Revisiting Inexact Fixed-Point Iterations for Min-Max Problems: Stochasticity and Structured Nonconvexity

Read original: arXiv:2402.05071 - Published 8/14/2024 by Ahmet Alacaoglu, Donghwan Kim, Stephen J. Wright

✨

Overview

The research paper focuses on solving constrained, smooth, potentially stochastic, and nonconvex-nonconcave min-max optimization problems.
These problems arise in areas like two-player reinforcement learning, interaction-dominant min-max problems, and certain synthetic test problems.
The key challenge is that classical min-max algorithms can fail on these problem classes.
The paper aims to provide optimal or best-known complexity guarantees under specific conditions, relaxing the constraints of previous results.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at a class of optimization problems called "min-max" problems, which involve finding the best solution when two competing objectives are involved. These problems can be challenging because they can be constrained, smooth, stochastic, and nonconvex-nonconcave, meaning they don't have simple, well-behaved mathematical properties.

These types of problems arise in applications like two-player reinforcement learning, where two agents are trying to optimize their own objectives, and in certain synthetic test problems. Classical optimization algorithms can struggle with these problems, so the researchers aim to develop new techniques that can handle the challenging characteristics.

The key insight is to leverage a recently proposed "conic nonexpansiveness" property of the operators involved in the optimization process. This allows the researchers to obtain improved convergence guarantees compared to previous results, relaxing some of the restrictive conditions. The paper also provides a refined analysis for a specific optimization algorithm, further improving the state of the art for certain problem classes.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on constrained, L-smooth, potentially stochastic, and nonconvex-nonconcave min-max optimization problems. These problems either satisfy ρ-cohypomonotonicity or admit a solution to the ρ-weakly Minty Variational Inequality (MVI), where larger values of ρ>0 correspond to a greater degree of nonconvexity.

The key technical contributions are:

Leveraging Conic Nonexpansiveness: The researchers harness the recently proposed "conic nonexpansiveness" property of operators to obtain optimal or best-known complexity guarantees for ρ < 1/L, improving upon previous results that were limited to ρ < 1/2L.
Refined Inexact Halpern Iteration Analysis: The paper provides a refined analysis for inexact Halpern iteration, which relaxes the required inexactness level and improves the state-of-the-art complexity results even for constrained stochastic convex-concave min-max problems.
Stochastic Inexact Krasnosel'skiu{i}-Mann Iteration: The researchers analyze a stochastic inexact Krasnosel'skiu{i}-Mann iteration with a multilevel Monte Carlo estimator, where the assumptions only need to hold with respect to a solution.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents promising theoretical results, extending the limits of what is possible with first-order methods for solving challenging min-max optimization problems. The use of the conic nonexpansiveness property and the refined analyses of the inexact iterative algorithms are notable technical contributions.

However, the paper focuses solely on the theoretical aspects and does not provide any empirical validation of the proposed algorithms. It would be helpful to see how the methods perform on real-world problem instances or benchmarks, as the practical implications of the theoretical results are not immediately clear.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or caveats of the proposed approaches. For example, it is unclear how sensitive the methods are to the specific assumptions, such as the ρ-cohypomonotonicity or ρ-weakly Minty Variational Inequality conditions, and how these conditions can be verified or guaranteed in practice.

Further research could explore the practical applicability of the techniques, their robustness to relaxed assumptions, and the development of efficient algorithms that can leverage the theoretical insights presented in this work.

Conclusion

This research paper provides important theoretical advances in the field of min-max optimization, addressing a class of challenging problems that arise in various applications. By leveraging the conic nonexpansiveness property and refining the analyses of iterative algorithms, the researchers have obtained improved complexity guarantees, relaxing some of the restrictive conditions of previous results.

While the paper is focused on the theoretical aspects, the insights and techniques presented could have significant implications for the development of practical solvers for min-max optimization problems, particularly in domains like reinforcement learning and interaction-dominant systems. Further empirical validation and exploration of the practical limitations and extensions of the proposed methods could help bridge the gap between theory and practice in this important area of optimization.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

✨

Revisiting Inexact Fixed-Point Iterations for Min-Max Problems: Stochasticity and Structured Nonconvexity

