To the Max: Reinventing Reward in Reinforcement Learning

Overview

• The paper "To the Max: Reinventing Reward in Reinforcement Learning" explores ways to improve reinforcement learning agents by rethinking the reward function.
• The authors propose a new reward formulation called "MaxReward" that aims to provide better exploration and convergence properties compared to traditional reward functions.
• The paper includes a theoretical analysis of MaxReward and experiments on a set of benchmark reinforcement learning tasks to evaluate its performance.

Plain English Explanation

In reinforcement learning, agents learn to make decisions by receiving rewards or punishments for their actions. The standard approach is to define a single reward function that the agent tries to maximize. However, this can lead to issues with exploration and convergence to suboptimal policies.

The authors of this paper propose a new way to define the reward function, called "MaxReward." Instead of a single reward, the agent receives a set of potential rewards, and its goal is to maximize the

of these rewards. This encourages the agent to explore a wider range of actions to ensure it can achieve a good minimum reward, rather than focusing solely on maximizing a single reward.

The authors provide a theoretical analysis of the MaxReward formulation, showing that it can lead to better exploration and convergence properties compared to traditional reward functions. They also evaluate MaxReward on a variety of reinforcement learning tasks and find that it outperforms standard reward functions in many cases.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by motivating the need for new reward formulations in reinforcement learning. The authors argue that traditional reward functions can lead to issues with exploration and convergence, as the agent may get stuck pursuing a single reward signal that does not lead to the best long-term outcome.

To address this, the authors propose the "MaxReward" formulation. Instead of a single reward, the agent receives a set of potential rewards, and its goal is to maximize the

of these rewards. Formally, the MaxReward for a given state-action pair (s, a) is defined as:

MaxReward(s, a) = max_r min_i r_i(s, a)

Where r_i(s, a) are the individual reward components.

The authors provide a theoretical analysis of the MaxReward formulation, showing that it can lead to better exploration and convergence properties compared to traditional reward functions. They also evaluate MaxReward on a variety of reinforcement learning tasks, including classic control problems and Atari games, and find that it outperforms standard reward functions in many cases.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and interesting approach to defining reward functions in reinforcement learning. The authors make a compelling case for the limitations of traditional reward functions and provide a well-designed alternative in the form of MaxReward.

One potential limitation of the approach is that it may be more computationally expensive, as the agent needs to consider a set of potential rewards rather than a single value. Additionally, the authors do not provide a systematic way to determine the individual reward components r_i, which could be challenging in practice.

Further research could explore ways to make the MaxReward formulation more efficient, as well as investigate how to automatically generate the individual reward components. It would also be interesting to see how MaxReward performs on a wider range of reinforcement learning tasks and in more complex environments.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel reward formulation called "MaxReward" that aims to improve exploration and convergence in reinforcement learning. By shifting the focus from maximizing a single reward to maximizing the minimum of a set of potential rewards, the authors demonstrate how this approach can lead to better performance on a variety of benchmark tasks.

The paper provides a solid theoretical foundation and experimental evaluation of the MaxReward approach, making it a valuable contribution to the field of reinforcement learning. While there are still some open questions and areas for further research, this work represents an important step towards reinventing reward functions and advancing the capabilities of reinforcement learning agents.