CONFINE: Conformal Prediction for Interpretable Neural Networks
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a new method called CONFINE that combines conformal prediction with interpretable neural networks
- Aims to provide accurate and calibrated uncertainty estimates while maintaining model interpretability
- Tested on various datasets and compared to other conformal prediction methods
Plain English Explanation
CONFINE is a new machine learning technique that combines two important ideas: conformal prediction and interpretable neural networks. Conformal prediction allows the model to provide accurate estimates of how confident it is in its predictions, which is crucial for many real-world applications. Interpretable neural networks make it easier for humans to understand how the model is making its decisions, rather than treating the model like a black box.
The key insight behind CONFINE is that you can have the best of both worlds - accurate uncertainty estimates and model interpretability. This is done by building an interpretable neural network that also outputs conformal prediction intervals, which quantify the model's uncertainty. The researchers tested CONFINE on a variety of datasets and found that it outperformed other conformal prediction methods in terms of calibration and interpretability.
This is an important advance because many machine learning models today are powerful but difficult to understand. CONFINE shows that you can create models that are both highly accurate and easily interpretable, which is critical for building trust in AI systems and deploying them safely in high-stakes applications like healthcare or finance.
Technical Explanation
The CONFINE method first trains an interpretable neural network, such as a self-consistent conformal predictor or a conformal online model aggregator. This interpretable model serves as the base for the conformal prediction process.
To generate conformal prediction intervals, CONFINE uses the residuals between the model's predictions and the true labels to calibrate the uncertainty estimates. This conformal prediction step ensures that the uncertainty estimates are well-calibrated and valid, meaning the model can reliably quantify how certain it is about each prediction.
The researchers evaluated CONFINE on several datasets, including tabular, image, and text data. They compared CONFINE to other conformal prediction methods, such as out-of-calibration detection and conformal prediction for natural language processing. The results showed that CONFINE achieved better calibration and interpretability than these alternative approaches.
Critical Analysis
One potential limitation of CONFINE is that the interpretable neural network architecture may not be as flexible or expressive as a standard "black box" neural network. This could potentially result in a trade-off between interpretability and predictive performance. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that future work could explore ways to maintain interpretability while boosting model capacity.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the computational complexity or training time of CONFINE compared to other conformal prediction methods. This information would be useful for practitioners to assess the practical feasibility of deploying CONFINE in real-world applications.
Overall, the CONFINE method represents an important step forward in the field of interpretable machine learning. By combining conformal prediction with interpretable models, the researchers have created a powerful tool that can provide reliable uncertainty estimates while also allowing users to understand the reasoning behind the model's decisions.
Conclusion
The CONFINE method addresses a crucial challenge in machine learning: how to build models that are both highly accurate and easily interpretable. By leveraging conformal prediction to generate well-calibrated uncertainty estimates and pairing this with an interpretable neural network architecture, CONFINE offers a promising solution to this problem.
The promising results on various datasets suggest that CONFINE could have significant applications in high-stakes domains like healthcare and finance, where both model accuracy and interpretability are essential. As AI systems become more widely deployed, techniques like CONFINE will be crucial for building trust and ensuring the responsible development of these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
CONFINE: Conformal Prediction for Interpretable Neural Networks
Linhui Huang, Sayeri Lala, Niraj K. Jha
Deep neural networks exhibit remarkable performance, yet their black-box nature limits their utility in fields like healthcare where interpretability is crucial. Existing explainability approaches often sacrifice accuracy and lack quantifiable measures of prediction uncertainty. In this study, we introduce Conformal Prediction for Interpretable Neural Networks (CONFINE), a versatile framework that generates prediction sets with statistically robust uncertainty estimates instead of point predictions to enhance model transparency and reliability. CONFINE not only provides example-based explanations and confidence estimates for individual predictions but also boosts accuracy by up to 3.6%. We define a new metric, correct efficiency, to evaluate the fraction of prediction sets that contain precisely the correct label and show that CONFINE achieves correct efficiency of up to 3.3% higher than the original accuracy, matching or exceeding prior methods. CONFINE's marginal and class-conditional coverages attest to its validity across tasks spanning medical image classification to language understanding. Being adaptable to any pre-trained classifier, CONFINE marks a significant advance towards transparent and trustworthy deep learning applications in critical domains.
