A Symplectic Analysis of Alternating Mirror Descent

Read original: arXiv:2405.03472 - Published 5/30/2024 by Jonas Katona, Xiuyuan Wang, Andre Wibisono

⛏️

Overview

The paper explores the behavior of the Alternating Mirror Descent (AMD) algorithm for bilinear zero-sum games by studying the discretization of continuous-time Hamiltonian flow using the symplectic Euler method.
The researchers provide a framework for analysis using results from Hamiltonian dynamics, Lie algebra, and symplectic numerical integrators.
They focus on the existence and properties of a conserved quantity, the modified Hamiltonian (MH), for the symplectic Euler method.
The paper derives new error bounds on the MH and uses these to show improved regret and duality gap bounds for the AMD algorithm.
The researchers propose a conjecture that could further improve the bounds for AMD under certain conditions.

Plain English Explanation

The paper investigates the behavior of an algorithm called Alternating Mirror Descent (AMD) that is used for a specific type of game called a bilinear zero-sum game. To better understand how AMD works, the researchers look at a related mathematical concept called Hamiltonian flow, which describes the dynamics of certain physical systems.

Specifically, the researchers study how to discretize, or break down, the continuous-time Hamiltonian flow into smaller, discrete steps using a technique called the symplectic Euler method. They find that this process introduces a new quantity, called the modified Hamiltonian (MH), which is conserved, or maintained, over time.

The researchers are able to compute the MH in a closed-form expression when the original Hamiltonian (the function describing the system's energy) is a quadratic function. They show that this MH is generally different from another conserved quantity that was previously known in this case.

By deriving new bounds, or limits, on how much the MH can change, the researchers are able to prove that the AMD algorithm has improved performance in terms of total regret and duality gap compared to previous results.

Finally, the researchers propose a conjecture, or educated guess, that if true, could lead to even stronger performance guarantees for AMD under certain conditions.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on understanding the behavior of the Alternating Mirror Descent (AMD) algorithm for bilinear zero-sum games by studying the discretization of continuous-time Hamiltonian flow using the symplectic Euler method.

The researchers establish a framework for analysis using results from Hamiltonian dynamics, Lie algebra, and symplectic numerical integrators. A key aspect of their work is the investigation of the existence and properties of a conserved quantity, the modified Hamiltonian (MH), for the symplectic Euler method.

When the original Hamiltonian is a quadratic function, the researchers are able to compute the MH in closed-form. They show that the MH generally differs from another conserved quantity known previously in this case.

By deriving new error bounds on the truncation of the MH in terms of the number of iterations, K, the researchers are able to utilize these bounds to prove an improved O(K^{1/5}) total regret bound and an O(K^{-4/5}) duality gap of the average iterates for the AMD algorithm. These bounds represent an improvement over previous results.

Finally, the researchers propose a conjecture which, if true, would imply that the total regret for AMD goes as O(K^ε) and the duality gap of the average iterates as O(K^{-1+ε}) for any ε>0. They suggest that the conjecture can be proven true under certain conditions related to the convergence of the MH.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough theoretical analysis of the Alternating Mirror Descent (AMD) algorithm for bilinear zero-sum games by leveraging tools from Hamiltonian dynamics, Lie algebra, and symplectic numerical integrators. The researchers' focus on the modified Hamiltonian (MH) and its properties is a key contribution that allows them to derive improved regret and duality gap bounds for AMD.

However, the paper does not address the practical implementation or empirical performance of the AMD algorithm. While the theoretical analysis is rigorous, it would be valuable to see how the algorithm performs on real-world problems or benchmark datasets, especially in comparison to other state-of-the-art algorithms for bilinear zero-sum games.

Additionally, the proposed conjecture, if proven true, could lead to even stronger performance guarantees for AMD. The researchers suggest certain convergence conditions for the MH that could enable this, but further investigation would be needed to fully validate the conjecture and its implications.

Finally, the paper focuses solely on the AMD algorithm and does not provide a broader context or discussion of other related algorithms or approaches in the field of online learning and game theory. Contextualizing the AMD algorithm within the broader landscape of research in these areas could help readers better understand its significance and potential applications.

Conclusion

The provided paper presents a detailed analysis of the Alternating Mirror Descent (AMD) algorithm for bilinear zero-sum games, focusing on the discretization of continuous-time Hamiltonian flow using the symplectic Euler method. The researchers' key contributions include:

Establishing a framework for analysis using Hamiltonian dynamics, Lie algebra, and symplectic numerical integrators.
Investigating the existence and properties of a conserved quantity, the modified Hamiltonian (MH), for the symplectic Euler method.
Deriving new error bounds on the MH and utilizing these to prove improved regret and duality gap bounds for the AMD algorithm.
Proposing a conjecture that, if true, could lead to even stronger performance guarantees for AMD under certain conditions.

