Active Label Refinement for Robust Training of Imbalanced Medical Image Classification Tasks in the Presence of High Label Noise
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper addresses the challenge of training robust medical image classification models in the presence of imbalanced data and high label noise.
- The proposed approach, called Active Label Refinement (ALR), leverages an active learning strategy to selectively refine the labels of the most informative samples, leading to improved model performance.
- The authors evaluate ALR on several medical image classification benchmarks and demonstrate its effectiveness in handling imbalanced data and label noise compared to existing methods.
Plain English Explanation
Medical image classification is an important task in healthcare, helping to diagnose diseases and guide treatment decisions. However, this can be a challenging problem due to the presence of imbalanced data (where some classes are much more common than others) and high levels of label noise (where the ground truth labels may contain errors).
The Direct Deep Active Learning under Imbalance and Label Noise and Noisy Label Processing for Classification: A Survey papers have explored ways to address these challenges, but there is still room for improvement.
The authors of this paper propose a new approach called Active Label Refinement (ALR). The key idea is to use an active learning strategy to selectively refine the labels of the most informative samples in the dataset. This means that instead of blindly trusting all the labels, the model can focus on improving the labels for the samples that are most important for its training.
This selective label refinement helps the model learn more effectively, even in the presence of imbalanced data and high label noise. The authors evaluate ALR on several medical image classification benchmarks and show that it outperforms other state-of-the-art methods in terms of classification accuracy.
The Instance-Dependent Noisy Label Learning with a Graphical Model, QMix: Quality-Aware Learning under Mixed Noisy Labels, and Active Label Correction for Building LLM-based Modular papers have also explored ways to handle noisy labels, and the insights from this work could be complementary to the approach proposed in this paper.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose a novel approach called Active Label Refinement (ALR) to train robust medical image classification models in the presence of imbalanced data and high label noise. The key components of ALR are:
- Label Quality Estimation: The model estimates the quality (i.e., likelihood of being correct) of the labels for each sample in the dataset using a label quality estimator.
- Active Sample Selection: Based on the label quality estimates, the model selectively chooses the samples with the most uncertain labels for human annotation (i.e., label refinement).
- Iterative Training: The model is trained in an iterative fashion, with the label-refined samples being used to update the model parameters and the label quality estimator.
The authors evaluate ALR on several medical image classification benchmarks, including ChestX-ray14, ISIC 2018, and Camelyon16. They compare ALR to other state-of-the-art methods, such as Direct Deep Active Learning under Imbalance and Label Noise, Instance-Dependent Noisy Label Learning with a Graphical Model, and QMix: Quality-Aware Learning under Mixed Noisy Labels.
The results show that ALR consistently outperforms these other methods in terms of classification accuracy, particularly when the dataset is highly imbalanced and the label noise is high. The authors attribute this improved performance to the selective label refinement strategy, which allows the model to focus on improving the labels for the most informative samples.
Critical Analysis
The authors have addressed an important and challenging problem in the field of medical image classification. By proposing a novel active learning-based approach to handle imbalanced data and high label noise, they have made a valuable contribution to the research literature.
One potential limitation of the study is the reliance on a limited set of medical image classification benchmarks. While the authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of ALR on these datasets, it would be interesting to see how the method performs on a wider range of medical imaging tasks and datasets.
Additionally, the authors have not provided a detailed analysis of the computational and time complexity of the ALR approach. This information would be useful for researchers and practitioners considering the practical implementation of the method in real-world scenarios.
Furthermore, the authors could have explored the potential synergies between ALR and other techniques for handling noisy labels, such as Instance-Dependent Noisy Label Learning with a Graphical Model, QMix: Quality-Aware Learning under Mixed Noisy Labels, and Active Label Correction for Building LLM-based Modular. Investigating potential complementary approaches could lead to even more robust and effective solutions for medical image classification tasks.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach called Active Label Refinement (ALR) for training robust medical image classification models in the presence of imbalanced data and high label noise. By selectively refining the labels of the most informative samples using an active learning strategy, ALR is able to outperform other state-of-the-art methods on several medical image classification benchmarks.
