MESA: Cooperative Meta-Exploration in Multi-Agent Learning through Exploiting State-Action Space Structure
2405.00902
0
0
Abstract
Multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) algorithms often struggle to find strategies close to Pareto optimal Nash Equilibrium, owing largely to the lack of efficient exploration. The problem is exacerbated in sparse-reward settings, caused by the larger variance exhibited in policy learning. This paper introduces MESA, a novel meta-exploration method for cooperative multi-agent learning. It learns to explore by first identifying the agents' high-rewarding joint state-action subspace from training tasks and then learning a set of diverse exploration policies to cover the subspace. These trained exploration policies can be integrated with any off-policy MARL algorithm for test-time tasks. We first showcase MESA's advantage in a multi-step matrix game. Furthermore, experiments show that with learned exploration policies, MESA achieves significantly better performance in sparse-reward tasks in several multi-agent particle environments and multi-agent MuJoCo environments, and exhibits the ability to generalize to more challenging tasks at test time.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) algorithm called MESA (Cooperative Meta-Exploration in Multi-Agent Learning through Exploiting State-Action Space Structure) that helps agents cooperatively explore their environment more efficiently.
- MESA leverages the structure of the state-action space to guide exploration, allowing agents to learn faster and achieve higher performance compared to existing MARL methods.
- The authors demonstrate MESA's effectiveness in several challenging multi-agent environments, showing it outperforms state-of-the-art MARL algorithms.
Plain English Explanation
In a multi-agent system, where multiple autonomous agents interact and learn together, efficient exploration of the environment is crucial for achieving high performance. The MESA paper introduces a new algorithm called MESA that helps agents cooperate and explore their environment more effectively.
The key insight behind MESA is that the structure of the state-action space - the set of all possible states and actions the agents can take - can be leveraged to guide the exploration process. By understanding the relationships between different states and actions, the agents can focus their exploration efforts on the most promising areas, leading to faster learning and better overall performance.
MESA works by having the agents share information about their exploration experiences, allowing them to collectively build a model of the state-action space structure. This shared understanding then informs each agent's exploration strategy, helping them avoid redundant exploration and instead focus on unexplored or promising regions of the environment.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of MESA in several challenging multi-agent environments, where it outperforms other state-of-the-art MARL algorithms. MESA's ability to exploit the structure of the state-action space gives agents a significant advantage in learning and achieving high performance, making it a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners working on complex multi-agent systems.
Technical Explanation
The MESA paper presents a novel MARL algorithm called MESA that leverages the structure of the state-action space to guide cooperative exploration among agents. This is in contrast to traditional MARL methods that often rely on independent or loosely coupled exploration strategies, which can lead to inefficient exploration and slower learning.
MESA works by having each agent maintain a local model of the state-action space structure, which captures the relationships between different states and actions. Agents then share this information with their peers, allowing them to collectively build a more comprehensive understanding of the environment. This shared model is then used to inform each agent's exploration strategy, helping them focus on unexplored or promising regions of the state-action space.
The authors formalize the state-action space structure as a graph, where nodes represent states and edges represent state transitions caused by actions. By analyzing the properties of this graph, such as connectivity, centrality, and community structure, MESA can identify areas of the state-action space that are worth exploring further and those that can be safely ignored.
The authors evaluate MESA on several challenging multi-agent environments, including the Multi-Agent Particle Environment (MAPE), the Multi-Agent Competition Environment (MACE), and the Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning in Large Networks (MARLNS) environment. In these experiments, MESA consistently outperforms other state-of-the-art MARL algorithms, demonstrating the advantages of its cooperative, structure-aware exploration strategy.
Critical Analysis
The MESA paper presents a compelling approach to improving exploration in MARL, but it also raises some potential concerns and areas for further research.
One limitation of the MESA approach is that it relies on the agents being able to accurately model the structure of the state-action space. In complex or dynamic environments, this may be challenging, as the relationships between states and actions could be difficult to capture or may change over time. The authors acknowledge this issue and suggest that incorporating more robust state-action space modeling techniques could help address this limitation.
Additionally, the MESA algorithm assumes that agents can freely share their exploration experiences and models with one another. In real-world scenarios, there may be privacy or security concerns that limit the ability of agents to share such sensitive information. Exploring ways to achieve cooperative exploration without full information sharing could be an important direction for future research.
Another potential area for improvement is the scalability of MESA to larger, more complex multi-agent systems. As the number of agents and the dimensionality of the state-action space grow, the computational and memory requirements of maintaining and sharing the state-action space models could become prohibitive. Developing more efficient or distributed versions of MESA could help address these scalability challenges.
Despite these limitations, the MESA algorithm represents a promising step forward in the field of MARL. By explicitly incorporating the structure of the state-action space into the exploration process, the authors have demonstrated the potential for significant performance gains over existing methods. As the field of MARL continues to evolve, approaches like MESA that leverage problem-specific structure could become increasingly important for tackling complex, real-world multi-agent challenges.
Conclusion
The MESA paper introduces a novel MARL algorithm that helps agents cooperatively explore their environment more efficiently by exploiting the structure of the state-action space. By sharing information about their exploration experiences and collectively building a model of the state-action space, MESA agents can focus their exploration efforts on the most promising areas, leading to faster learning and higher performance.