While the theoretical analysis is rigorous, the paper does not address the practical implementation or empirical performance of the AMD algorithm. Additionally, contextualizing the algorithm within the broader landscape of research in online learning and game theory could help readers better understand its significance and potential applications. Overall, the paper provides valuable insights into the behavior of the AMD algorithm and lays the groundwork for further research in this area.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

⛏️

A Symplectic Analysis of Alternating Mirror Descent

Jonas Katona, Xiuyuan Wang, Andre Wibisono

Motivated by understanding the behavior of the Alternating Mirror Descent (AMD) algorithm for bilinear zero-sum games, we study the discretization of continuous-time Hamiltonian flow via the symplectic Euler method. We provide a framework for analysis using results from Hamiltonian dynamics, Lie algebra, and symplectic numerical integrators, with an emphasis on the existence and properties of a conserved quantity, the modified Hamiltonian (MH), for the symplectic Euler method. We compute the MH in closed-form when the original Hamiltonian is a quadratic function, and show that it generally differs from the other conserved quantity known previously in that case. We derive new error bounds on the MH when truncated at orders in the stepsize in terms of the number of iterations, $K$, and use these bounds to show an improved $mathcal{O}(K^{1/5})$ total regret bound and an $mathcal{O}(K^{-4/5})$ duality gap of the average iterates for AMD. Finally, we propose a conjecture which, if true, would imply that the total regret for AMD scales as $mathcal{O}left(K^{varepsilon}right)$ and the duality gap of the average iterates as $mathcal{O}left(K^{-1+varepsilon}right)$ for any $varepsilon>0$, and we can take $varepsilon=0$ upon certain convergence conditions for the MH.

5/30/2024

🔍

On Convergence of the Alternating Directions SGHMC Algorithm

Soumyadip Ghosh, Yingdong Lu, Tomasz Nowicki

We study convergence rates of Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (HMC) algorithms with leapfrog integration under mild conditions on stochastic gradient oracle for the target distribution (SGHMC). Our method extends standard HMC by allowing the use of general auxiliary distributions, which is achieved by a novel procedure of Alternating Directions. The convergence analysis is based on the investigations of the Dirichlet forms associated with the underlying Markov chain driving the algorithms. For this purpose, we provide a detailed analysis on the error of the leapfrog integrator for Hamiltonian motions with both the kinetic and potential energy functions in general form. We characterize the explicit dependence of the convergence rates on key parameters such as the problem dimension, functional properties of both the target and auxiliary distributions, and the quality of the oracle.

5/28/2024

🤯

Sample-efficient Learning of Infinite-horizon Average-reward MDPs with General Function Approximation

Jianliang He, Han Zhong, Zhuoran Yang

We study infinite-horizon average-reward Markov decision processes (AMDPs) in the context of general function approximation. Specifically, we propose a novel algorithmic framework named Local-fitted Optimization with OPtimism (LOOP), which incorporates both model-based and value-based incarnations. In particular, LOOP features a novel construction of confidence sets and a low-switching policy updating scheme, which are tailored to the average-reward and function approximation setting. Moreover, for AMDPs, we propose a novel complexity measure -- average-reward generalized eluder coefficient (AGEC) -- which captures the challenge of exploration in AMDPs with general function approximation. Such a complexity measure encompasses almost all previously known tractable AMDP models, such as linear AMDPs and linear mixture AMDPs, and also includes newly identified cases such as kernel AMDPs and AMDPs with Bellman eluder dimensions. Using AGEC, we prove that LOOP achieves a sublinear $tilde{mathcal{O}}(mathrm{poly}(d, mathrm{sp}(V^*)) sqrt{Tbeta} )$ regret, where $d$ and $beta$ correspond to AGEC and log-covering number of the hypothesis class respectively, $mathrm{sp}(V^*)$ is the span of the optimal state bias function, $T$ denotes the number of steps, and $tilde{mathcal{O}} (cdot) $ omits logarithmic factors. When specialized to concrete AMDP models, our regret bounds are comparable to those established by the existing algorithms designed specifically for these special cases. To the best of our knowledge, this paper presents the first comprehensive theoretical framework capable of handling nearly all AMDPs.

4/22/2024

🔮

Adaptively Perturbed Mirror Descent for Learning in Games

Kenshi Abe, Kaito Ariu, Mitsuki Sakamoto, Atsushi Iwasaki

This paper proposes a payoff perturbation technique for the Mirror Descent (MD) algorithm in games where the gradient of the payoff functions is monotone in the strategy profile space, potentially containing additive noise. The optimistic family of learning algorithms, exemplified by optimistic MD, successfully achieves {it last-iterate} convergence in scenarios devoid of noise, leading the dynamics to a Nash equilibrium. A recent re-emerging trend underscores the promise of the perturbation approach, where payoff functions are perturbed based on the distance from an anchoring, or {it slingshot}, strategy. In response, we propose {it Adaptively Perturbed MD} (APMD), which adjusts the magnitude of the perturbation by repeatedly updating the slingshot strategy at a predefined interval. This innovation empowers us to find a Nash equilibrium of the underlying game with guaranteed rates. Empirical demonstrations affirm that our algorithm exhibits significantly accelerated convergence.

6/26/2024