Tiered Reward: Designing Rewards for Specification and Fast Learning of Desired Behavior

Overview

• Reinforcement learning agents aim to maximize a reward signal by interacting with their environment.
• Designing good reward functions to induce the desired behavior is challenging, as is ensuring fast learning.
• This work introduces a family of reward structures called "Tiered Reward" to address these challenges.

Plain English Explanation

Reinforcement learning is a type of machine learning where an agent tries to learn the best actions to take in an environment in order to maximize a reward signal. As humans, our job is to design these reward functions to express the behavior we want the agent to learn and enable it to learn that behavior quickly.

However, designing good reward functions that lead to the desired behavior is generally quite difficult. It's also not easy to know what rewards will make the learning process fast. This paper introduces a new type of reward structure called "Tiered Reward" that aims to address both of these challenges.

The researchers consider reward design for tasks where the goal is to reach desirable states and avoid undesirable states. They propose a way to order the possible policies (the different ways the agent could behave) based on preferences - favoring policies that reach the good states faster and more reliably, while avoiding the bad states for longer.

The Tiered Reward approach is a class of environment-independent reward functions that is guaranteed to lead to policies that are Pareto-optimal according to this preference ordering. The researchers also show that Tiered Reward leads to fast learning with a variety of reinforcement learning algorithms, both simple and more advanced.

Technical Explanation

The core idea behind this work is to impose a strict partial ordering on the space of reinforcement learning policies. This ordering prefers policies that:

1. Reach the desirable states faster
2. Reach the desirable states with higher probability
3. Avoid the undesirable states for longer

The researchers introduce a class of reward functions called "Tiered Reward" that are designed to induce policies that are Pareto-optimal according to this preference ordering. Tiered Reward works by dividing the state space into tiers, with higher tiers representing more desirable states. The reward function then provides a higher reward for reaching higher tiers, while also avoiding catastrophic forgetting of lower tiers.

The key benefit of Tiered Reward is that it allows the reward function to be specified independently of the environment dynamics. This makes it more generally applicable than reward functions that are tightly coupled to a particular task. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of Tiered Reward with both tabular and deep reinforcement learning algorithms, showing that it leads to faster learning compared to standard reward shaping approaches.

Critical Analysis

The Tiered Reward approach proposed in this paper addresses an important challenge in reinforcement learning - how to design reward functions that induce the desired behavior and enable fast learning. By explicitly encoding preferences over policies, the method helps resolve common trade-offs in reward design.

That said, the paper does not address some potential limitations or areas for further research. For example, it's not clear how the tiering of states should be determined in practice, especially for complex environments. The researchers also don't explore how sensitive the method is to the specific ordering of tiers.

Additionally, while the paper shows Tiered Reward outperforms standard reward shaping, it would be helpful to see comparisons to other advanced reward modeling techniques, such as inverse reward design or multi-objective optimization. These could provide further insights into the strengths and limitations of the proposed approach.

Overall, the Tiered Reward method is a promising contribution, but additional research is needed to fully understand its capabilities and practical applicability.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a new family of reward structures called Tiered Reward that aims to address two key challenges in reinforcement learning: designing reward functions to induce desired behavior, and enabling fast learning.

By imposing a strict partial ordering on the policy space and designing rewards to optimize for this ordering, Tiered Reward is able to produce policies that reach good states quickly, reliably avoid bad states, and learn efficiently. The environment-independent nature of the reward function also makes it more generally applicable than approaches tightly coupled to specific tasks.

While the paper highlights the benefits of Tiered Reward, further research is needed to fully understand its limitations and how it compares to other advanced reward modeling techniques. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in the quest to create reinforcement learning agents that can reliably learn to behave in accordance with human preferences.