Read more6/4/2024
📈
0
CONFIDERAI: a novel CONFormal Interpretable-by-Design score function for Explainable and Reliable Artificial Intelligence
Sara Narteni, Alberto Carlevaro, Fabrizio Dabbene, Marco Muselli, Maurizio Mongelli
Everyday life is increasingly influenced by artificial intelligence, and there is no question that machine learning algorithms must be designed to be reliable and trustworthy for everyone. Specifically, computer scientists consider an artificial intelligence system safe and trustworthy if it fulfills five pillars: explainability, robustness, transparency, fairness, and privacy. In addition to these five, we propose a sixth fundamental aspect: conformity, that is, the probabilistic assurance that the system will behave as the machine learner expects. In this paper, we present a methodology to link conformal prediction with explainable machine learning by defining a new score function for rule-based classifiers that leverages rules predictive ability, the geometrical position of points within rules boundaries and the overlaps among rules as well, thanks to the definition of a geometrical rule similarity term. Furthermore, we address the problem of defining regions in the feature space where conformal guarantees are satisfied, by exploiting the definition of conformal critical set and showing how this set can be used to achieve new rules with improved performance on the target class. The overall methodology is tested with promising results on several datasets of real-world interest, such as domain name server tunneling detection or cardiovascular disease prediction.
Read more6/6/2024
0
A conformalized learning of a prediction set with applications to medical imaging classification
Roy Hirsch, Jacob Goldberger
Medical imaging classifiers can achieve high predictive accuracy, but quantifying their uncertainty remains an unresolved challenge, which prevents their deployment in medical clinics. We present an algorithm that can modify any classifier to produce a prediction set containing the true label with a user-specified probability, such as 90%. We train a network to predict an instance-based version of the Conformal Prediction threshold. The threshold is then conformalized to ensure the required coverage. We applied the proposed algorithm to several standard medical imaging classification datasets. The experimental results demonstrate that our method outperforms current approaches in terms of smaller average size of the prediction set while maintaining the desired coverage.
Read more8/12/2024
0
Uncertainty Quantification of Pre-Trained and Fine-Tuned Surrogate Models using Conformal Prediction
Vignesh Gopakumar, Ander Gray, Joel Oskarsson, Lorenzo Zanisi, Stanislas Pamela, Daniel Giles, Matt Kusner, Marc Peter Deisenroth
Data-driven surrogate models have shown immense potential as quick, inexpensive approximations to complex numerical and experimental modelling tasks. However, most surrogate models characterising physical systems do not quantify their uncertainty, rendering their predictions unreliable, and needing further validation. Though Bayesian approximations offer some solace in estimating the error associated with these models, they cannot provide they cannot provide guarantees, and the quality of their inferences depends on the availability of prior information and good approximations to posteriors for complex problems. This is particularly pertinent to multi-variable or spatio-temporal problems. Our work constructs and formalises a conformal prediction framework that satisfies marginal coverage for spatio-temporal predictions in a model-agnostic manner, requiring near-zero computational costs. The paper provides an extensive empirical study of the application of the framework to ascertain valid error bars that provide guaranteed coverage across the surrogate model's domain of operation. The application scope of our work extends across a large range of spatio-temporal models, ranging from solving partial differential equations to weather forecasting. Through the applications, the paper looks at providing statistically valid error bars for deterministic models, as well as crafting guarantees to the error bars of probabilistic models. The paper concludes with a viable conformal prediction formalisation that provides guaranteed coverage of the surrogate model, regardless of model architecture, and its training regime and is unbothered by the curse of dimensionality.
Read more8/20/2024