Benchmarking Vision-Language Contrastive Methods for Medical Representation Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper compares different vision-language contrastive learning methods for medical representation learning.
- The authors evaluate the performance of these methods on various medical image and text tasks to understand their strengths and weaknesses.
- The goal is to identify the most effective approach for learning robust and generalizable representations from medical data.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines different ways of training AI models to understand the connection between medical images and the text descriptions associated with them. This is an important task, as being able to relate visual medical data (like X-rays or CT scans) with the corresponding text (like a doctor's notes) can help develop more powerful AI systems for medical applications.
The authors compare several "vision-language contrastive learning" methods, which are techniques that learn to match up images and text by contrasting positive and negative examples. They test these methods on a variety of medical image and text understanding tasks to see which ones perform the best.
The goal is to find the most effective approach for learning useful representations from medical data that can be applied broadly, rather than just for a single specialized task. This could lead to AI systems that can better comprehend and reason about the connections between medical visuals and text, with applications in areas like automated report generation or cross-modal retrieval.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates several vision-language contrastive learning methods for medical representation learning, including CLIP, ALIGN, and ConVIRT. These approaches learn to match medical images and text by contrasting positive (matching) and negative (non-matching) image-text pairs.
The authors test the learned representations on a range of downstream medical tasks, including image classification, text classification, and cross-modal retrieval. They analyze the performance of each method, as well as the transferability of the learned representations to different datasets and tasks.
The results show that the evaluated contrastive learning methods exhibit varying strengths and weaknesses. For example, CLIP demonstrates strong performance on image classification, while ConVIRT excels at cross-modal retrieval. The authors provide insights into the factors that influence the effectiveness of these approaches, such as the choice of pretraining data and the specific contrastive objective.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of several state-of-the-art vision-language contrastive learning methods for medical representation learning. The authors acknowledge the limitations of their study, such as the reliance on a limited set of tasks and datasets, and the potential impact of hyperparameter choices on the results.
One potential area for further research is the exploration of more specialized contrastive objectives or architectures tailored to the unique characteristics of medical data and tasks. Additionally, the authors do not address the potential data privacy and ethical concerns that may arise when training on large-scale medical datasets, which is an important consideration for real-world deployment of such systems.
Overall, the paper offers valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of different vision-language contrastive learning methods for medical representation learning, and serves as a useful benchmark for future research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper provides a thorough evaluation of several vision-language contrastive learning methods for medical representation learning. The authors demonstrate the varying performance of these approaches across a range of medical image and text understanding tasks, offering insights into the factors that influence their effectiveness.
The findings of this research can inform the development of more powerful and generalizable AI systems for medical applications, such as automated report generation and cross-modal retrieval. As the field of medical AI continues to evolve, the insights from this benchmarking study can serve as a valuable reference for practitioners and researchers alike.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Benchmarking Vision-Language Contrastive Methods for Medical Representation Learning
Shuvendu Roy, Yasaman Parhizkar, Franklin Ogidi, Vahid Reza Khazaie, Michael Colacci, Ali Etemad, Elham Dolatabadi, Arash Afkanpour
We perform a comprehensive benchmarking of contrastive frameworks for learning multimodal representations in the medical domain. Through this study, we aim to answer the following research questions: (i) How transferable are general-domain representations to the medical domain? (ii) Is multimodal contrastive training sufficient, or does it benefit from unimodal training as well? (iii) What is the impact of feature granularity on the effectiveness of multimodal medical representation learning? To answer these questions, we investigate eight contrastive learning approaches under identical training setups, and train them on 2.8 million image-text pairs from four datasets, and evaluate them on 25 downstream tasks, including classification (zero-shot and linear probing), image-to-text and text-to-image retrieval, and visual question-answering. Our findings suggest a positive answer to the first question, a negative answer to the second question, and the benefit of learning fine-grained features. Finally, we make our code publicly available.
