Case-Based Reasoning Approach for Solving Financial Question Answering

Overview

• Measuring a machine's understanding of human language often involves assessing its reasoning skills, i.e. the logical process of deriving answers to questions.
• Recent language models have shown remarkable proficiency in text-based tasks, but their efficacy in complex reasoning problems involving heterogeneous information like text, tables, and numbers remains uncertain.
• The FinQA dataset introduced a numerical reasoning task for financial documents and proposed a program generation approach to address it.
• The study found that half of the errors (48%) were due to incorrect operations being generated.
• To address this issue, the researchers propose a novel approach using case-based reasoning (CBR), an AI paradigm that provides problem-solving guidance by offering similar cases (i.e., similar questions and corresponding logical programs).

Plain English Explanation

Machines can understand human language quite well these days, but they still struggle with more complex reasoning tasks that involve different types of information, like text, tables, and numbers. The FinQA dataset was created to test how well machines can do numerical reasoning on financial documents.

The researchers found that a major problem with the existing approaches was that the machines were generating incorrect mathematical operations when trying to answer the questions. To fix this, the researchers developed a new method that uses case-based reasoning (CBR). This means the machine looks for similar questions it has seen before and uses the solutions to those previous cases to help it answer the new question.

By expanding the machine's "memory" of past cases, the researchers were able to improve the machine's performance on these complex, multi-step reasoning problems, which was a weakness of the previous approaches. The key idea is to provide the machine with more examples of how to solve these types of problems, so it can learn from them and apply that knowledge to new questions.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a novel approach to tackle numerical reasoning problems using case-based reasoning (CBR), an AI paradigm that provides problem-solving guidance by offering similar cases (i.e., similar questions and corresponding logical programs). The model retrieves relevant cases to address a given question and then generates an answer based on the retrieved cases and contextual information.

The researchers conducted experiments on the FinQA dataset, which was introduced to benchmark numerical reasoning on financial documents. The results demonstrate the competitive performance of the CBR-based approach, and the researchers show that by expanding the case repository, the model can better solve complex, multi-step programs, which was a weakness of the previous program generation approach proposed for FinQA.

Critical Analysis

The paper's focus on addressing the issue of incorrect operations being generated is a valuable contribution, as this was a significant source of errors in the previous program generation approach. The CBR-based method provides a promising alternative that leverages the guidance of similar past cases to improve the model's reasoning abilities.

However, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the types of cases or the case retrieval mechanism used in the CBR model. More information on how the case base is constructed and how relevant cases are identified would help readers better understand the strengths and limitations of the approach.

Additionally, the paper could have explored the scalability of the CBR-based method, particularly as the case repository grows. Reasoning as Retrieval (RAR-B) and CuriousLLM are related approaches that may offer insights into scaling case-based reasoning systems.

Overall, the proposed CBR-based method shows promise in addressing the limitations of previous program generation approaches for numerical reasoning on financial documents. Further research on the specifics of the case-based reasoning system and its scalability could help strengthen the contributions of this work.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to numerical reasoning on financial documents, addressing the issue of incorrect operations being generated by previous methods. The researchers propose a case-based reasoning (CBR) model that retrieves and leverages similar past cases to guide the generation of logical programs for answering questions.

The results demonstrate the competitive performance of the CBR-based approach and its ability to better solve complex, multi-step reasoning problems compared to the previous program generation method. This work highlights the potential of case-based reasoning techniques to enhance the reasoning capabilities of language models, particularly in domains that require processing heterogeneous information and performing complex logical inferences.

As the field of numerical reasoning continues to evolve, this research contributes a promising direction for further exploration and refinement of case-based reasoning approaches to address the challenges in this important area of natural language understanding.