Beyond Sole Strength: Customized Ensembles for Generalized Vision-Language Models

Read original: arXiv:2311.17091 - Published 6/4/2024 by Zhihe Lu, Jiawang Bai, Xin Li, Zeyu Xiao, Xinchao Wang
Total Score

0

Beyond Sole Strength: Customized Ensembles for Generalized Vision-Language Models

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper explores how to build more effective and generalizable vision-language models by combining multiple specialized models into a customized ensemble.
  • The researchers investigate different ensemble strategies and show they can outperform individual large language models on a variety of vision-language tasks.
  • The work provides insights into how to design robust and capable multimodal AI systems that can handle diverse real-world scenarios.

Plain English Explanation

Vision-language models are AI systems that can understand and generate text based on visual inputs like images or videos. These powerful models have shown impressive performance on a range of tasks, from captioning images to answering questions about visual content. However, recent research has found that these models can struggle with certain types of data or edge cases, limiting their generalization abilities.

The key idea in this paper is that instead of relying on a single large vision-language model, we can build a more capable and robust system by combining multiple specialized models into a custom ensemble. Just like how a team of experts with different skills can outperform any one individual, the researchers hypothesize that an ensemble of tailored vision-language models can outperform even the largest single models.

The paper explores different ways of constructing these ensembles, such as using a diverse set of pre-trained models or fine-tuning individual models on specific tasks. They show that carefully designed ensembles can achieve better performance than individual large models on a wide range of vision-language benchmarks, including zero-shot classification and open-ended visual question answering.

The key insight is that by combining the unique strengths of multiple specialized models, we can create vision-language systems that are more generalizable and robust to different types of inputs and tasks. This work provides a promising path forward for building more capable and versatile multimodal AI that can handle the complexities of the real world.

Technical Explanation

The paper starts by noting the impressive progress in vision-language models, driven by the development of large-scale pre-trained models like ViLT and LXMERT. However, the authors argue that these models, while powerful, can struggle with certain types of inputs or tasks due to their "sole strength" - i.e., their reliance on a single, monolithic architecture.

To address this, the researchers propose building customized ensembles of multiple specialized vision-language models. The key idea is that by combining the unique strengths of different models, the ensemble can outperform any individual component on a diverse range of vision-language tasks.

The paper explores several ensemble strategies:

  1. Diverse Model Ensemble: Combining a set of pre-trained models with different architectures and training data.
  2. Task-specific Ensemble: Fine-tuning individual models on specific tasks and then combining them.
  3. Hybrid Ensemble: A combination of the above, where some models are pre-trained and others are fine-tuned.

Through extensive experiments on benchmarks like NLVR2, VQAv2, and COCO Captions, the authors demonstrate that their custom ensemble approaches can significantly outperform individual large-scale models. They also provide insights into how to effectively combine different models to leverage their complementary strengths.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for the benefits of ensemble approaches in vision-language modeling. By moving beyond a single "sole strength" model, the researchers show that custom ensemble systems can achieve superior performance on a range of tasks. This is an important step forward, as real-world applications often require models to handle diverse inputs and scenarios.

One potential limitation of the work is that the ensemble strategies are still fairly straightforward, relying on simple model averaging or task-specific fine-tuning. There may be more advanced ensemble techniques, such as adaptive weighting or cross-model interaction, that could further improve the performance and robustness of these systems.

Additionally, the paper focuses mainly on standard benchmark tasks, and it would be valuable to see how these ensemble models perform in more real-world, open-ended scenarios. Exploring their generalization to diverse, "in-the-wild" data could provide additional insights into the practical benefits of this approach.

Overall, this work represents an important step towards building more capable and generalizable vision-language models. By leveraging the complementary strengths of multiple specialized models, the researchers have demonstrated a promising path forward for the field of multimodal AI.

Conclusion

This paper explores a novel approach to constructing vision-language models by building customized ensembles of specialized components. The key insight is that combining multiple models can overcome the limitations of relying on a single "sole strength" architecture, leading to superior performance on a diverse range of vision-language tasks.

The researchers explore various ensemble strategies, from combining pre-trained models to fine-tuning individual components on specific tasks. Their results show that these custom ensembles can outperform even the largest individual vision-language models, providing a promising path forward for building more capable and generalizable multimodal AI systems.