Ahmet Alacaoglu, Donghwan Kim, Stephen J. Wright

We focus on constrained, $L$-smooth, potentially stochastic and nonconvex-nonconcave min-max problems either satisfying $rho$-cohypomonotonicity or admitting a solution to the $rho$-weakly Minty Variational Inequality (MVI), where larger values of the parameter $rho>0$ correspond to a greater degree of nonconvexity. These problem classes include examples in two player reinforcement learning, interaction dominant min-max problems, and certain synthetic test problems on which classical min-max algorithms fail. It has been conjectured that first-order methods can tolerate a value of $rho$ no larger than $frac{1}{L}$, but existing results in the literature have stagnated at the tighter requirement $rho < frac{1}{2L}$. With a simple argument, we obtain optimal or best-known complexity guarantees with cohypomonotonicity or weak MVI conditions for $rho < frac{1}{L}$. First main insight for the improvements in the convergence analyses is to harness the recently proposed $textit{conic nonexpansiveness}$ property of operators. Second, we provide a refined analysis for inexact Halpern iteration that relaxes the required inexactness level to improve some state-of-the-art complexity results even for constrained stochastic convex-concave min-max problems. Third, we analyze a stochastic inexact Krasnosel'skiu{i}-Mann iteration with a multilevel Monte Carlo estimator when the assumptions only hold with respect to a solution.

8/14/2024

Accelerated Stochastic Min-Max Optimization Based on Bias-corrected Momentum

Haoyuan Cai, Sulaiman A. Alghunaim, Ali H. Sayed

Lower-bound analyses for nonconvex strongly-concave minimax optimization problems have shown that stochastic first-order algorithms require at least $mathcal{O}(varepsilon^{-4})$ oracle complexity to find an $varepsilon$-stationary point. Some works indicate that this complexity can be improved to $mathcal{O}(varepsilon^{-3})$ when the loss gradient is Lipschitz continuous. The question of achieving enhanced convergence rates under distinct conditions, remains unresolved. In this work, we address this question for optimization problems that are nonconvex in the minimization variable and strongly concave or Polyak-Lojasiewicz (PL) in the maximization variable. We introduce novel bias-corrected momentum algorithms utilizing efficient Hessian-vector products. We establish convergence conditions and demonstrate a lower iteration complexity of $mathcal{O}(varepsilon^{-3})$ for the proposed algorithms. The effectiveness of the method is validated through applications to robust logistic regression using real-world datasets.

6/21/2024

🛠️

New!Variance-reduced first-order methods for deterministically constrained stochastic nonconvex optimization with strong convergence guarantees

Zhaosong Lu, Sanyou Mei, Yifeng Xiao

In this paper, we study a class of deterministically constrained stochastic optimization problems. Existing methods typically aim to find an $epsilon$-stochastic stationary point, where the expected violations of both constraints and first-order stationarity are within a prescribed accuracy $epsilon$. However, in many practical applications, it is crucial that the constraints be nearly satisfied with certainty, making such an $epsilon$-stochastic stationary point potentially undesirable due to the risk of significant constraint violations. To address this issue, we propose single-loop variance-reduced stochastic first-order methods, where the stochastic gradient of the stochastic component is computed using either a truncated recursive momentum scheme or a truncated Polyak momentum scheme for variance reduction, while the gradient of the deterministic component is computed exactly. Under the error bound condition with a parameter $theta geq 1$ and other suitable assumptions, we establish that the proposed methods achieve a sample complexity and first-order operation complexity of $widetilde O(epsilon^{-max{4, 2theta}})$ for finding a stronger $epsilon$-stochastic stationary point, where the constraint violation is within $epsilon$ with certainty, and the expected violation of first-order stationarity is within $epsilon$. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to develop methods with provable complexity guarantees for finding an approximate stochastic stationary point of such problems that nearly satisfies all constraints with certainty.

9/18/2024

Single-loop Stochastic Algorithms for Difference of Max-Structured Weakly Convex Functions

Quanqi Hu, Qi Qi, Zhaosong Lu, Tianbao Yang

In this paper, we study a class of non-smooth non-convex problems in the form of $min_{x}[max_{yin Y}phi(x, y) - max_{zin Z}psi(x, z)]$, where both $Phi(x) = max_{yin Y}phi(x, y)$ and $Psi(x)=max_{zin Z}psi(x, z)$ are weakly convex functions, and $phi(x, y), psi(x, z)$ are strongly concave functions in terms of $y$ and $z$, respectively. It covers two families of problems that have been studied but are missing single-loop stochastic algorithms, i.e., difference of weakly convex functions and weakly convex strongly-concave min-max problems. We propose a stochastic Moreau envelope approximate gradient method dubbed SMAG, the first single-loop algorithm for solving these problems, and provide a state-of-the-art non-asymptotic convergence rate. The key idea of the design is to compute an approximate gradient of the Moreau envelopes of $Phi, Psi$ using only one step of stochastic gradient update of the primal and dual variables. Empirically, we conduct experiments on positive-unlabeled (PU) learning and partial area under ROC curve (pAUC) optimization with an adversarial fairness regularizer to validate the effectiveness of our proposed algorithms.

5/31/2024