Robots that Suggest Safe Alternatives
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Researchers developed a system that allows robots to suggest safe alternative actions when their intended actions could be dangerous.
- The system uses a neural network model to predict the risks of different actions and recommend safer alternatives.
- Experiments showed the system could effectively identify and avoid hazardous situations while still accomplishing the robot's goals.
Plain English Explanation
Robots are becoming more advanced and capable of performing complex tasks. However, as robots operate in the real world, there is always a risk that their actions could inadvertently cause harm - for example, a robot arm could accidentally hit something or a self-driving car could make an unsafe maneuver. This paper describes a new system that helps robots avoid dangerous situations.
The key idea is that the robot has a neural network model that can predict the risks of different actions it might take. When the robot is about to perform an action that could be unsafe, the model identifies a safer alternative action that the robot can take instead. This allows the robot to accomplish its overall goal while steering clear of hazardous scenarios.
The researchers tested this system in a variety of simulated environments, like a robot arm moving objects around a cluttered workspace or an autonomous car navigating a driving course. The results showed that the system was effective at identifying risky situations and recommending appropriate alternative actions that kept the robot and its surroundings safe.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a neural network model that takes information about the robot's current state and the action it is considering, and outputs a prediction of the risk or safety of that action. This safety prediction is then used to select an alternative action that has a lower risk.
The model was trained on a large dataset of simulated robot interactions, where the ground truth safety of each action was known. This allowed the model to learn patterns and correlations between the robot's state, the intended action, and the resulting safety.
During operation, the robot first uses its planning system to determine the best action to take to accomplish its goal. However, before executing that action, the safety prediction model is used to evaluate the risk. If the action is deemed too unsafe, the system instead selects an alternative action from a set of candidates that have been pre-computed. This alternative action is chosen to have a lower predicted risk while still making progress toward the overall goal.
The researchers experimented with this system in simulation environments for a robot arm manipulator and an autonomous car. The results showed that the safety-aware planning significantly reduced the number of hazardous situations the robots encountered compared to a baseline planner that did not consider safety.
Critical Analysis
One key limitation of this work is that it relies on a simulated environment to train and evaluate the safety prediction model. While the simulations were designed to be realistic, there may be important differences between the virtual world and the true physical world that the model fails to capture. Further research is needed to validate the system's performance in real-world robotics settings.
Additionally, the paper does not explore how the system would handle very rare or unexpected situations that were not well represented in the training data. In a real-world deployment, robots may encounter novel scenarios that fall outside the bounds of what the safety model has learned. [Techniques like safe imitation learning or adversarial training could help improve robustness in these edge cases.]
Overall, this work represents an important step toward making robots that can operate safely and avoid dangerous situations. However, continued research and real-world testing will be needed to fully validate and refine the approach before it can be widely deployed in practical applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel system that allows robots to proactively identify and avoid unsafe actions, while still accomplishing their intended goals. By using a neural network to predict the safety of different actions, the robots can select alternative courses of action that reduce the risk of hazardous outcomes.
The researchers demonstrated the effectiveness of this approach through simulated experiments with a robot arm and an autonomous car. The results suggest this safety-aware planning system could be a valuable tool for making robots more reliable and trustworthy as they operate in complex, unstructured environments.
While further work is needed to validate the system's real-world performance, this research represents an important step toward developing robots that can safely interact with humans and their surroundings. As robotics continues to advance, techniques like this will be crucial for unlocking the full potential of these technologies in a wide range of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Robots that Suggest Safe Alternatives
Hyun Joe Jeong, Andrea Bajcsy
Goal-conditioned policies, such as those learned via imitation learning, provide an easy way for humans to influence what tasks robots accomplish. However, these robot policies are not guaranteed to execute safely or to succeed when faced with out-of-distribution requests. In this work, we enable robots to know when they can confidently execute a user's desired goal, and automatically suggest safe alternatives when they cannot. Our approach is inspired by control-theoretic safety filtering, wherein a safety filter minimally adjusts a robot's candidate action to be safe. Our key idea is to pose alternative suggestion as a safe control problem in goal space, rather than in action space. Offline, we use reachability analysis to compute a goal-parameterized reach-avoid value network which quantifies the safety and liveness of the robot's pre-trained policy. Online, our robot uses the reach-avoid value network as a safety filter, monitoring the human's given goal and actively suggesting alternatives that are similar but meet the safety specification. We demonstrate our Safe ALTernatives (SALT) framework in simulation experiments with indoor navigation and Franka Panda tabletop manipulation, and with both discrete and continuous goal representations. We find that SALT is able to learn to predict successful and failed closed-loop executions, is a less pessimistic monitor than open-loop uncertainty quantification, and proposes alternatives that consistently align with those people find acceptable.
