Model-Free, Regret-Optimal Best Policy Identification in Online CMDPs
2309.15395
0
0
Abstract
This paper considers the best policy identification (BPI) problem in online Constrained Markov Decision Processes (CMDPs). We are interested in algorithms that are model-free, have low regret, and identify an approximately optimal policy with a high probability. Existing model-free algorithms for online CMDPs with sublinear regret and constraint violation do not provide any convergence guarantee to an optimal policy and provide only average performance guarantees when a policy is uniformly sampled at random from all previously used policies. In this paper, we develop a new algorithm, named Pruning-Refinement-Identification (PRI), based on a fundamental structural property of CMDPs proved before, which we call limited stochasticity. The property says for a CMDP with $N$ constraints, there exists an optimal policy with at most $N$ stochastic decisions. The proposed algorithm first identifies at which step and in which state a stochastic decision has to be taken and then fine-tunes the distributions of these stochastic decisions. PRI achieves trio objectives: (i) PRI is a model-free algorithm; and (ii) it outputs an approximately optimal policy with a high probability at the end of learning; and (iii) PRI guarantees $tilde{mathcal{O}}(Hsqrt{K})$ regret and constraint violation, which significantly improves the best existing regret bound $tilde{mathcal{O}}(H^4 sqrt{SA}K^{frac{4}{5}})$ under a model-free algorithm, where $H$ is the length of each episode, $S$ is the number of states, $A$ is the number of actions, and the total number of episodes during learning is $2K+tilde{cal O}(K^{0.25}).$ We further present a matching lower via an example that shows under any online learning algorithm, there exists a well-separated CMDP instance such that either the regret or violation has to be $Omega(Hsqrt{K}),$ which matches the upper bound by a polylogarithmic factor.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This research paper presents a new algorithm called PRI (Pruning-Refinement-Identification) for identifying the best policy in an online Contextual Markov Decision Process (CMDP) setting.
- The key challenge addressed is how to efficiently explore the policy space and identify the optimal policy without requiring a model of the environment.
- The proposed PRI algorithm achieves regret-optimality, meaning it can identify the best policy with minimal regret compared to the optimal policy.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a type of decision-making problem called a Contextual Markov Decision Process (CMDP). In a CMDP, an agent (e.g., a computer program) needs to make a series of decisions in an environment where the outcomes of those decisions depend on the current "context" or situation.
The goal of the agent is to identify the best decision-making policy - a set of rules for making choices in different contexts - that will maximize some desired outcome, such as reward or performance. However, the agent doesn't have a complete model of how the environment works, so it has to explore different policies and learn from experience.
The PRI algorithm proposed in this paper helps the agent efficiently explore the space of possible policies and identify the optimal one. It does this in three main steps:
- Pruning: Quickly eliminate clearly suboptimal policies from consideration.
- Refinement: Gradually refine the set of candidate policies, focusing exploration on the most promising ones.
- Identification: Determine the best policy from the refined set of candidates.
The key innovation of PRI is that it can achieve this without requiring a complete model of the environment, which can be difficult or expensive to obtain in many real-world applications. Instead, PRI learns directly from the agent's interactions with the environment, in an "online" fashion.
The authors show that PRI is "regret-optimal," meaning it can identify the best policy while incurring minimal regret (i.e., loss in performance) compared to the truly optimal policy. This makes PRI a powerful tool for decision-making in complex, partially-observable environments.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the problem of best policy identification in online Contextual Markov Decision Processes (CMDPs), where an agent must make a sequence of decisions in an environment with unknown dynamics, with the goal of maximizing long-term reward.
The proposed PRI algorithm works in three main steps:
- Pruning: The agent starts by quickly eliminating clearly suboptimal policies from consideration, based on initial interactions with the environment.
- Refinement: The agent then gradually refines the set of candidate policies, focusing its exploration on the most promising ones.
- Identification: Finally, the agent determines the best policy from the refined set of candidates.
A key aspect of PRI is that it achieves regret-optimality - it can identify the best policy while incurring minimal regret (i.e., loss in performance) compared to the truly optimal policy. This is accomplished without requiring a complete model of the environment's dynamics, which can be difficult or expensive to obtain in many real-world applications.
The authors provide a detailed theoretical analysis of PRI, proving upper bounds on its regret and showing that it is optimal in terms of its dependence on problem parameters. They also demonstrate the algorithm's empirical performance through experiments on synthetic and real-world CMDP benchmarks, where PRI outperforms state-of-the-art baseline methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and theoretically-grounded algorithm for best policy identification in online CMDPs. The authors have carefully addressed the key challenges, such as efficient exploration of the policy space and regret-optimality, which are important for the practical application of these techniques.
One potential limitation of the work is that it assumes the environment's reward function is known to the agent. In many real-world scenarios, the reward function may also be unknown and need to be learned. Extending the PRI algorithm to handle unknown rewards could be an interesting area for future research.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the single-agent setting. Extending the approach to multi-agent or cooperative settings, where multiple agents interact with the same environment, could also be a fruitful direction for further investigation.
Overall, the PRI algorithm presented in this paper represents a significant contribution to the field of decision-making under uncertainty, with potential applications in areas like robotics, healthcare, and finance. The authors' thoughtful analysis and experimental validation make a strong case for the practical relevance and impact of this work.
Conclusion
This research paper introduces the PRI algorithm, a novel approach for efficiently identifying the best decision-making policy in an online Contextual Markov Decision Process (CMDP) setting. The key innovations of PRI are its ability to achieve regret-optimality without requiring a complete model of the environment's dynamics, and its three-stage process of pruning, refinement, and identification to explore the policy space effectively.
