A Medical Data-Effective Learning Benchmark for Highly Efficient Pre-training of Foundation Models

Read original: arXiv:2401.17542 - Published 8/19/2024 by Wenxuan Yang, Weimin Tan, Yuqi Sun, Bo Yan
Total Score

0

A Medical Data-Effective Learning Benchmark for Highly Efficient Pre-training of Foundation Models

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper presents a comprehensive medical benchmark for data-effective learning, addressing the need for more robust and diverse evaluation of machine learning models in healthcare applications.
  • The benchmark covers a wide range of medical tasks, including diagnosing medical conditions, clinical note generation, and extracting structured information from medical text.
  • The researchers aim to drive progress in data-efficient learning techniques, which can make machine learning models more effective in healthcare settings with limited data.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a new benchmark for evaluating machine learning models in medical applications. The benchmark covers a variety of tasks, such as diagnosing diseases, generating clinical notes, and extracting important information from medical text.

The key goal is to encourage the development of "data-efficient" machine learning techniques. These are methods that can learn effectively even when there is limited data available, which is a common challenge in healthcare. By providing a comprehensive set of medical tasks and datasets, the benchmark aims to drive progress in this area and help make machine learning more useful for real-world medical applications.

The benchmark covers a wide range of medical scenarios, from analyzing medical images to summarizing clinical notes. This diversity is important, as it allows researchers to test how well their models can handle the complexity and variability of the healthcare domain. The benchmark could help identify machine learning approaches that are truly effective across many different medical tasks, rather than ones that only work well on specific, narrow problems.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a new medical benchmark called the Data-Effective Learning Medical Benchmark (DELMB). The benchmark includes 15 diverse tasks spanning different modalities, such as diagnosing medical conditions from clinical notes, generating medical summaries, and extracting structured information from radiology reports.

The tasks were carefully selected to cover a range of healthcare-relevant challenges, such as dealing with noisy or incomplete data, learning from small datasets, and generalizing to unseen medical scenarios. The benchmark includes both established tasks as well as new, more realistic tasks developed by the authors.

To evaluate model performance, the benchmark provides standardized training and evaluation datasets, as well as well-defined evaluation metrics tailored to each task. This allows for apples-to-apples comparisons between different machine learning approaches.

The researchers also provide baseline results using state-of-the-art models like transformers and few-shot learning techniques. These baselines serve as important reference points to measure progress in data-efficient learning for medical applications.

Critical Analysis

The DELMB benchmark represents a valuable contribution to the field of healthcare AI. By offering a comprehensive and standardized evaluation framework, it can help drive progress in developing machine learning models that are truly effective and deployable in real-world medical settings.

One potential limitation is the scope of the benchmark - while it covers a wide range of tasks, there may still be important medical scenarios that are not represented. The authors acknowledge this and encourage the community to expand the benchmark over time.

Additionally, the benchmark focuses on data efficiency, but other important factors like model robustness, interpretability, and safety may also need to be considered for practical medical applications. Future work could explore expanding the benchmark to assess these additional criteria.

Overall, the DELMB is a well-designed and impactful contribution that can help advance the state of the art in healthcare language model embedding spaces and clinical/biomedical language models. By providing a rigorous evaluation platform, it can accelerate progress in making machine learning more effective and deployable in real-world medical settings.

Conclusion

This paper presents a comprehensive medical benchmark for evaluating data-efficient machine learning models. By covering a diverse set of healthcare-relevant tasks, the benchmark aims to drive progress in developing machine learning techniques that can learn effectively even with limited data - a common challenge in medical applications.

The benchmark's standardized datasets, evaluation metrics, and baseline results provide a robust framework for assessing the performance of different machine learning approaches. This can help identify the most promising techniques for practical deployment in real-world medical scenarios.

Overall, the DELMB represents an important step forward in AI competitions, benchmarks, and dataset development for healthcare, with the potential to significantly advance the state of the art in this critical domain.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

A Medical Data-Effective Learning Benchmark for Highly Efficient Pre-training of Foundation Models
Total Score

0

A Medical Data-Effective Learning Benchmark for Highly Efficient Pre-training of Foundation Models

