Towards Optimal Adversarial Robust Q-learning with Bellman Infinity-error

Overview

• The paper explores establishing robust policies to counter attacks or disturbances affecting deep reinforcement learning (DRL) agents.
• It introduces a consistency assumption of policy (CAP) stating that optimal actions remain consistent with minor perturbations, supported by empirical and theoretical evidence.
• The paper proves the existence of a deterministic and stationary optimal robust policy (ORP) that aligns with the Bellman optimal policy.
• It highlights the necessity of the L^{infty}-norm when minimizing Bellman error to attain ORP, in contrast to prior DRL algorithms that target the Bellman optimal policy with L^{1}-norm.
• The paper introduces a Consistent Adversarial Robust Deep Q-Network (CAR-DQN) that minimizes a surrogate of Bellman Infinity-error, and validates its practical effectiveness across various benchmarks.

Plain English Explanation

Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) agents can be vulnerable to attacks or disturbances that can disrupt their performance. To address this, the paper explores establishing robust policies that can withstand these challenges.

The key idea is a "consistency assumption of policy" (CAP), which suggests that the optimal actions an agent should take remain consistent even with small changes to the environment. This is supported by both empirical evidence and theoretical analysis.

Building on CAP, the researchers prove that there exists an "optimal robust policy" (ORP) that is deterministic, stationary, and aligns with the mathematically optimal Bellman policy. Importantly, they show that to find this ORP, it is necessary to use the L^{infty}-norm when minimizing the Bellman error, rather than the L^{1}-norm used by previous DRL algorithms.

Motivated by this, the paper introduces a new algorithm called "Consistent Adversarial Robust Deep Q-Network" (CAR-DQN) that minimizes a proxy for the Bellman Infinity-error. The researchers demonstrate that CAR-DQN achieves top-tier performance across various benchmarks, validating the practical effectiveness of their approach and the soundness of the underlying theoretical analysis.

Technical Explanation

The paper investigates the challenge of establishing robust policies for deep reinforcement learning (DRL) agents to counter potential attacks or disturbances. Recent studies have explored state-adversarial robustness and suggested the potential lack of an optimal robust policy (ORP), posing challenges in setting strict robustness constraints.

The researchers first introduce a consistency assumption of policy (CAP), which states that optimal actions in the Markov decision process remain consistent with minor perturbations. This assumption is supported by both empirical and theoretical evidence.

Building upon CAP, the paper crucially proves the existence of a deterministic and stationary ORP that aligns with the Bellman optimal policy. Furthermore, the researchers illustrate the necessity of the L^{infty}-norm when minimizing Bellman error to attain ORP, in contrast to prior DRL algorithms that targeted the Bellman optimal policy using the L^{1}-norm.

Motivated by these findings, the paper introduces a Consistent Adversarial Robust Deep Q-Network (CAR-DQN) that minimizes a surrogate of Bellman Infinity-error. The researchers demonstrate the top-tier performance of CAR-DQN across various benchmarks, validating its practical effectiveness and reinforcing the soundness of their theoretical analysis.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a rigorous theoretical and empirical investigation into establishing robust policies for DRL agents. The introduction of the CAP assumption and the proof of the existence of a deterministic and stationary ORP are significant contributions, as they address a key challenge in setting strict robustness constraints for DRL systems.

One potential limitation of the research is the reliance on the L^{infty}-norm for minimizing Bellman error, which may not be the most efficient or practical approach in all scenarios. It would be interesting to explore alternative norms or regularization techniques that could achieve a similar level of robustness while potentially improving computational efficiency or sample complexity.

Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential tradeoffs between robustness and other desirable properties of DRL agents, such as sample efficiency or exploration-exploitation balance. Investigating these tradeoffs could provide valuable insights for practitioners and researchers alike.

Furthermore, the paper's analysis is primarily focused on the theoretical and empirical validation of the proposed CAR-DQN algorithm. It would be beneficial to see a more comprehensive comparison of CAR-DQN against other state-of-the-art robust DRL algorithms, as well as a deeper exploration of the practical implications and potential use cases of the research findings.

Conclusion

This paper makes important contributions to the field of robust deep reinforcement learning by introducing the consistency assumption of policy (CAP) and proving the existence of an optimal robust policy (ORP) that aligns with the Bellman optimal policy. The necessity of the L^{infty}-norm for minimizing Bellman error to attain ORP is a key insight that challenges the approaches used in prior DRL algorithms.

The proposed Consistent Adversarial Robust Deep Q-Network (CAR-DQN) algorithm, which minimizes a surrogate of Bellman Infinity-error, demonstrates strong performance across various benchmarks, validating the practical effectiveness of the researchers' theoretical analysis. This work lays the foundation for developing more robust and reliable DRL agents that can withstand attacks or disturbances, with potentially significant implications for safety-critical applications and real-world deployments.