Tangent Transformers for Composition, Privacy and Removal

Overview

• The authors introduce Tangent Attention Fine-Tuning (TAFT), a method for fine-tuning linearized transformers
• TAFT computes a First-order Taylor Expansion around a pre-trained initialization to obtain a linearized transformer
• The resulting Jacobian-Vector Product can be computed efficiently in a single forward pass, reducing training and inference cost
• TAFT allows the resulting Tangent Transformer to perform comparably to fine-tuning the original non-linear network
• Tangent Transformers are linear with respect to the new set of weights, and the resulting fine-tuning loss is convex, providing advantages for model composition, parallel training, machine unlearning, and differential privacy

Plain English Explanation

The paper introduces a new method called Tangent Attention Fine-Tuning (TAFT) that can be used to fine-tune pre-trained transformer models. Transformers are a popular type of neural network architecture that have been very successful for a variety of tasks like language modeling and image classification.

The key idea behind TAFT is to linearize the transformer model by computing a first-order Taylor expansion around the pre-trained model's parameters. This results in a "Tangent Transformer" that is a linear function of the new set of weights. The authors show that the Jacobian-Vector Product, which is the key computation needed for fine-tuning the model, can be calculated efficiently in a single forward pass.

This has a few benefits. First, the training and inference time for the fine-tuned model is on par with the original non-linear transformer, despite the model being linear. Second, the fine-tuning loss is convex, which provides advantages for things like model composition, parallel training, machine unlearning, and differential privacy.

Overall, TAFT provides an efficient way to fine-tune transformer models that retains the performance of the original non-linear model while offering some additional benefits in terms of the optimization landscape.

Technical Explanation

The core technical contribution of this paper is the Tangent Attention Fine-Tuning (TAFT) method for fine-tuning linearized transformers. The authors start by computing a first-order Taylor expansion around the pre-trained initialization of a transformer model, resulting in a "Tangent Transformer" that is a linear function of the new set of weights.

They show that the key Jacobian-Vector Product computation needed for fine-tuning can be calculated efficiently in a single forward pass, reducing the training and inference cost of the fine-tuned model to the same order of magnitude as the original non-linear transformer, while using the same number of parameters.

When applying TAFT to various downstream visual classification tasks, the authors demonstrate that the resulting Tangent Transformer can perform comparably to fine-tuning the original non-linear transformer network. Crucially, since the Tangent Transformer is linear with respect to the new set of weights, and the fine-tuning loss is convex, the authors show that TAFT enjoys several advantages compared to non-linear fine-tuning. These include benefits for model composition, parallel training, machine unlearning, and differential privacy.

Critical Analysis

The authors present a thorough and well-designed study, with extensive experiments across multiple datasets and tasks. The core technical insight of leveraging a linearized transformer model for efficient fine-tuning is novel and compelling.

One potential limitation is that the experiments are focused on visual classification tasks, so it's unclear how well the TAFT approach would generalize to other domains like natural language processing. The authors acknowledge this and suggest exploring additional application areas as future work.

Another potential concern is the reliance on the first-order Taylor expansion approximation. While the authors show that this approximation works well in practice, it would be valuable to understand the failure modes or limitations of this approach, especially as the fine-tuning diverges from the pre-trained initialization.

Finally, the advantages of TAFT for model composition, parallel training, machine unlearning, and differential privacy are interesting, but the authors could provide more detailed analysis and examples to fully substantiate these claims.

Overall, the TAFT method represents an innovative approach to fine-tuning transformer models, with a strong theoretical foundation and promising empirical results. Further exploration of its generalization and potential limitations would be valuable contributions to the field.

Conclusion

The Tangent Attention Fine-Tuning (TAFT) method introduced in this paper provides an efficient way to fine-tune pre-trained transformer models. By linearizing the transformer architecture through a first-order Taylor expansion, the authors show that the fine-tuning process can be accelerated without sacrificing performance compared to fine-tuning the original non-linear model.

The key benefits of TAFT include reduced training and inference costs, a convex fine-tuning loss function, and advantages for model composition, parallel training, machine unlearning, and differential privacy. These properties make TAFT a compelling approach for fine-tuning transformers, especially in resource-constrained or privacy-sensitive applications.

Overall, this work represents an important contribution to the ongoing research on improving the efficiency and flexibility of transformer-based models. As the use of transformers continues to expand across a wide range of domains, techniques like TAFT will become increasingly valuable for enabling rapid adaptation and deployment of these powerful models.