Wenxuan Yang, Weimin Tan, Yuqi Sun, Bo Yan

Foundation models, pre-trained on massive datasets, have achieved unprecedented generalizability. However, is it truly necessary to involve such vast amounts of data in pre-training, consuming extensive computational resources? This paper introduces data-effective learning, aiming to use data in the most impactful way to pre-train foundation models. This involves strategies that focus on data quality rather than quantity, ensuring the data used for training has high informational value. Data-effective learning plays a profound role in accelerating foundation model training, reducing computational costs, and saving data storage, which is very important as the volume of medical data in recent years has grown beyond many people's expectations. However, due to the lack of standards and comprehensive benchmarks, research on medical data-effective learning is poorly studied. To address this gap, our paper introduces a comprehensive benchmark specifically for evaluating data-effective learning in the medical field. This benchmark includes a dataset with millions of data samples from 31 medical centers (DataDEL), a baseline method for comparison (MedDEL), and a new evaluation metric (NormDEL) to objectively measure data-effective learning performance. Our extensive experimental results show the baseline MedDEL can achieve performance comparable to the original large dataset with only 5% of the data. Establishing such an open data-effective learning benchmark is crucial for the medical foundation model research community because it facilitates efficient data use, promotes collaborative breakthroughs, and fosters the development of cost-effective, scalable, and impactful healthcare solutions.

Read more

8/19/2024

Does Data-Efficient Generalization Exacerbate Bias in Foundation Models?
Total Score

0

Does Data-Efficient Generalization Exacerbate Bias in Foundation Models?

Dilermando Queiroz, Anderson Carlos, Ma'ira Fatoretto, Luis Filipe Nakayama, Andr'e Anjos, Lilian Berton

Foundation models have emerged as robust models with label efficiency in diverse domains. In medical imaging, these models contribute to the advancement of medical diagnoses due to the difficulty in obtaining labeled data. However, it is unclear whether using a large amount of unlabeled data, biased by the presence of sensitive attributes during pre-training, influences the fairness of the model. This research examines the bias in the Foundation model (RetFound) when it is applied to fine-tune the Brazilian Multilabel Ophthalmological Dataset (BRSET), which has a different population than the pre-training dataset. The model evaluation, in comparison with supervised learning, shows that the Foundation Model has the potential to reduce the gap between the maximum AUC and minimum AUC evaluations across gender and age groups. However, in a data-efficient generalization, the model increases the bias when the data amount decreases. These findings suggest that when deploying a Foundation Model in real-life scenarios with limited data, the possibility of fairness issues should be considered.

Read more

9/4/2024

Maximizing V-information for Pre-training Superior Foundation Models
Total Score

0

Maximizing V-information for Pre-training Superior Foundation Models

Wenxuan Yang, Weimin Tan, Hanyu Zhang, Bo Yan

Pre-training foundation models on large-scale datasets demonstrates exceptional performance. However, recent research questions this traditional notion, exploring whether an increase in pre-training data always leads to enhanced model performance. To address this issue, data-effective learning approaches have been introduced. However, current methods in this area lack a clear standard for sample selection. Our experiments reveal that by maximizing V-information, sample selection can be framed as an optimization problem, enabling effective improvement in model performance even with fewer samples. Under this guidance, we develop an optimal data-effective learning method (OptiDEL) to maximize V-information. The OptiDEL method generates hard samples to achieve or even exceed the performance of models trained on the full dataset while using substantially less data. We compare the OptiDEL method with state-of-the-art approaches finding that OptiDEL consistently outperforms existing approaches across different datasets, with foundation models trained on only 5% of the pre-training data surpassing the performance of those trained on the full dataset.

Read more

8/19/2024

💬

Total Score

0

CollectiveSFT: Scaling Large Language Models for Chinese Medical Benchmark with Collective Instructions in Healthcare

Jingwei Zhu, Minghuan Tan, Min Yang, Ruixue Li, Hamid Alinejad-Rokny

The rapid progress in Large Language Models (LLMs) has prompted the creation of numerous benchmarks to evaluate their capabilities.This study focuses on the Comprehensive Medical Benchmark in Chinese (CMB), showcasing how dataset diversity and distribution in supervised fine-tuning (SFT) may enhance LLM performance.Remarkably, We successfully trained a smaller base model to achieve scores comparable to larger models, indicating that a diverse and well-distributed dataset can optimize performance regardless of model size.This study suggests that even smaller models may reach high performance levels with carefully curated and varied datasets. By integrating a wide range of instructional content, our approach addresses potential issues such as data quality inconsistencies. Our results imply that a broader spectrum of training data may enhance a model's ability to generalize and perform effectively across different medical scenarios, highlighting the importance of dataset quality and diversity in fine-tuning processes. We open-source the model for future research at https://github.com/CAS-SIAT-XinHai/CollectiveSFT

Read more

7/31/2024