Solving Continual Offline Reinforcement Learning with Decision Transformer
2401.08478
0
1
🏅
Abstract
Continuous offline reinforcement learning (CORL) combines continuous and offline reinforcement learning, enabling agents to learn multiple tasks from static datasets without forgetting prior tasks. However, CORL faces challenges in balancing stability and plasticity. Existing methods, employing Actor-Critic structures and experience replay (ER), suffer from distribution shifts, low efficiency, and weak knowledge-sharing. We aim to investigate whether Decision Transformer (DT), another offline RL paradigm, can serve as a more suitable offline continuous learner to address these issues. We first compare AC-based offline algorithms with DT in the CORL framework. DT offers advantages in learning efficiency, distribution shift mitigation, and zero-shot generalization but exacerbates the forgetting problem during supervised parameter updates. We introduce multi-head DT (MH-DT) and low-rank adaptation DT (LoRA-DT) to mitigate DT's forgetting problem. MH-DT stores task-specific knowledge using multiple heads, facilitating knowledge sharing with common components. It employs distillation and selective rehearsal to enhance current task learning when a replay buffer is available. In buffer-unavailable scenarios, LoRA-DT merges less influential weights and fine-tunes DT's decisive MLP layer to adapt to the current task. Extensive experiments on MoJuCo and Meta-World benchmarks demonstrate that our methods outperform SOTA CORL baselines and showcase enhanced learning capabilities and superior memory efficiency.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Continuous offline reinforcement learning (CORL) allows agents to learn multiple tasks from static datasets without forgetting prior tasks
- However, CORL faces challenges in balancing stability and plasticity
- Existing CORL methods, using Actor-Critic structures and experience replay, suffer from distribution shifts, low efficiency, and weak knowledge-sharing
- This research investigates whether Decision Transformer (DT), another offline RL paradigm, can serve as a more suitable offline continuous learner to address these issues
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a way for AI agents to continuously learn multiple tasks from pre-existing data, without forgetting what they've learned before. This is a challenging problem because the agents need to balance being able to learn new skills (plasticity) with retaining their existing knowledge (stability).
Current methods for this "continuous offline reinforcement learning" (CORL) use structures like Actor-Critic and experience replay, but these have issues like inefficiency and struggling to share knowledge between tasks.
The researchers wanted to see if a different offline reinforcement learning approach, called Decision Transformer, could do a better job. Decision Transformer has some advantages like improved learning efficiency and being able to generalize to new situations. However, it also has problems with forgetting previous skills.
To address this, the researchers developed two new variations of Decision Transformer - Multi-Head Decision Transformer (MH-DT) and Low-Rank Adaptation Decision Transformer (LoRA-DT). These methods allow the agent to store task-specific knowledge and adapt to new tasks in a more memory-efficient way.
Through extensive experiments, the researchers show that their new approaches outperform existing state-of-the-art CORL methods, demonstrating enhanced learning capabilities and better memory efficiency.
Technical Explanation
The paper first compares standard Actor-Critic based offline RL algorithms with Decision Transformer (DT) in the CORL setting. DT offers advantages in learning efficiency, mitigating distribution shifts, and zero-shot generalization, but it exacerbates the forgetting problem during supervised parameter updates.
To address DT's forgetting issue, the researchers introduce two novel methods:
-
Multi-Head Decision Transformer (MH-DT): MH-DT stores task-specific knowledge using multiple heads, facilitating knowledge sharing with common components. It employs distillation and selective rehearsal to enhance current task learning when a replay buffer is available.
-
Low-Rank Adaptation Decision Transformer (LoRA-DT): In buffer-unavailable scenarios, LoRA-DT merges less influential weights and fine-tunes DT's decisive MLP layer to adapt to the current task, as proposed in INFLORA.
The researchers conduct extensive experiments on the MoJuCo and Meta-World benchmarks, demonstrating that their methods outperform state-of-the-art CORL baselines and showcase enhanced learning capabilities and superior memory efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to address the challenges of continuous offline reinforcement learning (CORL), which is an important problem for enabling efficient, flexible, and scalable AI agents. The authors' proposed methods, MH-DT and LoRA-DT, show substantial improvements over existing CORL algorithms.
However, the paper could have delved deeper into discussing the potential limitations and caveats of their approach. For example, it would be helpful to understand how the methods scale to a larger number of tasks, the impact of task similarity on performance, and the sensitivity to hyperparameter choices.
Additionally, the authors could have provided a more thorough analysis of the trade-offs between the two proposed methods. While MH-DT and LoRA-DT both aim to mitigate forgetting, it's unclear how they compare in terms of practical considerations like implementation complexity, computational overhead, and data efficiency.
Furthermore, the paper does not address potential negative societal impacts or ethical considerations that may arise from the deployment of such CORL systems. As these technologies become more advanced and widespread, it is crucial to consider these important aspects alongside the technical advancements.
Overall, the research presented in this paper represents a valuable contribution to the field of continuous offline reinforcement learning. With further exploration of the limitations and potential societal implications, this work could have a significant impact on the development of more robust and adaptable AI agents.
Conclusion
This paper investigates the use of Decision Transformer (DT), an offline reinforcement learning paradigm, as a potential solution to the challenges faced by continuous offline reinforcement learning (CORL). The researchers introduce two novel methods, Multi-Head Decision Transformer (MH-DT) and Low-Rank Adaptation Decision Transformer (LoRA-DT), to address DT's forgetting problem and enhance its capabilities as an offline continuous learner.
Through extensive experiments, the researchers demonstrate that their proposed methods outperform state-of-the-art CORL baselines, showcasing improved learning efficiency, distribution shift mitigation, and superior memory efficiency. This work represents a significant advancement in the field of CORL and could have far-reaching implications for the development of more adaptable and versatile AI agents.