Read more6/12/2024
0
Few-shot Adaptation of Medical Vision-Language Models
Fereshteh Shakeri, Yunshi Huang, Julio Silva-Rodr'iguez, Houda Bahig, An Tang, Jose Dolz, Ismail Ben Ayed
Integrating image and text data through multi-modal learning has emerged as a new approach in medical imaging research, following its successful deployment in computer vision. While considerable efforts have been dedicated to establishing medical foundation models and their zero-shot transfer to downstream tasks, the popular few-shot setting remains relatively unexplored. Following on from the currently strong emergence of this setting in computer vision, we introduce the first structured benchmark for adapting medical vision-language models (VLMs) in a strict few-shot regime and investigate various adaptation strategies commonly used in the context of natural images. Furthermore, we evaluate a simple generalization of the linear-probe adaptation baseline, which seeks an optimal blending of the visual prototypes and text embeddings via learnable class-wise multipliers. Surprisingly, such a text-informed linear probe yields competitive performances in comparison to convoluted prompt-learning and adapter-based strategies, while running considerably faster and accommodating the black-box setting. Our extensive experiments span three different medical modalities and specialized foundation models, nine downstream tasks, and several state-of-the-art few-shot adaptation methods. We made our benchmark and code publicly available to trigger further developments in this emergent subject: url{https://github.com/FereshteShakeri/few-shot-MedVLMs}.
Read more9/9/2024
0
Learning Generalized Medical Image Representations through Image-Graph Contrastive Pretraining
Sameer Khanna, Daniel Michael, Marinka Zitnik, Pranav Rajpurkar
Medical image interpretation using deep learning has shown promise but often requires extensive expert-annotated datasets. To reduce this annotation burden, we develop an Image-Graph Contrastive Learning framework that pairs chest X-rays with structured report knowledge graphs automatically extracted from radiology notes. Our approach uniquely encodes the disconnected graph components via a relational graph convolution network and transformer attention. In experiments on the CheXpert dataset, this novel graph encoding strategy enabled the framework to outperform existing methods that use image-text contrastive learning in 1% linear evaluation and few-shot settings, while achieving comparable performance to radiologists. By exploiting unlabeled paired images and text, our framework demonstrates the potential of structured clinical insights to enhance contrastive learning for medical images. This work points toward reducing demands on medical experts for annotations, improving diagnostic precision, and advancing patient care through robust medical image understanding.
Read more5/17/2024
🔄
0
Exploring Transfer Learning in Medical Image Segmentation using Vision-Language Models
Kanchan Poudel, Manish Dhakal, Prasiddha Bhandari, Rabin Adhikari, Safal Thapaliya, Bishesh Khanal
Medical image segmentation allows quantifying target structure size and shape, aiding in disease diagnosis, prognosis, surgery planning, and comprehension.Building upon recent advancements in foundation Vision-Language Models (VLMs) from natural image-text pairs, several studies have proposed adapting them to Vision-Language Segmentation Models (VLSMs) that allow using language text as an additional input to segmentation models. Introducing auxiliary information via text with human-in-the-loop prompting during inference opens up unique opportunities, such as open vocabulary segmentation and potentially more robust segmentation models against out-of-distribution data. Although transfer learning from natural to medical images has been explored for image-only segmentation models, the joint representation of vision-language in segmentation problems remains underexplored. This study introduces the first systematic study on transferring VLSMs to 2D medical images, using carefully curated $11$ datasets encompassing diverse modalities and insightful language prompts and experiments. Our findings demonstrate that although VLSMs show competitive performance compared to image-only models for segmentation after finetuning in limited medical image datasets, not all VLSMs utilize the additional information from language prompts, with image features playing a dominant role. While VLSMs exhibit enhanced performance in handling pooled datasets with diverse modalities and show potential robustness to domain shifts compared to conventional segmentation models, our results suggest that novel approaches are required to enable VLSMs to leverage the various auxiliary information available through language prompts. The code and datasets are available at https://github.com/naamiinepal/medvlsm.
Read more6/21/2024