Predictive Coding beyond Correlations
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents research on automated mapping of virtual environments using visual predictive coding, language reconstruction from brain activity using predictive coding, sample-based causal discovery of aggregate recipes, causal contrastive learning for counterfactual regression over time, and smoke and mirrors in causal downstream tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The paper covers several different research topics related to artificial intelligence and machine learning. It looks at ways to automatically map out virtual environments using visual cues, reconstruct language from brain activity data, discover causal relationships in data, and understand the challenges of causal reasoning in downstream tasks.
The key ideas are using predictive coding to efficiently represent and navigate virtual spaces, extracting meaningful information from complex brain signals, uncovering the underlying causal structure in data, and learning causal relationships even when dealing with confounding factors. The research also highlights some of the challenges in applying causal reasoning to real-world problems.
Overall, this work advances our understanding of how AI and machine learning can be used to model complex environments, extract insights from data, and uncover underlying causal mechanisms - all of which have important implications for a wide range of applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper covers several technical research topics. For automated mapping of virtual environments, the authors propose using a predictive coding approach to efficiently represent and navigate 3D spaces. Their model learns to predict future visual observations, allowing it to build an internal map without requiring prior knowledge.
In the language reconstruction from brain activity work, the researchers use predictive coding principles to reconstruct the linguistic content of people's thoughts based on their fMRI brain activity data. Their model learns to extract meaningful information from the noisy neural signals.
The paper also covers causal discovery techniques that can uncover the underlying causal structure in observational data, using a sample-based approach to estimate causal relationships at the aggregate level. This allows inferring causal models without requiring interventions.
Additionally, the researchers present causal contrastive learning methods for learning causal relationships even in the presence of confounding factors. Their approach enables counterfactual reasoning and causal forecasting over time.
Lastly, the paper discusses the challenges of applying causal reasoning to real-world downstream tasks, highlighting potential issues with extrapolation, confounding, and the difficulty of validating causal claims.
Critical Analysis
The paper tackles a diverse set of technical problems, each with its own caveats and limitations. For the virtual environment mapping work, the authors note that their predictive coding approach may struggle in highly dynamic or complex environments. The language reconstruction research is limited by the coarse spatial resolution of fMRI data and could benefit from combining with other neuroimaging modalities.
The causal discovery and causal contrastive learning techniques rely on strong assumptions about the data-generating process, and their performance may degrade in the presence of unobserved confounders or nonlinear relationships. The authors acknowledge the need for further research to address these limitations.
The discussion of causal reasoning in downstream tasks highlights important practical challenges, such as the difficulty of validating causal claims, the potential for spurious correlations, and the risk of making invalid extrapolations. These are critical issues that the research community will need to grapple with as causal methods become more widely applied.
Overall, the paper presents a diverse set of technical contributions, each of which warrants further investigation and validation. Readers should approach the research with a critical eye, considering the stated limitations and the need for continued advancements in these complex and important areas of AI and machine learning.
Conclusion
This paper tackles a range of technical problems in artificial intelligence and machine learning, including automated mapping of virtual environments, language reconstruction from brain activity, causal discovery, causal contrastive learning, and the challenges of applying causal reasoning to downstream tasks.
The research advances our fundamental understanding of how AI systems can efficiently represent complex environments, extract meaningful insights from noisy data, and uncover underlying causal relationships - all of which have important implications for a wide range of real-world applications. However, the authors also highlight the significant challenges and limitations of these techniques, underscoring the need for continued research and validation.
As the field of AI continues to evolve, this paper provides valuable insights and a thought-provoking perspective on the current state of the art and the future directions for this exciting and rapidly advancing area of study.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Predictive Coding beyond Correlations
Tommaso Salvatori, Luca Pinchetti, Amine M'Charrak, Beren Millidge, Thomas Lukasiewicz
Recently, there has been extensive research on the capabilities of biologically plausible algorithms. In this work, we show how one of such algorithms, called predictive coding, is able to perform causal inference tasks. First, we show how a simple change in the inference process of predictive coding enables to compute interventions without the need to mutilate or redefine a causal graph. Then, we explore applications in cases where the graph is unknown, and has to be inferred from observational data. Empirically, we show how such findings can be used to improve the performance of predictive coding in image classification tasks, and conclude that such models are able to perform simple end-to-end causal inference tasks.
