What is the Solution for State-Adversarial Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning?
2212.02705
0
0
🏅
Abstract
Various methods for Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) have been developed with the assumption that agents' policies are based on accurate state information. However, policies learned through Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) are susceptible to adversarial state perturbation attacks. In this work, we propose a State-Adversarial Markov Game (SAMG) and make the first attempt to investigate different solution concepts of MARL under state uncertainties. Our analysis shows that the commonly used solution concepts of optimal agent policy and robust Nash equilibrium do not always exist in SAMGs. To circumvent this difficulty, we consider a new solution concept called robust agent policy, where agents aim to maximize the worst-case expected state value. We prove the existence of robust agent policy for finite state and finite action SAMGs. Additionally, we propose a Robust Multi-Agent Adversarial Actor-Critic (RMA3C) algorithm to learn robust policies for MARL agents under state uncertainties. Our experiments demonstrate that our algorithm outperforms existing methods when faced with state perturbations and greatly improves the robustness of MARL policies. Our code is public on https://songyanghan.github.io/what_is_solution/.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the challenges of Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) under state uncertainties, where agents' policies can be vulnerable to adversarial attacks.
- The researchers propose a new framework called State-Adversarial Markov Game (SAMG) to model state uncertainties in MARL.
- They analyze existing solution concepts like optimal agent policy and robust Nash equilibrium, and find they may not always exist in SAMGs.
- To address this, the researchers introduce a new solution concept called robust agent policy, which aims to maximize the worst-case expected state value.
- They also propose a Robust Multi-Agent Adversarial Actor-Critic (RMA3C) algorithm to learn robust policies for MARL agents under state uncertainties.
Plain English Explanation
In the world of Reinforcement Learning, researchers have developed various methods for Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL). These methods assume that the agents have accurate information about the state of the environment.
However, when agents use Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) to learn their policies, these policies can be vulnerable to adversarial attacks that manipulate the state information.
To address this issue, the researchers in this paper propose a new framework called the State-Adversarial Markov Game (SAMG). This framework allows them to model the state uncertainties that can occur in MARL scenarios.
The researchers then analyze the existing solution concepts used in MARL, such as optimal agent policy and robust Nash equilibrium. They find that these solutions may not always exist in the SAMG framework.
To overcome this challenge, the researchers introduce a new solution concept called robust agent policy. This approach aims to have the agents maximize the worst-case expected state value, rather than the average or best-case value.
The researchers also develop a new algorithm called Robust Multi-Agent Adversarial Actor-Critic (RMA3C) to help agents learn these robust policies in the face of state uncertainties. Their experiments show that this algorithm outperforms existing methods when dealing with state perturbations and significantly improves the robustness of MARL policies.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new framework called the State-Adversarial Markov Game (SAMG) to model state uncertainties in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) scenarios. In a SAMG, the environment can adversarially perturb the true state, making the agents' policies vulnerable to attack.
The researchers analyze two common solution concepts in MARL: optimal agent policy and robust Nash equilibrium. They show that these solutions may not always exist in the SAMG framework, as the state uncertainties can prevent agents from finding optimal or equilibrium policies.
To address this challenge, the researchers introduce a new solution concept called robust agent policy. In this approach, agents aim to maximize the worst-case expected state value, rather than the average or best-case value. The researchers prove the existence of robust agent policies for finite state and finite action SAMGs.
Additionally, the researchers propose a Robust Multi-Agent Adversarial Actor-Critic (RMA3C) algorithm to help agents learn robust policies in the face of state uncertainties. The algorithm combines ideas from adversarial training and multi-agent actor-critic methods.
In their experiments, the researchers demonstrate that the RMA3C algorithm outperforms existing methods when agents face state perturbations. The robust policies learned by RMA3C significantly improve the overall robustness of MARL systems.
Critical Analysis
The researchers in this paper make an important contribution by addressing the issue of state uncertainties in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL). Their proposed State-Adversarial Markov Game (SAMG) framework provides a valuable tool for modeling these types of challenges.
However, the paper also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. For example, the analysis of solution concepts is limited to finite state and finite action spaces, and the existence of robust agent policies in more general settings remains an open question.
Additionally, the researchers note that their RMA3C algorithm relies on a particular form of the adversarial perturbation function, and the performance may be sensitive to the choice of this function. Exploring alternative perturbation models or allowing the agents to learn the perturbation function could be an interesting direction for future work.
Another potential area for improvement is in the experimental evaluation. While the results demonstrate the benefits of the RMA3C algorithm, it would be helpful to see a more comprehensive set of benchmarks and comparisons to a wider range of existing MARL methods.
Overall, this paper takes an important step forward in addressing the critical issue of state uncertainties in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning. The proposed solutions and analysis provide a solid foundation for further research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper tackles the challenge of state uncertainties in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) by introducing a new framework called the State-Adversarial Markov Game (SAMG). The researchers analyze existing solution concepts in MARL and find that they may not always exist in the SAMG setting.
To address this, the researchers propose a new solution concept called robust agent policy, which aims to maximize the worst-case expected state value. They also develop a Robust Multi-Agent Adversarial Actor-Critic (RMA3C) algorithm to help agents learn these robust policies.
