Rewarding What Matters: Step-by-Step Reinforcement Learning for Task-Oriented Dialogue
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper presents a step-by-step reinforcement learning approach for training task-oriented dialogue agents to focus on the most relevant aspects of the dialogue.
• The authors develop a novel reward shaping technique that encourages the agent to make progress towards the desired goal in a more targeted and efficient manner.
• The proposed method, called Rewarding What Matters, is evaluated on a set of task-oriented dialogue benchmarks and shows improved performance compared to baseline approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a way to train conversational AI agents, such as virtual assistants, to be better at completing specific tasks through dialogue. Traditional reinforcement learning approaches for training these agents often reward the agent for any progress made during the conversation, even if it's not directly relevant to the main goal.
The authors of this paper propose a new method that focuses the agent's training on the most important aspects of the dialogue. Instead of just rewarding the agent for any progress, their approach gives the agent more targeted feedback on how well it is moving towards the desired outcome.
This is achieved through a technique called "reward shaping," which modifies the reward signal the agent receives during training to better align with the truly important steps in the conversation. By guiding the agent's learning in this way, the authors show that the agent can become more efficient and effective at completing the target task.
The Rewarding What Matters method is evaluated on several benchmark tasks for task-oriented dialogue, and the results demonstrate its advantages over traditional reinforcement learning approaches.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel reward shaping technique called Rewarding What Matters for training task-oriented dialogue agents using reinforcement learning.
The key idea is to design a more targeted reward function that encourages the agent to make progress towards the desired goal in a step-by-step manner. This is in contrast to typical reinforcement learning approaches, where the agent is rewarded for any progress made during the dialogue, even if it's not directly relevant to the main task.
The Rewarding What Matters method works by first decomposing the task into a sequence of sub-goals. Then, during training, the agent receives a reward signal that is shaped to incentivize the agent to complete these sub-goals in the correct order.
The authors evaluate their approach on several task-oriented dialogue benchmarks, including MultiWOZ, SGD, and ConvLab-2. The results show that the Rewarding What Matters approach outperforms baseline reinforcement learning methods, demonstrating the benefits of guiding the agent's learning towards the most relevant aspects of the dialogue.
Critical Analysis
The Rewarding What Matters approach presents a promising step towards more efficient and effective training of task-oriented dialogue agents. By focusing the agent's learning on the most important aspects of the dialogue, the method can lead to improved performance and sample efficiency.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the approach. For example, the decomposition of the task into sub-goals may not always be straightforward, and the method's performance may be sensitive to the quality of this decomposition. Additionally, the paper does not explore how the Rewarding What Matters approach would scale to more complex, open-ended dialogue tasks or how it might interact with other techniques, such as Label-Sensitive Reward or Text2Reward.
Further research could investigate the robustness of the Rewarding What Matters method, explore ways to automate the sub-goal decomposition process, and examine its applicability to a wider range of dialogue tasks and scenarios.
Conclusion
The Rewarding What Matters paper presents a novel reward shaping technique for training task-oriented dialogue agents using reinforcement learning. By focusing the agent's learning on the most relevant aspects of the dialogue, the method can lead to improved performance and sample efficiency compared to traditional reinforcement learning approaches.