Read more6/4/2024
0
Divide-and-Conquer Predictive Coding: a structured Bayesian inference algorithm
Eli Sennesh, Hao Wu, Tommaso Salvatori
Unexpected stimuli induce error or surprise signals in the brain. The theory of predictive coding promises to explain these observations in terms of Bayesian inference by suggesting that the cortex implements variational inference in a probabilistic graphical model. However, when applied to machine learning tasks, this family of algorithms has yet to perform on par with other variational approaches in high-dimensional, structured inference problems. To address this, we introduce a novel predictive coding algorithm for structured generative models, that we call divide-and-conquer predictive coding (DCPC). DCPC differs from other formulations of predictive coding, as it respects the correlation structure of the generative model and provably performs maximum-likelihood updates of model parameters, all without sacrificing biological plausibility. Empirically, DCPC achieves better numerical performance than competing algorithms and provides accurate inference in a number of problems not previously addressed with predictive coding. We provide an open implementation of DCPC in Pyro on Github.
Read more8/13/2024
0
Predictive Coding Networks and Inference Learning: Tutorial and Survey
Bjorn van Zwol, Ro Jefferson, Egon L. van den Broek
Recent years have witnessed a growing call for renewed emphasis on neuroscience-inspired approaches in artificial intelligence research, under the banner of NeuroAI. A prime example of this is predictive coding networks (PCNs), based on the neuroscientific framework of predictive coding. This framework views the brain as a hierarchical Bayesian inference model that minimizes prediction errors through feedback connections. Unlike traditional neural networks trained with backpropagation (BP), PCNs utilize inference learning (IL), a more biologically plausible algorithm that explains patterns of neural activity that BP cannot. Historically, IL has been more computationally intensive, but recent advancements have demonstrated that it can achieve higher efficiency than BP with sufficient parallelization. Furthermore, PCNs can be mathematically considered a superset of traditional feedforward neural networks (FNNs), significantly extending the range of trainable architectures. As inherently probabilistic (graphical) latent variable models, PCNs provide a versatile framework for both supervised learning and unsupervised (generative) modeling that goes beyond traditional artificial neural networks. This work provides a comprehensive review and detailed formal specification of PCNs, particularly situating them within the context of modern ML methods. Additionally, we introduce a Python library (PRECO) for practical implementation. This positions PC as a promising framework for future ML innovations.
Read more7/23/2024
🤔
0
Automated mapping of virtual environments with visual predictive coding
James Gornet, Matthew Thomson
Humans construct internal cognitive maps of their environment directly from sensory inputs without access to a system of explicit coordinates or distance measurements. While machine learning algorithms like SLAM utilize specialized visual inference procedures to identify visual features and construct spatial maps from visual and odometry data, the general nature of cognitive maps in the brain suggests a unified mapping algorithmic strategy that can generalize to auditory, tactile, and linguistic inputs. Here, we demonstrate that predictive coding provides a natural and versatile neural network algorithm for constructing spatial maps using sensory data. We introduce a framework in which an agent navigates a virtual environment while engaging in visual predictive coding using a self-attention-equipped convolutional neural network. While learning a next image prediction task, the agent automatically constructs an internal representation of the environment that quantitatively reflects distances. The internal map enables the agent to pinpoint its location relative to landmarks using only visual information.The predictive coding network generates a vectorized encoding of the environment that supports vector navigation where individual latent space units delineate localized, overlapping neighborhoods in the environment. Broadly, our work introduces predictive coding as a unified algorithmic framework for constructing cognitive maps that can naturally extend to the mapping of auditory, sensorimotor, and linguistic inputs.
Read more4/19/2024