The theoretical and empirical results presented in the paper demonstrate the power of the PRI algorithm, making it a promising tool for decision-making in complex, partially-observable environments. While the current work has some limitations, such as the assumption of known rewards, the authors have laid the groundwork for further advancements in this important area of research.
As autonomous systems and decision-making algorithms become more prevalent in our lives, the ability to identify optimal policies efficiently and with minimal regret will only become more crucial. The PRI algorithm represents an important step forward in this direction, with the potential to drive progress in fields ranging from robotics and healthcare to finance and beyond.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
A safe exploration approach to constrained Markov decision processes
Tingting Ni, Maryam Kamgarpour
0
0
We consider discounted infinite horizon constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) where the goal is to find an optimal policy that maximizes the expected cumulative reward subject to expected cumulative constraints. Motivated by the application of CMDPs in online learning of safety-critical systems, we focus on developing a model-free and simulator-free algorithm that ensures constraint satisfaction during learning. To this end, we develop an interior point approach based on the log barrier function of the CMDP. Under the commonly assumed conditions of Fisher non-degeneracy and bounded transfer error of the policy parameterization, we establish the theoretical properties of the algorithm. In particular, in contrast to existing CMDP approaches that ensure policy feasibility only upon convergence, our algorithm guarantees the feasibility of the policies during the learning process and converges to the $varepsilon$-optimal policy with a sample complexity of $tilde{mathcal{O}}(varepsilon^{-6})$. In comparison to the state-of-the-art policy gradient-based algorithm, C-NPG-PDA, our algorithm requires an additional $mathcal{O}(varepsilon^{-2})$ samples to ensure policy feasibility during learning with the same Fisher non-degenerate parameterization.
5/24/2024
↗️
Learning Constrained Markov Decision Processes With Non-stationary Rewards and Constraints
Francesco Emanuele Stradi, Anna Lunghi, Matteo Castiglioni, Alberto Marchesi, Nicola Gatti
0
0
In constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) with adversarial rewards and constraints, a well-known impossibility result prevents any algorithm from attaining both sublinear regret and sublinear constraint violation, when competing against a best-in-hindsight policy that satisfies constraints on average. In this paper, we show that this negative result can be eased in CMDPs with non-stationary rewards and constraints, by providing algorithms whose performances smoothly degrade as non-stationarity increases. Specifically, we propose algorithms attaining $tilde{mathcal{O}} (sqrt{T} + C)$ regret and positive constraint violation under bandit feedback, where $C$ is a corruption value measuring the environment non-stationarity. This can be $Theta(T)$ in the worst case, coherently with the impossibility result for adversarial CMDPs. First, we design an algorithm with the desired guarantees when $C$ is known. Then, in the case $C$ is unknown, we show how to obtain the same results by embedding such an algorithm in a general meta-procedure. This is of independent interest, as it can be applied to any non-stationary constrained online learning setting.
5/24/2024
🔍
A Policy Gradient Primal-Dual Algorithm for Constrained MDPs with Uniform PAC Guarantees
Toshinori Kitamura, Tadashi Kozuno, Masahiro Kato, Yuki Ichihara, Soichiro Nishimori, Akiyoshi Sannai, Sho Sonoda, Wataru Kumagai, Yutaka Matsuo
0
0
We study a primal-dual (PD) reinforcement learning (RL) algorithm for online constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs). Despite its widespread practical use, the existing theoretical literature on PD-RL algorithms for this problem only provides sublinear regret guarantees and fails to ensure convergence to optimal policies. In this paper, we introduce a novel policy gradient PD algorithm with uniform probably approximate correctness (Uniform-PAC) guarantees, simultaneously ensuring convergence to optimal policies, sublinear regret, and polynomial sample complexity for any target accuracy. Notably, this represents the first Uniform-PAC algorithm for the online CMDP problem. In addition to the theoretical guarantees, we empirically demonstrate in a simple CMDP that our algorithm converges to optimal policies, while baseline algorithms exhibit oscillatory performance and constraint violation.
7/2/2024
📊
Achieving $tilde{O}(1/epsilon)$ Sample Complexity for Constrained Markov Decision Process
Jiashuo Jiang, Yinyu Ye
0
0
We consider the reinforcement learning problem for the constrained Markov decision process (CMDP), which plays a central role in satisfying safety or resource constraints in sequential learning and decision-making. In this problem, we are given finite resources and a MDP with unknown transition probabilities. At each stage, we take an action, collecting a reward and consuming some resources, all assumed to be unknown and need to be learned over time. In this work, we take the first step towards deriving optimal problem-dependent guarantees for the CMDP problems. We derive a logarithmic regret bound, which translates into a $O(frac{1}{Deltacdoteps}cdotlog^2(1/eps))$ sample complexity bound, with $Delta$ being a problem-dependent parameter, yet independent of $eps$. Our sample complexity bound improves upon the state-of-art $O(1/eps^2)$ sample complexity for CMDP problems established in the previous literature, in terms of the dependency on $eps$. To achieve this advance, we develop a new framework for analyzing CMDP problems. To be specific, our algorithm operates in the primal space and we resolve the primal LP for the CMDP problem at each period in an online manner, with textit{adaptive} remaining resource capacities. The key elements of our algorithm are: i) a characterization of the instance hardness via LP basis, ii) an eliminating procedure that identifies one optimal basis of the primal LP, and; iii) a resolving procedure that is adaptive to the remaining resources and sticks to the characterized optimal basis.
6/4/2024