Utilizing Large Language Models to Generate Synthetic Data to Increase the Performance of BERT-Based Neural Networks

Overview

• Lack of available healthcare experts is a significant issue
• Machine learning (ML) models could help by aiding in patient diagnosis
• Creating large datasets to train these models is expensive
• This paper evaluates using large language models (LLMs) to generate synthetic data to augment existing medical data

Plain English Explanation

There is a shortage of healthcare experts, such as doctors and nurses, available to diagnose and treat patients. Machine learning models could help by using computer algorithms to assist in identifying patient conditions. However, training these machine learning models requires large datasets, which can be costly to create.

To address this, the researchers in this paper explored using large language models like ChatGPT and GPT-Premium to generate synthetic, or artificial, data about Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD). The goal was to create a larger dataset that could be used to train machine learning models to better recognize the signs and symptoms of autism.

The researchers then used a BERT classifier, a type of machine learning model, to evaluate the quality of the synthetic data generated by the LLMs. They found that a random sample of the data contained about 83% correct example-label pairs, meaning the LLMs were able to generate realistic examples of autism-related behaviors and correctly label them.

Using the synthetic data to augment the existing dataset increased the machine learning model's ability to correctly identify cases of autism (recall) by 13%, but reduced its overall accuracy (precision) by 16%. This suggests the synthetic data helped the model recognize more cases of autism, but also introduced some inaccuracies.

The researchers plan to further analyze how different characteristics of the synthetic data affect the performance of the machine learning models, with the goal of enhancing diagnostic accuracy and understanding how large language models process medical information.

Technical Explanation

The researchers in this paper evaluated the use of large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-Premium to generate synthetic data for training machine learning (ML) models to diagnose Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD).

They prompted the LLMs to generate 4,200 synthetic observations about ASD, which were then used to augment an existing dataset. A BERT classifier pre-trained on biomedical literature was used to assess the quality of the LLM-generated data by evaluating a random sample of 140 examples.

The clinician-assessed sample was found to contain 83% correct example-label pairs, indicating the LLMs were able to produce realistic examples of ASD-related behaviors and correctly associate them with the appropriate diagnostic criteria.

Incorporating the synthetic data into the training set increased the recall of the BERT classifier by 13%, meaning it could identify more actual cases of ASD. However, this came at the cost of a 16% decrease in precision, suggesting the synthetic data also introduced some inaccuracies.

The researchers plan to further analyze how different characteristics of the synthetic data, such as specific traits or behaviors, affect the performance of the ML models. The goal is to understand how to best leverage LLMs to enhance diagnostic accuracy and improve the processing of medical information by large language models.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that while the synthetic data generated by the LLMs showed promise in augmenting the existing dataset, the decrease in precision indicates there is still room for improvement. The tradeoff between increased recall and decreased precision suggests the synthetic data may introduce some biases or inaccuracies that need to be addressed.

One potential limitation of the study is the relatively small sample size used to evaluate the quality of the synthetic data. While the 83% correct example-label rate is encouraging, a larger sample size would provide more confidence in the overall quality of the generated data.

Additionally, the researchers only focused on ASD as a use case. Evaluating the LLMs' performance on generating synthetic data for other medical conditions or diagnoses would help understand the broader applicability of this approach.

Future research could also explore ways to fine-tune the LLMs or adjust the prompting process to improve the accuracy and consistency of the generated synthetic data. Analyzing the narrative processing capabilities of LLMs may also provide insights into how to better leverage these models for medical data generation.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates the potential of using large language models (LLMs) to generate synthetic data for training machine learning (ML) models in healthcare. By prompting LLMs like ChatGPT and GPT-Premium to create observations about Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD), the researchers were able to augment an existing dataset and improve the recall of a BERT classifier.

While the synthetic data showed promise, with 83% of a sample containing correct example-label pairs, the decrease in precision suggests there is still room for improvement. Future research should explore ways to further enhance the quality and consistency of the generated data, as well as investigate the broader applicability of this approach across different medical domains.

Overall, the findings of this paper highlight the potential of LLMs to aid in digital diagnostics and enhance diagnostic accuracy through the generation of targeted, synthetic data. As the healthcare industry continues to grapple with a lack of available experts, solutions like this could play an important role in improving patient outcomes.