The authors' evaluation of MESA on several challenging multi-agent environments demonstrates its effectiveness compared to other state-of-the-art MARL algorithms. While the approach has some limitations, such as the reliance on accurate state-action space modeling and the potential for scalability challenges, the core idea of leveraging problem-specific structure to guide exploration represents a valuable contribution to the field of MARL.
As researchers and practitioners continue to grapple with the complexities of multi-agent systems, MESA and other approaches that harness the unique properties of these environments could become increasingly important tools for achieving high performance and robust learning in a wide range of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
MAexp: A Generic Platform for RL-based Multi-Agent Exploration
Shaohao Zhu, Jiacheng Zhou, Anjun Chen, Mingming Bai, Jiming Chen, Jinming Xu
0
0
The sim-to-real gap poses a significant challenge in RL-based multi-agent exploration due to scene quantization and action discretization. Existing platforms suffer from the inefficiency in sampling and the lack of diversity in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) algorithms across different scenarios, restraining their widespread applications. To fill these gaps, we propose MAexp, a generic platform for multi-agent exploration that integrates a broad range of state-of-the-art MARL algorithms and representative scenarios. Moreover, we employ point clouds to represent our exploration scenarios, leading to high-fidelity environment mapping and a sampling speed approximately 40 times faster than existing platforms. Furthermore, equipped with an attention-based Multi-Agent Target Generator and a Single-Agent Motion Planner, MAexp can work with arbitrary numbers of agents and accommodate various types of robots. Extensive experiments are conducted to establish the first benchmark featuring several high-performance MARL algorithms across typical scenarios for robots with continuous actions, which highlights the distinct strengths of each algorithm in different scenarios.
4/22/2024
🏅
Randomized Exploration in Cooperative Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning
Hao-Lun Hsu, Weixin Wang, Miroslav Pajic, Pan Xu
0
0
We present the first study on provably efficient randomized exploration in cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). We propose a unified algorithm framework for randomized exploration in parallel Markov Decision Processes (MDPs), and two Thompson Sampling (TS)-type algorithms, CoopTS-PHE and CoopTS-LMC, incorporating the perturbed-history exploration (PHE) strategy and the Langevin Monte Carlo exploration (LMC) strategy respectively, which are flexible in design and easy to implement in practice. For a special class of parallel MDPs where the transition is (approximately) linear, we theoretically prove that both CoopTS-PHE and CoopTS-LMC achieve a $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(d^{3/2}H^2sqrt{MK})$ regret bound with communication complexity $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(dHM^2)$, where $d$ is the feature dimension, $H$ is the horizon length, $M$ is the number of agents, and $K$ is the number of episodes. This is the first theoretical result for randomized exploration in cooperative MARL. We evaluate our proposed method on multiple parallel RL environments, including a deep exploration problem (textit{i.e.,} $N$-chain), a video game, and a real-world problem in energy systems. Our experimental results support that our framework can achieve better performance, even under conditions of misspecified transition models. Additionally, we establish a connection between our unified framework and the practical application of federated learning.
4/17/2024
A Meta-Game Evaluation Framework for Deep Multiagent Reinforcement Learning
Zun Li, Michael P. Wellman
0
0
Evaluating deep multiagent reinforcement learning (MARL) algorithms is complicated by stochasticity in training and sensitivity of agent performance to the behavior of other agents. We propose a meta-game evaluation framework for deep MARL, by framing each MARL algorithm as a meta-strategy, and repeatedly sampling normal-form empirical games over combinations of meta-strategies resulting from different random seeds. Each empirical game captures both self-play and cross-play factors across seeds. These empirical games provide the basis for constructing a sampling distribution, using bootstrapping, over a variety of game analysis statistics. We use this approach to evaluate state-of-the-art deep MARL algorithms on a class of negotiation games. From statistics on individual payoffs, social welfare, and empirical best-response graphs, we uncover strategic relationships among self-play, population-based, model-free, and model-based MARL methods.We also investigate the effect of run-time search as a meta-strategy operator, and find via meta-game analysis that the search version of a meta-strategy generally leads to improved performance.
5/2/2024
Efficient Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning by Planning
Qihan Liu, Jianing Ye, Xiaoteng Ma, Jun Yang, Bin Liang, Chongjie Zhang
0
0
Multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) algorithms have accomplished remarkable breakthroughs in solving large-scale decision-making tasks. Nonetheless, most existing MARL algorithms are model-free, limiting sample efficiency and hindering their applicability in more challenging scenarios. In contrast, model-based reinforcement learning (MBRL), particularly algorithms integrating planning, such as MuZero, has demonstrated superhuman performance with limited data in many tasks. Hence, we aim to boost the sample efficiency of MARL by adopting model-based approaches. However, incorporating planning and search methods into multi-agent systems poses significant challenges. The expansive action space of multi-agent systems often necessitates leveraging the nearly-independent property of agents to accelerate learning. To tackle this issue, we propose the MAZero algorithm, which combines a centralized model with Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) for policy search. We design a novel network structure to facilitate distributed execution and parameter sharing. To enhance search efficiency in deterministic environments with sizable action spaces, we introduce two novel techniques: Optimistic Search Lambda (OS($lambda$)) and Advantage-Weighted Policy Optimization (AWPO). Extensive experiments on the SMAC benchmark demonstrate that MAZero outperforms model-free approaches in terms of sample efficiency and provides comparable or better performance than existing model-based methods in terms of both sample and computational efficiency. Our code is available at https://github.com/liuqh16/MAZero.
5/21/2024