Contrasting Intra-Modal and Ranking Cross-Modal Hard Negatives to Enhance Visio-Linguistic Compositional Understanding
2306.08832
0
0
Abstract
Vision-Language Models (VLMs), such as CLIP, exhibit strong image-text comprehension abilities, facilitating advances in several downstream tasks such as zero-shot image classification, image-text retrieval, and text-to-image generation. However, the compositional reasoning abilities of existing VLMs remains subpar. The root of this limitation lies in the inadequate alignment between the images and captions in the pretraining datasets. Additionally, the current contrastive learning objective fails to focus on fine-grained grounding components like relations, actions, and attributes, resulting in bag-of-words representations. We introduce a simple and effective method to improve compositional reasoning in VLMs. Our method better leverages available datasets by refining and expanding the standard image-text contrastive learning framework. Our approach does not require specific annotations and does not incur extra parameters. When integrated with CLIP, our technique yields notable improvement over state-of-the-art baselines across five vision-language compositional benchmarks. We open-source our code at https://github.com/lezhang7/Enhance-FineGrained.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores techniques for improving visio-linguistic fine-grained understanding, which is the ability to analyze and comprehend the relationship between visual and textual information.
- The authors propose two methods for training machine learning models to better understand the nuances between visual and linguistic data: contrasting intra-modal hard negatives and ranking cross-modal hard negatives.
- The techniques aim to help models better distinguish between relevant and irrelevant visual-textual pairings, leading to enhanced performance on downstream tasks that require fine-grained understanding.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about helping AI systems better understand the relationship between images and text. The authors suggest two new training techniques to improve this "visio-linguistic fine-grained understanding."
The first technique, "contrasting intra-modal hard negatives," focuses on training the model to clearly differentiate between similar images or similar text. This helps the model learn to spot even subtle differences.
The second technique, "ranking cross-modal hard negatives," trains the model to rank pairings of images and text from most relevant to least relevant. This teaches the model to truly grasp the nuanced connections between visual and linguistic information.
By using these techniques, the authors aim to create AI systems that can analyze images and text with a higher level of sophistication and precision. This could lead to improvements in all kinds of applications that require understanding the deep relationships between what we see and what we read.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents two novel approaches for enhancing visio-linguistic fine-grained understanding in machine learning models:
-
Contrasting Intra-Modal Hard Negatives: This technique focuses on training the model to better distinguish between similar images or similar text. By creating "hard negative" examples that are very close to positive examples, the model is forced to learn more discriminative features within a single modality (e.g., images or text). This helps the model develop a more nuanced understanding of the differences between visually or linguistically similar inputs.
-
Ranking Cross-Modal Hard Negatives: Here, the model is trained to rank pairings of images and text from most relevant to least relevant. This "ranking" approach, combined with "hard negative" examples that have a high degree of visual-textual similarity but are ultimately not a match, encourages the model to more precisely capture the complex relationships between the two modalities.
The authors evaluate these techniques on several downstream tasks that require fine-grained visio-linguistic understanding, such as ComCLIP, Iterated Learning, and Eyes Wide Shut. The results demonstrate that the proposed methods can significantly improve model performance compared to standard training approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful and well-designed approach to enhancing visio-linguistic understanding in machine learning models. The two proposed techniques, contrasting intra-modal hard negatives and ranking cross-modal hard negatives, appear to be effective in improving model performance on relevant tasks.
One potential limitation mentioned in the paper is the computational cost and complexity associated with generating the hard negative examples. The authors acknowledge that this could be a challenge, especially for large-scale datasets and models. Further research may be needed to explore more efficient ways of creating the hard negative samples without significantly increasing training time and resource requirements.
Additionally, while the paper focuses on evaluating the techniques on specific downstream tasks, it would be valuable to assess the broader applicability and generalizability of the methods. Exploring their performance on a wider range of visio-linguistic tasks, as well as their impact on real-world applications, could provide deeper insights into the practical implications of this work.
Overall, the paper presents a promising approach to enhancing visio-linguistic understanding, and the proposed techniques could have important implications for various fields that rely on the ability to effectively integrate and comprehend visual and textual information, such as Learn No to Say Yes Better and RankCLIP.
Conclusion
This paper introduces two novel techniques, contrasting intra-modal hard negatives and ranking cross-modal hard negatives, to improve visio-linguistic fine-grained understanding in machine learning models. The authors demonstrate that these methods can significantly enhance model performance on downstream tasks that require a nuanced comprehension of the relationships between visual and textual information.