The researchers' efforts to address the stability-plasticity challenge in CORL, combined with the innovative use of Decision Transformer, highlight the potential of this approach to enable AI systems that can continuously learn and adapt to new tasks without losing their previous knowledge. As the field of AI continues to evolve, research like this will be crucial in shaping the next generation of intelligent systems that can operate effectively in complex, dynamic environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
OER: Offline Experience Replay for Continual Offline Reinforcement Learning
Sibo Gai, Donglin Wang, Li He
0
0
The capability of continuously learning new skills via a sequence of pre-collected offline datasets is desired for an agent. However, consecutively learning a sequence of offline tasks likely leads to the catastrophic forgetting issue under resource-limited scenarios. In this paper, we formulate a new setting, continual offline reinforcement learning (CORL), where an agent learns a sequence of offline reinforcement learning tasks and pursues good performance on all learned tasks with a small replay buffer without exploring any of the environments of all the sequential tasks. For consistently learning on all sequential tasks, an agent requires acquiring new knowledge and meanwhile preserving old knowledge in an offline manner. To this end, we introduced continual learning algorithms and experimentally found experience replay (ER) to be the most suitable algorithm for the CORL problem. However, we observe that introducing ER into CORL encounters a new distribution shift problem: the mismatch between the experiences in the replay buffer and trajectories from the learned policy. To address such an issue, we propose a new model-based experience selection (MBES) scheme to build the replay buffer, where a transition model is learned to approximate the state distribution. This model is used to bridge the distribution bias between the replay buffer and the learned model by filtering the data from offline data that most closely resembles the learned model for storage. Moreover, in order to enhance the ability on learning new tasks, we retrofit the experience replay method with a new dual behavior cloning (DBC) architecture to avoid the disturbance of behavior-cloning loss on the Q-learning process. In general, we call our algorithm offline experience replay (OER). Extensive experiments demonstrate that our OER method outperforms SOTA baselines in widely-used Mujoco environments.
4/23/2024
HarmoDT: Harmony Multi-Task Decision Transformer for Offline Reinforcement Learning
Shengchao Hu, Ziqing Fan, Li Shen, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Dacheng Tao
0
0
The purpose of offline multi-task reinforcement learning (MTRL) is to develop a unified policy applicable to diverse tasks without the need for online environmental interaction. Recent advancements approach this through sequence modeling, leveraging the Transformer architecture's scalability and the benefits of parameter sharing to exploit task similarities. However, variations in task content and complexity pose significant challenges in policy formulation, necessitating judicious parameter sharing and management of conflicting gradients for optimal policy performance. In this work, we introduce the Harmony Multi-Task Decision Transformer (HarmoDT), a novel solution designed to identify an optimal harmony subspace of parameters for each task. We approach this as a bi-level optimization problem, employing a meta-learning framework that leverages gradient-based techniques. The upper level of this framework is dedicated to learning a task-specific mask that delineates the harmony subspace, while the inner level focuses on updating parameters to enhance the overall performance of the unified policy. Empirical evaluations on a series of benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of HarmoDT, verifying the effectiveness of our approach.
5/29/2024
Single-Task Continual Offline Reinforcement Learning
Sibo Gai, Donglin Wang
0
0
In this paper, we study the continual learning problem of single-task offline reinforcement learning. In the past, continual reinforcement learning usually only dealt with multitasking, that is, learning multiple related or unrelated tasks in a row, but once each learned task was learned, it was not relearned, but only used in subsequent processes. However, offline reinforcement learning tasks require the continuously learning of multiple different datasets for the same task. Existing algorithms will try their best to achieve the best results in each offline dataset they have learned and the skills of the network will overwrite the high-quality datasets that have been learned after learning the subsequent poor datasets. On the other hand, if too much emphasis is placed on stability, the network will learn the subsequent better dataset after learning the poor offline dataset, and the problem of insufficient plasticity and non-learning will occur. How to design a strategy that can always preserve the best performance for each state in the data that has been learned is a new challenge and the focus of this study. Therefore, this study proposes a new algorithm, called Ensemble Offline Reinforcement Learning Based on Experience Replay, which introduces multiple value networks to learn the same dataset and judge whether the strategy has been learned by the discrete degree of the value network, to improve the performance of the network in single-task offline reinforcement learning.
5/6/2024
In-Context Decision Transformer: Reinforcement Learning via Hierarchical Chain-of-Thought
Sili Huang, Jifeng Hu, Hechang Chen, Lichao Sun, Bo Yang
0
0
In-context learning is a promising approach for offline reinforcement learning (RL) to handle online tasks, which can be achieved by providing task prompts. Recent works demonstrated that in-context RL could emerge with self-improvement in a trial-and-error manner when treating RL tasks as an across-episodic sequential prediction problem. Despite the self-improvement not requiring gradient updates, current works still suffer from high computational costs when the across-episodic sequence increases with task horizons. To this end, we propose an In-context Decision Transformer (IDT) to achieve self-improvement in a high-level trial-and-error manner. Specifically, IDT is inspired by the efficient hierarchical structure of human decision-making and thus reconstructs the sequence to consist of high-level decisions instead of low-level actions that interact with environments. As one high-level decision can guide multi-step low-level actions, IDT naturally avoids excessively long sequences and solves online tasks more efficiently. Experimental results show that IDT achieves state-of-the-art in long-horizon tasks over current in-context RL methods. In particular, the online evaluation time of our IDT is textbf{36$times$} times faster than baselines in the D4RL benchmark and textbf{27$times$} times faster in the Grid World benchmark.
6/3/2024