Natural Policy Gradient and Actor Critic Methods for Constrained Multi-Task Reinforcement Learning
2405.02456
0
0
🌿
Abstract
Multi-task reinforcement learning (RL) aims to find a single policy that effectively solves multiple tasks at the same time. This paper presents a constrained formulation for multi-task RL where the goal is to maximize the average performance of the policy across tasks subject to bounds on the performance in each task. We consider solving this problem both in the centralized setting, where information for all tasks is accessible to a single server, and in the decentralized setting, where a network of agents, each given one task and observing local information, cooperate to find the solution of the globally constrained objective using local communication. We first propose a primal-dual algorithm that provably converges to the globally optimal solution of this constrained formulation under exact gradient evaluations. When the gradient is unknown, we further develop a sampled-based actor-critic algorithm that finds the optimal policy using online samples of state, action, and reward. Finally, we study the extension of the algorithm to the linear function approximation setting.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a constrained formulation for multi-task reinforcement learning (RL)
- The goal is to maximize the average performance of the policy across tasks, while bounding the performance in each individual task
- The paper considers both centralized and decentralized settings for solving this constrained optimization problem
- A primal-dual algorithm is proposed that provably converges to the globally optimal solution under exact gradient information
- When gradients are unknown, a sample-based actor-critic algorithm is developed to find the optimal policy using online samples
- The paper also explores extending the algorithm to use linear function approximation
Plain English Explanation
In multi-task reinforcement learning, the aim is to find a single policy (decision-making strategy) that can effectively solve multiple tasks at the same time. This paper presents a new way to approach this problem by framing it as a constrained optimization task.
The researchers want to maximize the average performance of the policy across all the tasks, but they also want to make sure the policy doesn't perform too poorly on any individual task. So they put a limit or "constraint" on the minimum acceptable performance for each task.
To solve this problem, the paper looks at two different scenarios. In the first, all the information about the different tasks is available to a central server that can coordinate the solution. In the second, a network of agents, each responsible for one task, have to work together using local communication to find the globally optimal solution.
The researchers first develop a mathematical algorithm that is guaranteed to find the best policy under the constraints, as long as they have perfect information about the gradients (the direction of improvement) for each task. When that gradient information is not available, they create a sample-based "actor-critic" algorithm that can learn the optimal policy using only the experiences (samples) of interacting with the environment.
Finally, the paper explores extending this algorithm to work with more complex function approximation models, which can help when the tasks are very complicated and can't be fully described by simple mathematical formulas.
The key innovation here is balancing the overall performance across multiple tasks while ensuring no single task is neglected. This could be very useful in real-world applications where we want AI systems to be well-rounded and not excel at one thing at the expense of everything else.
Technical Explanation
This paper introduces a constrained formulation for multi-task reinforcement learning. The goal is to find a single policy that maximizes the average performance across a set of tasks, while ensuring the performance on each individual task remains above a specified threshold.
In the centralized setting, the researchers propose a primal-dual algorithm that provably converges to the globally optimal constrained solution, assuming exact gradient information is available. When gradients are unknown, they develop a sample-based actor-critic algorithm that can learn the optimal policy using online interaction data.
The paper also explores extending the algorithm to the linear function approximation setting, which is important for scaling to more complex tasks that cannot be fully described by simple mathematical formulas. This relates to constrained RL under model mismatch and actor-critic with phased actor updates.
Overall, this work presents a principled approach to multi-task RL that aims to balance overall performance while ensuring no individual task is neglected. This could have significant practical implications for building well-rounded AI systems that excel across a diverse range of capabilities.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to multi-task reinforcement learning, but there are a few caveats and areas for further research worth noting:
-
The theoretical guarantees rely on strong assumptions, like the availability of exact gradients or the ability to perfectly model the tasks using linear function approximation. In practice, these assumptions may not hold, so the performance of the algorithms may degrade.
-
The paper only considers stationary task environments. Extensions to non-stationary or adversarial settings could be an interesting direction for future work.
-
The experiments are limited to relatively simple benchmark tasks. It would be valuable to see how the algorithms scale to more complex, real-world multi-task problems.
-
The decentralized setting assumes all agents have equal access to communication resources. Exploring more heterogeneous or resource-constrained communication scenarios could yield additional insights.
Despite these limitations, this paper makes an important contribution by formulating multi-task RL as a constrained optimization problem. The proposed algorithms provide a principled approach to balancing performance across tasks, which is a key challenge in building versatile and robust AI systems. Further research building on these ideas could lead to significant advances in the field.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel constrained formulation for multi-task reinforcement learning and develops algorithms to solve it in both centralized and decentralized settings. The key innovation is the ability to maximize average performance across tasks while ensuring no individual task is neglected.
