ACPO: A Policy Optimization Algorithm for Average MDPs with Constraints

Overview

• This paper introduces a new policy optimization algorithm for reinforcement learning (RL) in constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) with the average reward criterion.
• The proposed Average-Constrained Policy Optimization (ACPO) algorithm is inspired by trust region-based policy optimization techniques.
• The algorithm leverages sensitivity analysis for average CMDPs to provide theoretical performance guarantees.
• Extensive experiments in challenging OpenAI Gym environments show ACPO outperforms other state-of-the-art algorithms adapted for average CMDPs.

Plain English Explanation

Reinforcement learning is a powerful technique for training agents to perform complex tasks by providing rewards and penalties. However, in many real-world applications, there are constraints that the agent must adhere to, such as safety or resource constraints. These constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) are an important problem in RL.

Often, the average reward over time is more suitable than the discounted reward, which gives more weight to immediate rewards. But learning RL agents for average-reward CMDPs (ACMDPs) remains a significant challenge. Existing algorithms designed for discounted constrained RL problems don't work well for the average CMDP setting.

This paper introduces a new algorithm called Average-Constrained Policy Optimization (ACPO). ACPO is inspired by "trust region" policy optimization methods, which keep the agent's policy from changing too rapidly. The authors develop sensitivity analysis for average CMDPs and use the resulting bounds to design the ACPO algorithm.

Through extensive testing in difficult OpenAI Gym environments, the authors show that ACPO outperforms other state-of-the-art algorithms adapted for average CMDPs. This is an important step forward in making RL more applicable to real-world scenarios with constraints.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contribution of this paper is the Average-Constrained Policy Optimization (ACPO) algorithm for reinforcement learning in constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) with the average reward criterion.

The authors first develop basic sensitivity theory for average CMDPs, providing bounds on how changes to the policy affect the average reward and constraint values. They then use these bounds in the design of the ACPO algorithm, which is inspired by trust region-based policy optimization techniques like Constrained Policy Optimization (CPO) and Natural Policy Gradient (NPG).

ACPO aims to find a policy that maximizes the average reward while satisfying the constraints. The algorithm alternates between policy evaluation to estimate the value function and policy improvement to update the policy parameters. Crucially, the policy improvement step uses the sensitivity analysis bounds to ensure the new policy is guaranteed to satisfy the constraints and achieve sufficient improvement in the objective.

The authors provide theoretical guarantees on the performance of ACPO, showing it converges to a stationary point of the constrained optimization problem. They also conduct extensive experiments on various challenging OpenAI Gym environments, demonstrating ACPO's superior empirical performance compared to other state-of-the-art algorithms adapted for average CMDPs.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a valuable contribution by introducing a new algorithm, ACPO, for reinforcement learning in constrained Markov decision processes with the average reward criterion. This is an important problem that is not well addressed by existing methods.

The authors provide a solid theoretical foundation for ACPO, leveraging sensitivity analysis to derive performance bounds that ensure constraint satisfaction and policy improvement. The experimental results are also impressive, showing ACPO outperforming other adapted algorithms in challenging environments.

However, the paper does not address some potential limitations or areas for further research. For example, the sensitivity analysis and resulting bounds may be difficult to compute in practice, especially for high-dimensional or complex environments. It would be interesting to see how ACPO scales to larger problems and whether there are ways to simplify the theoretical guarantees.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the average reward criterion, but there may be cases where the discounted reward is more appropriate. It would be helpful to understand the trade-offs between the two criteria and the conditions under which each is more suitable.

Overall, this paper presents an important step forward in reinforcement learning for constrained MDPs, and the ACPO algorithm shows promise for real-world applications with safety or resource constraints. Further research to address the potential limitations and expand the algorithm's applicability would be a valuable contribution to the field.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a new reinforcement learning algorithm, Average-Constrained Policy Optimization (ACPO), for constrained Markov decision processes with the average reward criterion. ACPO leverages sensitivity analysis to provide theoretical guarantees on constraint satisfaction and policy improvement.

Through extensive experiments, the authors demonstrate ACPO's superior performance compared to other state-of-the-art algorithms adapted for average CMDPs. This work is an important advancement in making reinforcement learning more applicable to real-world scenarios with safety or resource constraints, which is a critical requirement for many practical applications.

While the paper provides a strong theoretical and empirical foundation, further research is needed to address potential limitations, such as computational complexity and the trade-offs between average and discounted reward criteria. Nonetheless, this paper represents a significant step forward in the field of constrained reinforcement learning and opens up new avenues for exploring RL in more realistic and challenging environments.