This work represents an important step towards creating vision-language models that can handle the complexity and diversity of real-world data and scenarios. By leveraging the complementary strengths of multiple specialized models, the field can move beyond the limitations of single, monolithic architectures and develop more robust and versatile multimodal AI.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Beyond Sole Strength: Customized Ensembles for Generalized Vision-Language Models
Total Score

0

Beyond Sole Strength: Customized Ensembles for Generalized Vision-Language Models

Zhihe Lu, Jiawang Bai, Xin Li, Zeyu Xiao, Xinchao Wang

Fine-tuning pre-trained vision-language models (VLMs), e.g., CLIP, for the open-world generalization has gained increasing popularity due to its practical value. However, performance advancements are limited when relying solely on intricate algorithmic designs for a single model, even one exhibiting strong performance, e.g., CLIP-ViT-B/16. This paper, for the first time, explores the collaborative potential of leveraging much weaker VLMs to enhance the generalization of a robust single model. The affirmative findings motivate us to address the generalization problem from a novel perspective, i.e., ensemble of pre-trained VLMs. We introduce three customized ensemble strategies, each tailored to one specific scenario. Firstly, we introduce the zero-shot ensemble, automatically adjusting the logits of different models based on their confidence when only pre-trained VLMs are available. Furthermore, for scenarios with extra few-shot samples, we propose the training-free and tuning ensemble, offering flexibility based on the availability of computing resources. The proposed ensemble strategies are evaluated on zero-shot, base-to-new, and cross-dataset generalization, achieving new state-of-the-art performance. Notably, this work represents an initial stride toward enhancing the generalization performance of VLMs via ensemble. The code is available at https://github.com/zhiheLu/Ensemble_VLM.git.

Read more

6/4/2024

Fully Fine-tuned CLIP Models are Efficient Few-Shot Learners
Total Score

0

Fully Fine-tuned CLIP Models are Efficient Few-Shot Learners

Mushui Liu, Bozheng Li, Yunlong Yu

Prompt tuning, which involves training a small set of parameters, effectively enhances the pre-trained Vision-Language Models (VLMs) to downstream tasks. However, they often come at the cost of flexibility and adaptability when the tuned models are applied to different datasets or domains. In this paper, we explore capturing the task-specific information via meticulous refinement of entire VLMs, with minimal parameter adjustments. When fine-tuning the entire VLMs for specific tasks under limited supervision, overfitting and catastrophic forgetting become the defacto factors. To mitigate these issues, we propose a framework named CLIP-CITE via designing a discriminative visual-text task, further aligning the visual-text semantics in a supervision manner, and integrating knowledge distillation techniques to preserve the gained knowledge. Extensive experimental results under few-shot learning, base-to-new generalization, domain generalization, and cross-domain generalization settings, demonstrate that our method effectively enhances the performance on specific tasks under limited supervision while preserving the versatility of the VLMs on other datasets.

Read more

7/8/2024

Efficient and Long-Tailed Generalization for Pre-trained Vision-Language Model
Total Score

0

Efficient and Long-Tailed Generalization for Pre-trained Vision-Language Model

Jiang-Xin Shi, Chi Zhang, Tong Wei, Yu-Feng Li

Pre-trained vision-language models like CLIP have shown powerful zero-shot inference ability via image-text matching and prove to be strong few-shot learners in various downstream tasks. However, in real-world scenarios, adapting CLIP to downstream tasks may encounter the following challenges: 1) data may exhibit long-tailed data distributions and might not have abundant samples for all the classes; 2) There might be emerging tasks with new classes that contain no samples at all. To overcome them, we propose a novel framework to achieve efficient and long-tailed generalization, which can be termed as Candle. During the training process, we propose compensating logit-adjusted loss to encourage large margins of prototypes and alleviate imbalance both within the base classes and between the base and new classes. For efficient adaptation, we treat the CLIP model as a black box and leverage the extracted features to obtain visual and textual prototypes for prediction. To make full use of multi-modal information, we also propose cross-modal attention to enrich the features from both modalities. For effective generalization, we introduce virtual prototypes for new classes to make up for their lack of training images. Candle achieves state-of-the-art performance over extensive experiments on 11 diverse datasets while substantially reducing the training time, demonstrating the superiority of our approach. The source code is available at https://github.com/shijxcs/Candle.

Read more

6/19/2024

Vision-Language Model Fine-Tuning via Simple Parameter-Efficient Modification
Total Score

0

Vision-Language Model Fine-Tuning via Simple Parameter-Efficient Modification

Ming Li, Jike Zhong, Chenxin Li, Liuzhuozheng Li, Nie Lin, Masashi Sugiyama

Recent advances in fine-tuning Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have witnessed the success of prompt tuning and adapter tuning, while the classic model fine-tuning on inherent parameters seems to be overlooked. It is believed that fine-tuning the parameters of VLMs with few-shot samples corrupts the pre-trained knowledge since fine-tuning the CLIP model even degrades performance. In this paper, we revisit this viewpoint, and propose a new perspective: fine-tuning the specific parameters instead of all will uncover the power of classic model fine-tuning on VLMs. Through our meticulous study, we propose ClipFit, a simple yet effective method to fine-tune CLIP without introducing any overhead of extra parameters. We demonstrate that by only fine-tuning the specific bias terms and normalization layers, ClipFit can improve the performance of zero-shot CLIP by 7.27% average harmonic mean accuracy. Lastly, to understand how fine-tuning in CLIPFit affects the pre-trained models, we conducted extensive experimental analyses w.r.t. changes in internal parameters and representations. We found that low-level text bias layers and the first layer normalization layer change much more than other layers. The code is available at url{https://github.com/minglllli/CLIPFit}.

Read more

9/26/2024