Zero Grads: Learning Local Surrogate Losses for Non-Differentiable Graphics

Overview

• Gradient-based optimization is widely used in graphics, but it cannot be applied to problems with undefined or zero gradients.
• The paper proposes a framework called ZeroGrads that automates the process of learning a neural approximation (surrogate) of the objective function, allowing differentiation through arbitrary black-box graphics pipelines.
• The surrogate is trained on an actively smoothed version of the objective, focusing its capacity on what matters at the current training episode.
• The fitting is performed online, alongside the parameter optimization, and is self-supervised, without pre-computed data or pre-trained models.
• The approach scales well to higher dimensions, demonstrated on problems with up to 35,000 interlinked variables.

Plain English Explanation

Gradient-based optimization is a powerful technique used in many graphics applications, but it has a limitation: it cannot be used when the objective function has undefined or zero gradients. To work around this issue, the researchers developed a framework called ZeroGrads that automatically learns a neural network to approximate the objective function. This neural network, or "surrogate," can then be used to calculate gradients, even for complex, black-box graphics pipelines.

The key idea is to train the surrogate on a smoothed version of the original objective function, focusing its capacity on the most relevant parts of the function for the current optimization task. This training happens online, alongside the main parameter optimization, without requiring any pre-computed data or pre-trained models. Since evaluating the original objective function can be computationally expensive (e.g., running a full simulation or rendering), the researchers also devised an efficient sampling scheme to make the optimization process tractable.

The ZeroGrads framework allows researchers and developers to optimize diverse, non-convex, and non-differentiable problems in graphics, such as visibility in rendering, discrete parameter spaces in procedural modeling, or optimal control in physics-driven animation. Compared to other derivative-free optimization algorithms, this approach scales well to higher-dimensional problems, handling up to 35,000 interlinked variables.

Technical Explanation

The ZeroGrads paper proposes a framework for optimizing non-convex, non-differentiable black-box problems in graphics by learning a neural surrogate of the objective function. This allows the use of gradient-based optimization techniques, even when the original objective has undefined or zero gradients.

The surrogate is trained on an actively smoothed version of the objective, encouraging locality and focusing the surrogate's capacity on what matters at the current training episode. The fitting is performed online, alongside the parameter optimization, and is self-supervised, without pre-computed data or pre-trained models. This approach is similar to the adaptive gradient-enhanced Gaussian process surrogates and universal online learning of gradient variations in multi-layer models.

To make the optimization process tractable, the researchers devise an efficient sampling scheme that allows for competitive performance at little overhead. This is important because evaluating the original objective function can be computationally expensive, requiring a full rendering or simulator run.

The ZeroGrads framework is demonstrated on diverse non-convex, non-differentiable black-box problems in graphics, such as visibility in rendering, discrete parameter spaces in procedural modeling, or optimal control in physics-driven animation. In contrast to other derivative-free algorithms, the approach scales well to higher dimensions, handling up to 35,000 interlinked variables.

Critical Analysis

The ZeroGrads paper presents a novel and promising approach to optimizing complex, non-differentiable problems in graphics. The use of a learned surrogate function to enable gradient-based optimization is a clever solution to a longstanding challenge in the field.

One potential limitation of the approach is the reliance on the surrogate's accuracy during the optimization process. If the surrogate fails to capture the true objective function well, the optimization may converge to a suboptimal solution. The paper acknowledges this and suggests further research into techniques like mean curvature flow arising in adversarial training to improve the surrogate's robustness.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the theoretical underpinnings of surrogate gradient learning in spiking neural networks, which could provide valuable insights into the stability and convergence properties of the ZeroGrads framework.

Overall, the ZeroGrads approach represents a significant advancement in gradient-based optimization for graphics and opens up new possibilities for tackling complex, non-differentiable problems. Continued research to address the identified limitations and further expand the capabilities of the framework will be valuable contributions to the field.

Conclusion

The ZeroGrads paper presents a novel framework for optimizing non-convex, non-differentiable black-box problems in graphics by learning a neural surrogate of the objective function. This allows the use of gradient-based optimization techniques, even when the original objective has undefined or zero gradients.

The key innovation is the online, self-supervised training of the surrogate, which focuses its capacity on the most relevant parts of the objective function for the current optimization task. The efficient sampling scheme and scalability to high-dimensional problems make the ZeroGrads framework a powerful tool for tackling diverse challenges in graphics, from rendering visibility to procedural modeling and physics-driven animation.

As the field continues to push the boundaries of graphics optimization, the ZeroGrads approach provides a valuable contribution, opening up new possibilities for researchers and developers to solve complex, non-differentiable problems. Further advancements in the theoretical foundations and robustness of the surrogate model will likely lead to even more impressive applications of this technology.