The authors' evaluation on several benchmark tasks demonstrates the advantages of their approach, and the paper contributes an important step towards more effective and efficient training of conversational AI systems. While the method has some potential limitations, the paper opens up interesting avenues for future research in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Rewarding What Matters: Step-by-Step Reinforcement Learning for Task-Oriented Dialogue
Huifang Du, Shuqin Li, Minghao Wu, Xuejing Feng, Yuan-Fang Li, Haofen Wang
Reinforcement learning (RL) is a powerful approach to enhance task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems. However, existing RL methods tend to mainly focus on generation tasks, such as dialogue policy learning (DPL) or response generation (RG), while neglecting dialogue state tracking (DST) for understanding. This narrow focus limits the systems to achieve globally optimal performance by overlooking the interdependence between understanding and generation. Additionally, RL methods face challenges with sparse and delayed rewards, which complicates training and optimization. To address these issues, we extend RL into both understanding and generation tasks by introducing step-by-step rewards throughout the token generation. The understanding reward increases as more slots are correctly filled in DST, while the generation reward grows with the accurate inclusion of user requests. Our approach provides a balanced optimization aligned with task completion. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach effectively enhances the performance of TOD systems and achieves new state-of-the-art results on three widely used datasets, including MultiWOZ2.0, MultiWOZ2.1, and In-Car. Our approach also shows superior few-shot ability in low-resource settings compared to current models.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Affordance-Guided Reinforcement Learning via Visual Prompting
Olivia Y. Lee, Annie Xie, Kuan Fang, Karl Pertsch, Chelsea Finn
Robots equipped with reinforcement learning (RL) have the potential to learn a wide range of skills solely from a reward signal. However, obtaining a robust and dense reward signal for general manipulation tasks remains a challenge. Existing learning-based approaches require significant data, such as demonstrations or examples of success and failure, to learn task-specific reward functions. Recently, there is also a growing adoption of large multi-modal foundation models for robotics. These models can perform visual reasoning in physical contexts and generate coarse robot motions for various manipulation tasks. Motivated by this range of capability, in this work, we propose and study rewards shaped by vision-language models (VLMs). State-of-the-art VLMs have demonstrated an impressive ability to reason about affordances through keypoints in zero-shot, and we leverage this to define dense rewards for robotic learning. On a real-world manipulation task specified by natural language description, we find that these rewards improve the sample efficiency of autonomous RL and enable successful completion of the task in 20K online finetuning steps. Additionally, we demonstrate the robustness of the approach to reductions in the number of in-domain demonstrations used for pretraining, reaching comparable performance in 35K online finetuning steps.
Read more7/16/2024
🤿
0
Advancing Household Robotics: Deep Interactive Reinforcement Learning for Efficient Training and Enhanced Performance
Arpita Soni, Sujatha Alla, Suresh Dodda, Hemanth Volikatla
The market for domestic robots made to perform household chores is growing as these robots relieve people of everyday responsibilities. Domestic robots are generally welcomed for their role in easing human labor, in contrast to industrial robots, which are frequently criticized for displacing human workers. But before these robots can carry out domestic chores, they need to become proficient in several minor activities, such as recognizing their surroundings, making decisions, and picking up on human behaviors. Reinforcement learning, or RL, has emerged as a key robotics technology that enables robots to interact with their environment and learn how to optimize their actions to maximize rewards. However, the goal of Deep Reinforcement Learning is to address more complicated, continuous action-state spaces in real-world settings by combining RL with Neural Networks. The efficacy of DeepRL can be further augmented through interactive feedback, in which a trainer offers real-time guidance to expedite the robot's learning process. Nevertheless, the current methods have drawbacks, namely the transient application of guidance that results in repeated learning under identical conditions. Therefore, we present a novel method to preserve and reuse information and advice via Deep Interactive Reinforcement Learning, which utilizes a persistent rule-based system. This method not only expedites the training process but also lessens the number of repetitions that instructors will have to carry out. This study has the potential to advance the development of household robots and improve their effectiveness and efficiency as learners.
Read more5/30/2024
🔍
0
Tiered Reward: Designing Rewards for Specification and Fast Learning of Desired Behavior
Zhiyuan Zhou, Shreyas Sundara Raman, Henry Sowerby, Michael L. Littman
Reinforcement-learning agents seek to maximize a reward signal through environmental interactions. As humans, our job in the learning process is to design reward functions to express desired behavior and enable the agent to learn such behavior swiftly. However, designing good reward functions to induce the desired behavior is generally hard, let alone the question of which rewards make learning fast. In this work, we introduce a family of a reward structures we call Tiered Reward that addresses both of these questions. We consider the reward-design problem in tasks formulated as reaching desirable states and avoiding undesirable states. To start, we propose a strict partial ordering of the policy space to resolve trade-offs in behavior preference. We prefer policies that reach the good states faster and with higher probability while avoiding the bad states longer. Next, we introduce Tiered Reward, a class of environment-independent reward functions and show it is guaranteed to induce policies that are Pareto-optimal according to our preference relation. Finally, we demonstrate that Tiered Reward leads to fast learning with multiple tabular and deep reinforcement-learning algorithms.
Read more8/2/2024