. Next, we propose FedMS, a Maverick-Shapley client selection mechanism for FL that intelligently selects the clients that contribute the most in each round, by employing our Maverick-aware SV-based contribution score. We show that, compared to an extensive list of baselines, FedMS achieves better model performance and fairer Shapley Rewards distribution.
Read more5/22/2024
📊
0
Data Valuation and Detections in Federated Learning
Wenqian Li, Shuran Fu, Fengrui Zhang, Yan Pang
Federated Learning (FL) enables collaborative model training while preserving the privacy of raw data. A challenge in this framework is the fair and efficient valuation of data, which is crucial for incentivizing clients to contribute high-quality data in the FL task. In scenarios involving numerous data clients within FL, it is often the case that only a subset of clients and datasets are pertinent to a specific learning task, while others might have either a negative or negligible impact on the model training process. This paper introduces a novel privacy-preserving method for evaluating client contributions and selecting relevant datasets without a pre-specified training algorithm in an FL task. Our proposed approach FedBary, utilizes Wasserstein distance within the federated context, offering a new solution for data valuation in the FL framework. This method ensures transparent data valuation and efficient computation of the Wasserstein barycenter and reduces the dependence on validation datasets. Through extensive empirical experiments and theoretical analyses, we demonstrate the potential of this data valuation method as a promising avenue for FL research.
Read more5/10/2024
0
Redefining Contributions: Shapley-Driven Federated Learning
Nurbek Tastan, Samar Fares, Toluwani Aremu, Samuel Horvath, Karthik Nandakumar
Federated learning (FL) has emerged as a pivotal approach in machine learning, enabling multiple participants to collaboratively train a global model without sharing raw data. While FL finds applications in various domains such as healthcare and finance, it is challenging to ensure global model convergence when participants do not contribute equally and/or honestly. To overcome this challenge, principled mechanisms are required to evaluate the contributions made by individual participants in the FL setting. Existing solutions for contribution assessment rely on general accuracy evaluation, often failing to capture nuanced dynamics and class-specific influences. This paper proposes a novel contribution assessment method called ShapFed for fine-grained evaluation of participant contributions in FL. Our approach uses Shapley values from cooperative game theory to provide a granular understanding of class-specific influences. Based on ShapFed, we introduce a weighted aggregation method called ShapFed-WA, which outperforms conventional federated averaging, especially in class-imbalanced scenarios. Personalizing participant updates based on their contributions further enhances collaborative fairness by delivering differentiated models commensurate with the participant contributions. Experiments on CIFAR-10, Chest X-Ray, and Fed-ISIC2019 datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in improving utility, efficiency, and fairness in FL systems. The code can be found at https://github.com/tnurbek/shapfed.
Read more6/4/2024
📶
0
Federated Learning Can Find Friends That Are Advantageous
Nazarii Tupitsa, Samuel Horv'ath, Martin Tak'av{c}, Eduard Gorbunov
In Federated Learning (FL), the distributed nature and heterogeneity of client data present both opportunities and challenges. While collaboration among clients can significantly enhance the learning process, not all collaborations are beneficial; some may even be detrimental. In this study, we introduce a novel algorithm that assigns adaptive aggregation weights to clients participating in FL training, identifying those with data distributions most conducive to a specific learning objective. We demonstrate that our aggregation method converges no worse than the method that aggregates only the updates received from clients with the same data distribution. Furthermore, empirical evaluations consistently reveal that collaborations guided by our algorithm outperform traditional FL approaches. This underscores the critical role of judicious client selection and lays the foundation for more streamlined and effective FL implementations in the coming years.
Read more7/18/2024