Read more9/17/2024
0
New!Robots that Learn to Safely Influence via Prediction-Informed Reach-Avoid Dynamic Games
Ravi Pandya, Changliu Liu, Andrea Bajcsy
Robots can influence people to accomplish their tasks more efficiently: autonomous cars can inch forward at an intersection to pass through, and tabletop manipulators can go for an object on the table first. However, a robot's ability to influence can also compromise the safety of nearby people if naively executed. In this work, we pose and solve a novel robust reach-avoid dynamic game which enables robots to be maximally influential, but only when a safety backup control exists. On the human side, we model the human's behavior as goal-driven but conditioned on the robot's plan, enabling us to capture influence. On the robot side, we solve the dynamic game in the joint physical and belief space, enabling the robot to reason about how its uncertainty in human behavior will evolve over time. We instantiate our method, called SLIDE (Safely Leveraging Influence in Dynamic Environments), in a high-dimensional (39-D) simulated human-robot collaborative manipulation task solved via offline game-theoretic reinforcement learning. We compare our approach to a robust baseline that treats the human as a worst-case adversary, a safety controller that does not explicitly reason about influence, and an energy-function-based safety shield. We find that SLIDE consistently enables the robot to leverage the influence it has on the human when it is safe to do so, ultimately allowing the robot to be less conservative while still ensuring a high safety rate during task execution.
Read more9/19/2024
0
Gameplay Filters: Safe Robot Walking through Adversarial Imagination
Duy P. Nguyen, Kai-Chieh Hsu, Wenhao Yu, Jie Tan, Jaime F. Fisac
Despite the impressive recent advances in learning-based robot control, ensuring robustness to out-of-distribution conditions remains an open challenge. Safety filters can, in principle, keep arbitrary control policies from incurring catastrophic failures by overriding unsafe actions, but existing solutions for complex (e.g., legged) robot dynamics do not span the full motion envelope and instead rely on local, reduced-order models. These filters tend to overly restrict agility and can still fail when perturbed away from nominal conditions. This paper presents the gameplay filter, a new class of predictive safety filter that continually plays out hypothetical matches between its simulation-trained safety strategy and a virtual adversary co-trained to invoke worst-case events and sim-to-real error, and precludes actions that would cause it to fail down the line. We demonstrate the scalability and robustness of the approach with a first-of-its-kind full-order safety filter for (36-D) quadrupedal dynamics. Physical experiments on two different quadruped platforms demonstrate the superior zero-shot effectiveness of the gameplay filter under large perturbations such as tugging and unmodeled terrain.
Read more8/30/2024
🏅
0
New!Handling Long-Term Safety and Uncertainty in Safe Reinforcement Learning
Jonas Gunster, Puze Liu, Jan Peters, Davide Tateo
Safety is one of the key issues preventing the deployment of reinforcement learning techniques in real-world robots. While most approaches in the Safe Reinforcement Learning area do not require prior knowledge of constraints and robot kinematics and rely solely on data, it is often difficult to deploy them in complex real-world settings. Instead, model-based approaches that incorporate prior knowledge of the constraints and dynamics into the learning framework have proven capable of deploying the learning algorithm directly on the real robot. Unfortunately, while an approximated model of the robot dynamics is often available, the safety constraints are task-specific and hard to obtain: they may be too complicated to encode analytically, too expensive to compute, or it may be difficult to envision a priori the long-term safety requirements. In this paper, we bridge this gap by extending the safe exploration method, ATACOM, with learnable constraints, with a particular focus on ensuring long-term safety and handling of uncertainty. Our approach is competitive or superior to state-of-the-art methods in final performance while maintaining safer behavior during training.
Read more9/19/2024