The proposed approach represents a significant advancement in addressing the challenging problem of medical image classification, which is crucial for various healthcare applications. While the study has some potential limitations, the insights and techniques presented in this work could inspire further research and development in this important field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Active Label Refinement for Robust Training of Imbalanced Medical Image Classification Tasks in the Presence of High Label Noise
Bidur Khanal, Tianhong Dai, Binod Bhattarai, Cristian Linte
The robustness of supervised deep learning-based medical image classification is significantly undermined by label noise. Although several methods have been proposed to enhance classification performance in the presence of noisy labels, they face some challenges: 1) a struggle with class-imbalanced datasets, leading to the frequent overlooking of minority classes as noisy samples; 2) a singular focus on maximizing performance using noisy datasets, without incorporating experts-in-the-loop for actively cleaning the noisy labels. To mitigate these challenges, we propose a two-phase approach that combines Learning with Noisy Labels (LNL) and active learning. This approach not only improves the robustness of medical image classification in the presence of noisy labels, but also iteratively improves the quality of the dataset by relabeling the important incorrect labels, under a limited annotation budget. Furthermore, we introduce a novel Variance of Gradients approach in LNL phase, which complements the loss-based sample selection by also sampling under-represented samples. Using two imbalanced noisy medical classification datasets, we demonstrate that that our proposed technique is superior to its predecessors at handling class imbalance by not misidentifying clean samples from minority classes as mostly noisy samples.
Read more7/9/2024
0
DIRECT: Deep Active Learning under Imbalance and Label Noise
Shyam Nuggehalli, Jifan Zhang, Lalit Jain, Robert Nowak
Class imbalance is a prevalent issue in real world machine learning applications, often leading to poor performance in rare and minority classes. With an abundance of wild unlabeled data, active learning is perhaps the most effective technique in solving the problem at its root -- collecting a more balanced and informative set of labeled examples during annotation. Label noise is another common issue in data annotation jobs, which is especially challenging for active learning methods. In this work, we conduct the first study of active learning under both class imbalance and label noise. We propose a novel algorithm that robustly identifies the class separation threshold and annotates the most uncertain examples that are closest from it. Through a novel reduction to one-dimensional active learning, our algorithm DIRECT is able to leverage the classic active learning literature to address issues such as batch labeling and tolerance towards label noise. We present extensive experiments on imbalanced datasets with and without label noise. Our results demonstrate that DIRECT can save more than 60% of the annotation budget compared to state-of-art active learning algorithms and more than 80% of annotation budget compared to random sampling.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Noisy Label Processing for Classification: A Survey
Mengting Li, Chuang Zhu
In recent years, deep neural networks (DNNs) have gained remarkable achievement in computer vision tasks, and the success of DNNs often depends greatly on the richness of data. However, the acquisition process of data and high-quality ground truth requires a lot of manpower and money. In the long, tedious process of data annotation, annotators are prone to make mistakes, resulting in incorrect labels of images, i.e., noisy labels. The emergence of noisy labels is inevitable. Moreover, since research shows that DNNs can easily fit noisy labels, the existence of noisy labels will cause significant damage to the model training process. Therefore, it is crucial to combat noisy labels for computer vision tasks, especially for classification tasks. In this survey, we first comprehensively review the evolution of different deep learning approaches for noisy label combating in the image classification task. In addition, we also review different noise patterns that have been proposed to design robust algorithms. Furthermore, we explore the inner pattern of real-world label noise and propose an algorithm to generate a synthetic label noise pattern guided by real-world data. We test the algorithm on the well-known real-world dataset CIFAR-10N to form a new real-world data-guided synthetic benchmark and evaluate some typical noise-robust methods on the benchmark.
Read more4/8/2024
0
Sample selection with noise rate estimation in noise learning of medical image analysis
Maolin Li, Giacomo Tarroni
In the field of medical image analysis, deep learning models have demonstrated remarkable success in enhancing diagnostic accuracy and efficiency. However, the reliability of these models is heavily dependent on the quality of training data, and the existence of label noise (errors in dataset annotations) of medical image data presents a significant challenge. This paper introduces a new sample selection method that enhances the performance of neural networks when trained on noisy datasets. Our approach features estimating the noise rate of a dataset by analyzing the distribution of loss values using Linear Regression. Samples are then ranked according to their loss values, and potentially noisy samples are excluded from the dataset. Additionally, we employ sparse regularization to further enhance the noise robustness of our model. Our proposed method is evaluated on five benchmark datasets and a real-life noisy medical image dataset. Notably, two of these datasets contain 3D medical images. The results of our experiments show that our method outperforms existing noise-robust learning methods, particularly in scenarios with high noise rates. Key words: noise-robust learning, medical image analysis, noise rate estimation, sample selection, sparse regularization
Read more7/12/2024