The experimental results demonstrate that the RMA3C algorithm outperforms existing methods when agents face state perturbations, significantly improving the robustness of MARL systems. This research represents an important step forward in addressing a critical challenge in the field of Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
SUB-PLAY: Adversarial Policies against Partially Observed Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning Systems
Oubo Ma, Yuwen Pu, Linkang Du, Yang Dai, Ruo Wang, Xiaolei Liu, Yingcai Wu, Shouling Ji
0
0
Recent advancements in multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) have opened up vast application prospects, such as swarm control of drones, collaborative manipulation by robotic arms, and multi-target encirclement. However, potential security threats during the MARL deployment need more attention and thorough investigation. Recent research reveals that attackers can rapidly exploit the victim's vulnerabilities, generating adversarial policies that result in the failure of specific tasks. For instance, reducing the winning rate of a superhuman-level Go AI to around 20%. Existing studies predominantly focus on two-player competitive environments, assuming attackers possess complete global state observation. In this study, we unveil, for the first time, the capability of attackers to generate adversarial policies even when restricted to partial observations of the victims in multi-agent competitive environments. Specifically, we propose a novel black-box attack (SUB-PLAY) that incorporates the concept of constructing multiple subgames to mitigate the impact of partial observability and suggests sharing transitions among subpolicies to improve attackers' exploitative ability. Extensive evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness of SUB-PLAY under three typical partial observability limitations. Visualization results indicate that adversarial policies induce significantly different activations of the victims' policy networks. Furthermore, we evaluate three potential defenses aimed at exploring ways to mitigate security threats posed by adversarial policies, providing constructive recommendations for deploying MARL in competitive environments.
6/27/2024
Optimal Attack and Defense for Reinforcement Learning
Jeremy McMahan, Young Wu, Xiaojin Zhu, Qiaomin Xie
0
0
To ensure the usefulness of Reinforcement Learning (RL) in real systems, it is crucial to ensure they are robust to noise and adversarial attacks. In adversarial RL, an external attacker has the power to manipulate the victim agent's interaction with the environment. We study the full class of online manipulation attacks, which include (i) state attacks, (ii) observation attacks (which are a generalization of perceived-state attacks), (iii) action attacks, and (iv) reward attacks. We show the attacker's problem of designing a stealthy attack that maximizes its own expected reward, which often corresponds to minimizing the victim's value, is captured by a Markov Decision Process (MDP) that we call a meta-MDP since it is not the true environment but a higher level environment induced by the attacked interaction. We show that the attacker can derive optimal attacks by planning in polynomial time or learning with polynomial sample complexity using standard RL techniques. We argue that the optimal defense policy for the victim can be computed as the solution to a stochastic Stackelberg game, which can be further simplified into a partially-observable turn-based stochastic game (POTBSG). Neither the attacker nor the victim would benefit from deviating from their respective optimal policies, thus such solutions are truly robust. Although the defense problem is NP-hard, we show that optimal Markovian defenses can be computed (learned) in polynomial time (sample complexity) in many scenarios.
6/18/2024
Efficient Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning by Planning
Qihan Liu, Jianing Ye, Xiaoteng Ma, Jun Yang, Bin Liang, Chongjie Zhang
0
0
Multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) algorithms have accomplished remarkable breakthroughs in solving large-scale decision-making tasks. Nonetheless, most existing MARL algorithms are model-free, limiting sample efficiency and hindering their applicability in more challenging scenarios. In contrast, model-based reinforcement learning (MBRL), particularly algorithms integrating planning, such as MuZero, has demonstrated superhuman performance with limited data in many tasks. Hence, we aim to boost the sample efficiency of MARL by adopting model-based approaches. However, incorporating planning and search methods into multi-agent systems poses significant challenges. The expansive action space of multi-agent systems often necessitates leveraging the nearly-independent property of agents to accelerate learning. To tackle this issue, we propose the MAZero algorithm, which combines a centralized model with Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) for policy search. We design a novel network structure to facilitate distributed execution and parameter sharing. To enhance search efficiency in deterministic environments with sizable action spaces, we introduce two novel techniques: Optimistic Search Lambda (OS($lambda$)) and Advantage-Weighted Policy Optimization (AWPO). Extensive experiments on the SMAC benchmark demonstrate that MAZero outperforms model-free approaches in terms of sample efficiency and provides comparable or better performance than existing model-based methods in terms of both sample and computational efficiency. Our code is available at https://github.com/liuqh16/MAZero.
5/21/2024
Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning with Deep Networks for Diverse Q-Vectors
Zhenglong Luo, Zhiyong Chen, James Welsh
0
0
Multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) has become a significant research topic due to its ability to facilitate learning in complex environments. In multi-agent tasks, the state-action value, commonly referred to as the Q-value, can vary among agents because of their individual rewards, resulting in a Q-vector. Determining an optimal policy is challenging, as it involves more than just maximizing a single Q-value. Various optimal policies, such as a Nash equilibrium, have been studied in this context. Algorithms like Nash Q-learning and Nash Actor-Critic have shown effectiveness in these scenarios. This paper extends this research by proposing a deep Q-networks (DQN) algorithm capable of learning various Q-vectors using Max, Nash, and Maximin strategies. The effectiveness of this approach is demonstrated in an environment where dual robotic arms collaborate to lift a pot.
6/13/2024