The theoretical and empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, which could have important implications for building well-rounded AI systems capable of excelling at diverse tasks. While the current work has some limitations, it opens up promising directions for future research in multi-task RL and constrained optimization in the context of reinforcement learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌿
Finite-Time Analysis of Three-Timescale Constrained Actor-Critic and Constrained Natural Actor-Critic Algorithms
Prashansa Panda, Shalabh Bhatnagar
0
0
Actor Critic methods have found immense applications on a wide range of Reinforcement Learning tasks especially when the state-action space is large. In this paper, we consider actor critic and natural actor critic algorithms with function approximation for constrained Markov decision processes (C-MDP) involving inequality constraints and carry out a non-asymptotic analysis for both of these algorithms in a non-i.i.d (Markovian) setting. We consider the long-run average cost criterion where both the objective and the constraint functions are suitable policy-dependent long-run averages of certain prescribed cost functions. We handle the inequality constraints using the Lagrange multiplier method. We prove that these algorithms are guaranteed to find a first-order stationary point (i.e., $Vert nabla L(theta,gamma)Vert_2^2 leq epsilon$) of the performance (Lagrange) function $L(theta,gamma)$, with a sample complexity of $mathcal{tilde{O}}(epsilon^{-2.5})$ in the case of both Constrained Actor Critic (C-AC) and Constrained Natural Actor Critic (C-NAC) algorithms. We also show the results of experiments on three different Safety-Gym environments.
5/30/2024
🏅
A Dual Perspective of Reinforcement Learning for Imposing Policy Constraints
Bram De Cooman, Johan Suykens
0
0
Model-free reinforcement learning methods lack an inherent mechanism to impose behavioural constraints on the trained policies. While certain extensions exist, they remain limited to specific types of constraints, such as value constraints with additional reward signals or visitation density constraints. In this work we try to unify these existing techniques and bridge the gap with classical optimization and control theory, using a generic primal-dual framework for value-based and actor-critic reinforcement learning methods. The obtained dual formulations turn out to be especially useful for imposing additional constraints on the learned policy, as an intrinsic relationship between such dual constraints (or regularization terms) and reward modifications in the primal is reveiled. Furthermore, using this framework, we are able to introduce some novel types of constraints, allowing to impose bounds on the policy's action density or on costs associated with transitions between consecutive states and actions. From the adjusted primal-dual optimization problems, a practical algorithm is derived that supports various combinations of policy constraints that are automatically handled throughout training using trainable reward modifications. The resulting $texttt{DualCRL}$ method is examined in more detail and evaluated under different (combinations of) constraints on two interpretable environments. The results highlight the efficacy of the method, which ultimately provides the designer of such systems with a versatile toolbox of possible policy constraints.
4/26/2024
🏅
Achieving Zero Constraint Violation for Constrained Reinforcement Learning via Conservative Natural Policy Gradient Primal-Dual Algorithm
Qinbo Bai, Amrit Singh Bedi, Vaneet Aggarwal
0
0
We consider the problem of constrained Markov decision process (CMDP) in continuous state-actions spaces where the goal is to maximize the expected cumulative reward subject to some constraints. We propose a novel Conservative Natural Policy Gradient Primal-Dual Algorithm (C-NPG-PD) to achieve zero constraint violation while achieving state of the art convergence results for the objective value function. For general policy parametrization, we prove convergence of value function to global optimal upto an approximation error due to restricted policy class. We even improve the sample complexity of existing constrained NPG-PD algorithm cite{Ding2020} from $mathcal{O}(1/epsilon^6)$ to $mathcal{O}(1/epsilon^4)$. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to establish zero constraint violation with Natural policy gradient style algorithms for infinite horizon discounted CMDPs. We demonstrate the merits of proposed algorithm via experimental evaluations.
5/20/2024
🏅
Constrained Reinforcement Learning with Average Reward Objective: Model-Based and Model-Free Algorithms
Vaneet Aggarwal, Washim Uddin Mondal, Qinbo Bai
0
0
Reinforcement Learning (RL) serves as a versatile framework for sequential decision-making, finding applications across diverse domains such as robotics, autonomous driving, recommendation systems, supply chain optimization, biology, mechanics, and finance. The primary objective in these applications is to maximize the average reward. Real-world scenarios often necessitate adherence to specific constraints during the learning process. This monograph focuses on the exploration of various model-based and model-free approaches for Constrained RL within the context of average reward Markov Decision Processes (MDPs). The investigation commences with an examination of model-based strategies, delving into two foundational methods - optimism in the face of uncertainty and posterior sampling. Subsequently, the discussion transitions to parametrized model-free approaches, where the primal-dual policy gradient-based algorithm is explored as a solution for constrained MDPs. The monograph provides regret guarantees and analyzes constraint violation for each of the discussed setups. For the above exploration, we assume the underlying MDP to be ergodic. Further, this monograph extends its discussion to encompass results tailored for weakly communicating MDPs, thereby broadening the scope of its findings and their relevance to a wider range of practical scenarios.
6/24/2024