The proposed approaches provide a valuable contribution to the field of multimodal learning, offering strategies to help AI systems better grasp the intricate connections between what they see and what they read. As visio-linguistic understanding becomes increasingly important in various applications, such as image captioning, visual question answering, and language-guided image manipulation, this work could have far-reaching implications for advancing the state of the art in these domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Exploring the Spectrum of Visio-Linguistic Compositionality and Recognition
Youngtaek Oh, Pyunghwan Ahn, Jinhyung Kim, Gwangmo Song, Soonyoung Lee, In So Kweon, Junmo Kim
0
0
Vision and language models (VLMs) such as CLIP have showcased remarkable zero-shot recognition abilities yet face challenges in visio-linguistic compositionality, particularly in linguistic comprehension and fine-grained image-text alignment. This paper explores the intricate relationship between compositionality and recognition -- two pivotal aspects of VLM capability. We conduct a comprehensive evaluation of existing VLMs, covering both pre-training approaches aimed at recognition and the fine-tuning methods designed to improve compositionality. Our evaluation employs 12 benchmarks for compositionality, along with 21 zero-shot classification and two retrieval benchmarks for recognition. In our analysis from 274 CLIP model checkpoints, we reveal patterns and trade-offs that emerge between compositional understanding and recognition accuracy. Ultimately, this necessitates strategic efforts towards developing models that improve both capabilities, as well as the meticulous formulation of benchmarks for compositionality. We open our evaluation framework at https://github.com/ytaek-oh/vl_compo.
6/14/2024
🖼️
ComCLIP: Training-Free Compositional Image and Text Matching
Kenan Jiang, Xuehai He, Ruize Xu, Xin Eric Wang
0
0
Contrastive Language-Image Pretraining (CLIP) has demonstrated great zero-shot performance for matching images and text. However, it is still challenging to adapt vision-lanaguage pretrained models like CLIP to compositional image and text matching -- a more challenging image and text matching task requiring the model understanding of compositional word concepts and visual components. Towards better compositional generalization in zero-shot image and text matching, in this paper, we study the problem from a causal perspective: the erroneous semantics of individual entities are essentially confounders that cause the matching failure. Therefore, we propose a novel textbf{textit{training-free}} compositional CLIP model (ComCLIP). ComCLIP disentangles input images into subjects, objects, and action sub-images and composes CLIP's vision encoder and text encoder to perform evolving matching over compositional text embedding and sub-image embeddings. In this way, ComCLIP can mitigate spurious correlations introduced by the pretrained CLIP models and dynamically evaluate the importance of each component. Experiments on four compositional image-text matching datasets: SVO, ComVG, Winoground, and VL-checklist, and two general image-text retrieval datasets: Flick30K, and MSCOCO demonstrate the effectiveness of our plug-and-play method, which boosts the textbf{textit{zero-shot}} inference ability of CLIP, SLIP, and BLIP2 even without further training or fine-tuning. Our codes can be found at https://github.com/eric-ai-lab/ComCLIP.
4/16/2024
ConMe: Rethinking Evaluation of Compositional Reasoning for Modern VLMs
Irene Huang, Wei Lin, M. Jehanzeb Mirza, Jacob A. Hansen, Sivan Doveh, Victor Ion Butoi, Roei Herzig, Assaf Arbelle, Hilde Kuhene, Trevor Darrel, Chuang Gan, Aude Oliva, Rogerio Feris, Leonid Karlinsky
0
0
Compositional Reasoning (CR) entails grasping the significance of attributes, relations, and word order. Recent Vision-Language Models (VLMs), comprising a visual encoder and a Large Language Model (LLM) decoder, have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in such reasoning tasks. This prompts a crucial question: have VLMs effectively tackled the CR challenge? We conjecture that existing CR benchmarks may not adequately push the boundaries of modern VLMs due to the reliance on an LLM-only negative text generation pipeline. Consequently, the negatives produced either appear as outliers from the natural language distribution learned by VLMs' LLM decoders or as improbable within the corresponding image context. To address these limitations, we introduce ConMe -- a compositional reasoning benchmark and a novel data generation pipeline leveraging VLMs to produce `hard CR Q&A'. Through a new concept of VLMs conversing with each other to collaboratively expose their weaknesses, our pipeline autonomously generates, evaluates, and selects challenging compositional reasoning questions, establishing a robust CR benchmark, also subsequently validated manually. Our benchmark provokes a noteworthy, up to 33%, decrease in CR performance compared to preceding benchmarks, reinstating the CR challenge even for state-of-the-art VLMs.
6/13/2024
⚙️
CLAP: Isolating Content from Style through Contrastive Learning with Augmented Prompts
Yichao Cai, Yuhang Liu, Zhen Zhang, Javen Qinfeng Shi
0
0
Contrastive vision-language models, such as CLIP, have garnered considerable attention for various dowmsteam tasks, mainly due to the remarkable ability of the learned features for generalization. However, the features they learned often blend content and style information, which somewhat limits their generalization capabilities under distribution shifts. To address this limitation, we adopt a causal generative perspective for multimodal data and propose contrastive learning with data augmentation to disentangle content features from the original representations. To achieve this, we begins with exploring image augmentation techniques and develop a method to seamlessly integrate them into pre-trained CLIP-like models to extract pure content features. Taking a step further, recognizing the inherent semantic richness and logical structure of text data, we explore the use of text augmentation to isolate latent content from style features. This enables CLIP-like model's encoders to concentrate on latent content information, refining the learned representations by pre-trained CLIP-like models. Our extensive experiments across diverse datasets demonstrate significant improvements in zero-shot and few-shot classification tasks, alongside enhanced robustness to various perturbations. These results underscore the effectiveness of our proposed methods in refining vision-language representations and advancing the state-of-the-art in multimodal learning.
4/30/2024